Pelican Parts Forums

Pelican Parts Forums (http://forums.pelicanparts.com/)
-   Off Topic Discussions (http://forums.pelicanparts.com/off-topic-discussions/)
-   -   Anyone spoken to or understand holocaust deniers? (http://forums.pelicanparts.com/off-topic-discussions/1006776-anyone-spoken-understand-holocaust-deniers.html)

red-beard 09-03-2018 10:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sc_rufctr (Post 10166620)
This has been my experience.

A long time ago a Skin head (complete with Nazi tattoos on his head & neck) tried to convince me that it would be impossible to kill 6,000,000 Jews.

I said what about the other 5,000,000? (11,000,000 total were murdered in the Nazi concentration camps)

Hitler was a lot worse than most people realize.
Even when he knew Germany would loose the war he continued making no attempt to stop the slaughter.

"We" often forget that the German people suffered horribly because of the Hitler and the Nazis.

It has been studied that tremendous resources were diverted from the war effort. The idea of moving 11M people (and I think it was higher) using 1930's rail. All of those resources could have been used to move men and material. Also, if Hitler embraced the Jews, he would have had all of the key physicists. Germany didn't have the money to develop the bomb, but without all of the talent, we would not.

red-beard 09-03-2018 10:39 PM

My next door neighbors growing up both escaped from Europe before WWII. One from Austria and the other from the Czech republic. The Czech woman also had to escape from Paris as Germany ripped across France.

petrolhead611 09-04-2018 12:12 AM

My grandparents survived Belsen, by a miracle,( the actuality well documented in a book that I have copy of).My father escaped Germany in 1938, but went back to Berlin in 1945 to round up and interrogate Nazis( every one of whom denied any guilt and had no remorse whatsoever).The German government eventually paid restitution to victims : they would not have done so if there hadn't been a Holocaust.
Most Germans happily received Jewish property,, businesses, and possessions stolen from the Jews, so we're guilty of receiving stolen property if nothing else( in fact they all knew what was going on even if they denied it after the war.

tabs 09-04-2018 01:07 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by red-beard (Post 10166816)
It has been studied that tremendous resources were diverted from the war effort. The idea of moving 11M people (and I think it was higher) using 1930's rail. All of those resources could have been used to move men and material. Also, if Hitler embraced the Jews, he would have had all of the key physicists. Germany didn't have the money to develop the bomb, but without all of the talent, we would not.

I see you slept through the day you studied Ww2 in your history class.

John Toland came up with 4.8M Jews. It all comes down to what groups and what causes do you want to include in the number. The number of dead in Ww2 is estimated at 60m to 80m. As the walls started closing in on the Reich in 44 they actually sped up the processing of the Jews.

red-beard 09-04-2018 03:09 AM

Tabs, best data I've read is closer to 15M in death camps, including Roma Gypsies and other undesirables. 60M might. combine all deaths in all theaters.

Funny, since nuclear weapons, no big death tolls in war. Murder by govt, but not war.

jcommin 09-04-2018 03:41 AM

When my youngest was in the 8th grade, there was a girl who was raised in Indonesia he was friends with. She was a mixed race kid a very pretty girl. My son had a few friends over the house having pizza - 8th grade stuff. The subject of Muslim extremism came up. The girl, who was raised Muslim, asks a question " do you know what Jewish extremism is?" She then responds " it is a bunch of Jews that complain a few died during WWII." My wife is Jewish, my children are raised in Judaism, I'm not Jewish. My wife's jaw dropped! "Do you know this is a Jewish household she asks?" there was no reply and she never came over again.

Denial, hate, prejudice is taught - you can't stop that.

sc_rufctr 09-04-2018 04:33 AM

"it is a bunch of Jews that complain a few died during WWII." There's the problem.

That's a sad story Jim.

masraum 09-04-2018 04:37 AM

So it sounds like they are mostly other extremists, not crazies or conspiracy theorists (well, yes, but), and this fits in with their extremism.

I guess that makes sense.

sc_rufctr 09-04-2018 04:43 AM

It's an anti Jew thing... IMO people who don't like Jews are more likely to deny the Holocaust.

