View Single Post
look 171 look 171 is offline
Registered
 
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: Los Angeles
Posts: 13,770
Quote:
Originally Posted by masraum View Post
I watched this entire 9 part series. I think that's 4.5-5 hours. I don't plan to build this bench, and absolutely would not build it the way that he did (exclusively with hand tools), but I learned a ton of stuff.

One thing that I found interesting is that most of the stuff that I've watched or read about work benches as all about having the front of the bench flush (legs, apron, edge of top and the front face of the back jaw of the face clamp should all be on the same plane so that any part of the front of the bench can be used to clamp material. It makes sense to me, and I've seen how it could be useful. Also, most of what I've seen seems to like to have the face vise on the far left front end so it's out of the way (and with the front face of the rear jaw flush with the front of the table). Many designs also have the ends all flush so if you've got a tail vice, it's similar and can be used to clamp things to the end of the bench.

For his bench, the legs were set back, the front apron of the table has protruding bolt heads, the face vice is inside the legs which are not at the extreme ends so it's almost closer to offset from the center than it is to on the left end. The face vice is also out in front of the front edge of the bench.

I can understand how some folks like having a tool tray and some don't, but the other bits seem like great design plans.

Not the bench that he made in the video, but one that someone else built from the same plans.

I really do not understand that drop or step? It leaves such small work surface. If you are building furniture, fine, but anything else, More bench top is needed imo. No end vice is needed. If a piece is that long, I would just take a clamp and camp it to the bench. Its much faster to drag that long piece of lumber to the top, line it up and fetch a bench dog just to hold it in place. Its really an old fashion way of getting lumber flat or straighten. I suppose there's joy in that type of work. Its much easier to get S2S and straight line lumber and start making your project instead of having to mill it. Again, My stupid opinion.
Old 11-21-2020, 06:34 PM
  Pelican Parts Catalog | Tech Articles | Promos & Specials    Reply With Quote #158 (permalink)