Pelican Parts Forums

Pelican Parts Forums (http://forums.pelicanparts.com/)
-   911 Engine Rebuilding Forum (http://forums.pelicanparts.com/911-engine-rebuilding-forum/)
-   -   3.3 recommended piston ring gaps (http://forums.pelicanparts.com/911-engine-rebuilding-forum/1157389-3-3-recommended-piston-ring-gaps.html)

kamaro 02-12-2024 04:46 PM

3.3 recommended piston ring gaps
 
I got a low miles used 3.3 p&c set that are well with in the installation specs, Im using a set of new Mahle piston rings with them and right out of the box they all measured .016 for both top and 2nd rings, is that OK for a boosted 3.3? .. I'm planning to get close to 1 bar with that engine. Also since I'm using new rings, would you recommend de-glazing the cylinders with something like 400 or 600 grit?

Flat6pac 02-12-2024 05:40 PM

Deglaze with scotch brite and water with your hand.
600 grit is too coarse.
Bruce

Turbo_pro 02-12-2024 05:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by kamaro (Post 12193269)
I got a low miles used 3.3 p&c set that are well with in the installation specs, Im using a set of new Mahle piston rings with them and right out of the box they all measured .016 for both top and 2nd rings, is that OK for a boosted 3.3? .. I'm planning to get close to 1 bar with that engine. Also since I'm using new rings, would you recommend de-glazing the cylinders with something like 400 or 600 grit?

First, when I have the option, I always use the origin Goetze rings. The new Mahle rings are a cheaper product manufactured in Brazil.

.016" is too small.
I use the formula .006"x bore.
.006"x 3.8"=.0228" + or - .001 Basically .021 to .023"
The second ring should be .002" larger than the top ring. This allows the pressure that passes the top ring to escape unimpeded. If the second ring traps the compression, this will create pressure under the top ring that will damage the piston/ring land.

kamaro 02-13-2024 01:59 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Flat6pac (Post 12193294)
Deglaze with scotch brite and water with your hand.
600 grit is too coarse.
Bruce

I will do, I always trust your opinions, Bruce :D

Henry Schmidt 02-13-2024 03:52 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Turbo_pro (Post 12193299)
First, when I have the option, I always use the origin Goetze rings. The new Mahle rings are a cheaper product manufactured in Brazil.

.016" is too small.
I use the formula .006"x bore.
.006"x 3.8"=.0228" + or - .001 Basically .021 to .023"
The second ring should be .002" larger than the top ring. This allows the pressure that passes the top ring to escape unimpeded. If the second ring traps the compression, this will create pressure under the top ring that will damage the piston/ring land.

100% correct on all points.

kamaro 02-13-2024 04:06 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Turbo_pro (Post 12193299)
First, when I have the option, I always use the origin Goetze rings. The new Mahle rings are a cheaper product manufactured in Brazil.

.016" is too small.
I use the formula .006"x bore.
.006"x 3.8"=.0228" + or - .001 Basically .021 to .023"
The second ring should be .002" larger than the top ring. This allows the pressure that passes the top ring to escape unimpeded. If the second ring traps the compression, this will create pressure under the top ring that will damage the piston/ring land.

I already have the Mahle rings so I guess I will just use what I have, after all it is Mahle, so it must be at least "decent".

So is it safe to go with .020" for the first and .022" for 2nd? .. I just took my 3.2 apart and all rings were at .016" so I guess the turbo engines needs a bit more gap to be safe, right?

kamaro 02-13-2024 04:09 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Henry Schmidt (Post 12193394)
100% correct on all points.

I'm glad that you read my post, Henry, I really need your opinion here before I do a costly mistake, do I really have to throw away the Mahle rings and get Goetzes? .. I'm not looking to get 500+whp, just want a decent power out of a 3.3.

Henry Schmidt 02-13-2024 05:52 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by kamaro (Post 12193404)
I'm glad that you read my post, Henry, I really need your opinion here before I do a costly mistake, do I really have to throw away the Mahle rings and get Goetzes? .. I'm not looking to get 500+whp, just want a decent power out of a 3.3.

No, use what you have. They will be fine.
I think Jim was speaking to other builders looking to buy new rings. He didn't tell you to throw away your rings.

I really like the Goetze old school ring. I think it's an "old dog...new tricks" deal.
I even have custom pistons designed to utilize Goetze ring and you wouldn't believe the push-back I get from piston manufacturers.

kamaro 02-13-2024 05:54 AM

Happy to hear that :D .. thanks Henry

rudedude 02-13-2024 11:02 AM

Do you size naturally aspirated rings differently than turbocharged?

dannobee 02-13-2024 02:46 PM

NA engines don't need as much ring gap. If it's boosted, you'll need to add another 0.001" or so for each inch of bore because of the higher combustion temperatures.

As we used to say...

Big ring gap = big catch can

Small ring gap = big trash can

Tippy 02-13-2024 07:03 PM

I run my gaps looooooose now as I had them too tight during 1st rebuild and tore up the Nikasil and Total Seal rings.

Very costly mistake!!

No blowby after refresh.

kamaro 02-14-2024 04:34 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tippy (Post 12193858)
I run my gaps looooooose now as I had them too tight during 1st rebuild and tore up the Nikasil and Total Seal rings.

Very costly mistake!!

No blowby after refresh.

could you please share your before/after end gaps? .. I care of knowing about some real-time tests.

gsxrken 02-14-2024 07:53 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by kamaro (Post 12193952)
could you please share your before/after end gaps? .. I care of knowing about some real-time tests.

I’d like to know too. I assume Total Seal rings have a different spec if they’re gap-less ones but maybe they make standard ones too?

Tippy 02-20-2024 09:09 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by kamaro (Post 12193952)
could you please share your before/after end gaps? .. I care of knowing about some real-time tests.

I don’t remember the exact gaps (written down somewhere) but I chose gaps for 30 PSI/2 bar of boost.

porschedude996 02-25-2024 06:57 PM

What are the differences between the standard ring Mahle uses and the Goetze rings?


Quote:

Originally Posted by Henry Schmidt (Post 12193458)
No, use what you have. They will be fine.
I think Jim was speaking to other builders looking to buy new rings. He didn't tell you to throw away your rings.

I really like the Goetze old school ring. I think it's an "old dog...new tricks" deal.
I even have custom pistons designed to utilize Goetze ring and you wouldn't believe the push-back I get from piston manufacturers.


Henry Schmidt 02-25-2024 09:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by porschedude996 (Post 12201408)
What are the differences between the standard ring Mahle uses and the Goetze rings?

For years Mahle used Goetze rings. Economics dictated a change so Mahle started using rings made in Brazil. Made in Germany vs made in Brazil....seems an easy choice.
The difference would be design, materials and coatings. My guess, Goetze has proprietary processes.
I still believe that quality exists inexperience, and reputations are built on quality.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 12:59 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.6.0
Copyright 2025 Pelican Parts, LLC - Posts may be archived for display on the Pelican Parts Website


DTO Garage Plus vBulletin Plugins by Drive Thru Online, Inc.