Pelican Parts Forums

Pelican Parts Forums (http://forums.pelicanparts.com/)
-   911 Engine Rebuilding Forum (http://forums.pelicanparts.com/911-engine-rebuilding-forum/)
-   -   Dont trust new trw valves (http://forums.pelicanparts.com/911-engine-rebuilding-forum/1158504-dont-trust-new-trw-valves.html)

Dpmulvan 03-07-2024 01:10 PM

Dont trust new trw valves
 
Just opened 6 brand new trw exhaust valves every single one is below Porsche wear limit of 8.938. Can’t wait for intakes to show up tomorrow!!!! Yay more wasted time and headaches.

Dpmulvan 03-09-2024 08:06 AM

Intakes came yesterday from our host all checked out fine. I got exhaust valves from another source, they didn’t come with boxes and I see trw has added a hologram to their boxes for authenticity. Wonder if I got some Chinese exhaust valves? Very interesting.

Cloggie 03-09-2024 02:34 PM

....very interesting. I have a set of new TRW valves from literally 15 years ago, all in the box.

When I redid my heads, I did not trust their sourcing well enough to risk using them so the head rebuilder put in nice Porsche valves which hopefully were better.

I guess I ought to measure them and see if they are decorations or really even contenders for use/sale.

D.

Dpmulvan 03-10-2024 07:28 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cloggie (Post 12210022)
....very interesting. I have a set of new TRW valves from literally 15 years ago, all in the box.

When I redid my heads, I did not trust their sourcing well enough to risk using them so the head rebuilder put in nice Porsche valves which hopefully were better.

I guess I ought to measure them and see if they are decorations or really even contenders for use/sale.

D.

Porsche valves here on pelican are $210 a piece, I’m not spending $2000 plus on valves
Ridiculous.

Dpmulvan 03-10-2024 07:39 AM

So TRW valves are made in Thailand WTF. Left is pelican TRW valve 2 in a box made in Thailand, right are exhaust valves I sourced elsewhere no box all out of spec. I’m sick and tired of trying to figure out who’s being honest and who is selling me junk under false pretenses.
http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1710085148.jpg

Dpmulvan 03-10-2024 07:41 AM

I should weigh them just for the hell of it.

Cloggie 03-10-2024 07:48 AM

If it will help, I will dig out my old TRW's and check them for dimensions...if they are any good, happy to sell them to you...I certainly do not need them.

D.

Dpmulvan 03-10-2024 07:54 AM

What did you do to your heads?? Twin plugged, Ported, polished, titanium valve retainers, new seats oh and I almost forget THAI INTAKE VALVES and CHINESE EXHAUST VALVES!!!!! AWESOOOOOOOMMMMEE.
Better check your Wiener schnitzel, make sure there’s no Kung Pao Chicken in it.

PeteKz 03-10-2024 04:44 PM

Yeah, sourcing is getting to be a real crap shoot. That said, I wouldn't discount TRW valves made in Thailand out of hand. Like Bosch parts made in India, it very much depends on the manufacturing process and whether the parent company enforces adequate quality controls.

If the TRW valves are marginally undersize, you also could instruct your head rebuilder to ream the new guides to fit the valves, which they should do anyway. Much like honing cylinders to fit the pistons.

ahh911 03-10-2024 05:37 PM

Dpmulvan,


Please take a good look at the stem head interface. I bought one cheap TRW for lapping and that interface was offset (Stem was not centered on head). The valves the machinist bought were perfect, they were TRW but much more expensive...
This was roughly in 2019. There was clearly a difference in quality which I did not appreciate at the time until I compared both (expensive TRW with cheap TRW, both had the same part number!).

Phil

Dpmulvan 03-11-2024 07:28 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by PeteKz (Post 12210636)
Yeah, sourcing is getting to be a real crap shoot. That said, I wouldn't discount TRW valves made in Thailand out of hand. Like Bosch parts made in India, it very much depends on the manufacturing process and whether the parent company enforces adequate quality controls.

If the TRW valves are marginally undersize, you also could instruct your head rebuilder to ream the new guides to fit the valves, which they should do anyway. Much like honing cylinders to fit the pistons.

Pete,
I have the machines to do my own heads and I thought about that but I’m not going to remove perfectly good valve guides so I can install POS valves. These valves aren’t even close and thickness varies up and down the shafts. I’m just wondering how they get away with selling this crap? Are people just slapping them in or what??

Dpmulvan 03-11-2024 07:29 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ahh911 (Post 12210664)
Dpmulvan,


Please take a good look at the stem head interface. I bought one cheap TRW for lapping and that interface was offset (Stem was not centered on head). The valves the machinist bought were perfect, they were TRW but much more expensive...
This was roughly in 2019. There was clearly a difference in quality which I did not appreciate at the time until I compared both (expensive TRW with cheap TRW, both had the same part number!).

Phil

Phil,
Thanks for the heads up.

PeteKz 03-12-2024 12:07 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dpmulvan (Post 12210903)
Pete,
I have the machines to do my own heads and I thought about that but I’m not going to remove perfectly good valve guides so I can install POS valves. These valves aren’t even close and thickness varies up and down the shafts. I’m just wondering how they get away with selling this crap? Are people just slapping them in or what??

in that case, I wouldn't pull out the guides either. The more I think about it, the more I think I would just reject them and try another source.

Dpmulvan 03-12-2024 07:45 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by PeteKz (Post 12211410)
in that case, I wouldn't pull out the guides either. The more I think about it, the more I think I would just reject them and try another source.

To top it all off I fill out a form for a return and they tell me I have 5 days to get them back or they won’t honor return. It took them 10 days to ship them to me.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 06:34 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.6.0
Copyright 2025 Pelican Parts, LLC - Posts may be archived for display on the Pelican Parts Website


DTO Garage Plus vBulletin Plugins by Drive Thru Online, Inc.