GH85Carrera 09-04-2018 05:06 AM

One question I was asked once by a kid, just WHY do so many people hate the Jews?

I did not have an answer except that when left alone they seem to be the business owners and bankers.

Muslims have for thousands of years promoted slavery, and the killing of the non Muslims of the world and want to run the world under Sharia law. That is something for all of us to fear. The US Navy was created to combat Muslim slave ships.

tabs 09-04-2018 09:19 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by red-beard (Post 10166888)
Tabs, best data I've read is closer to 15M in death camps, including Roma Gypsies and other undesirables. 60M might. combine all deaths in all theaters.

Funny, since nuclear weapons, no big death tolls in war. Murder by govt, but not war.

Did you ever hear of Einstatz Gruppen, Ghetto' s or the Latvian among others? 3m of the included were Russian pows that were starved or worked to death. Communists in Russia were also taken care of as part of the processing.

A good portion and or most of the killing was done outside of the death camps. It was only one means of processing Jews. They only came into being in mid 42 after The Wansee confrence. The industrialization of genocide.

The Concentration Camps date to the mid 30's and were first used for political prisoners or enemies of the state. Later came the slave Labour and death camps (in Poland).

Poland suffered about 5m deaths. 3m Jews and 2m ethnic Poles.

The Russians after liberating their own Pows amd slave labour shot them or a majority of them were sent to the Gulags. The woman prisoners were raped or murdered by their own as well.

tabs 09-04-2018 09:43 AM

Eichmans job was the organization and transporting of the Jews to the processing and rendering plants in Poland. He was always complaing that the trains from France were never full. It seems that the French, Wermacht and even SS were none too keen on rounding up French Jews, mostly relying on refugee Jews to pack off to the processing in the East.

Russians Jews and Communists were processed on site mostly with bullets and carbon monoxide vans of the Einstatz Gruppen. In Poland the Jews were rounded up and put into Ghettos where they where famine and disease took care of the problem. The Latvians to the Germans surprise showed even more zeal in processing Jews than they did.Then came the slave Labour camps where famine, disease and over work killed millions.

Later (1953) it was only Stalin's death that prevented his plans for the purging of the Jews in Russia from taking place.

Por_sha911 09-04-2018 10:09 AM

To be clear, of the number of people killed by the Nazi hate machine, only half were Jews. The numbers vary depending on who you talk with but I have heard and go by 6 million Jews and then another 5 million others. This included Christians (any anyone who stood against the Nazis), Roma gypsies, and all people who had a disability of any kind.

Hitler put all his eggs in one lunatic basket. He gained power and united the German people upon the foundation of a pure Aryan race that would create a super-power nation. As we know in life, to have a hero, there has to be an enemy. Hitler chose the Jews as the enemy of the people. His system spent a huge amount of money eliminating the Jews but he also stole property, bank accounts, jewelry (even gold filings), art, and slave labor to make up for it. The one place he couldn't offset his loses was in the brain drain of scientists who fled and businesses and workers who quietly did less than their best (a la Schindler).

Not all Germans were Nazis. Some feared reprisal and quietly went along. Sadly, IMO, Dr. Porsche is in this group. Others who were vocal were silenced by force or simply "disappeared". Everyone knew what was happening. The ones in denial put on their rose colored glasses and ignored the elephant in the room.

sammyg2 09-04-2018 11:14 AM

Quote:

Anyone spoken to or understand holocaust deniers?
Never met one who would admit it, but then again I'm particular in whom I associate with.

Lots O'crazies out there that need to believe in UFO, bigfoot, lock ness, etc.
Mental illness.

EDIT: I have met one douche who denied that Unit 731 was real.
The US gubmint did the same thing after WWII. They shoulda all been hung. The gubmint I mean.
Oh and the war criminals too.


Quote:

Instead of being tried for war crimes after the war, the researchers involved in Unit 731 were secretly given immunity by the U.S. in exchange for the data they gathered through human experimentation.[5] Other researchers that the Soviet forces managed to arrest first were tried at the Khabarovsk War Crime Trials in 1949. The Americans did not try the researchers so that the information and experience gained in bio-weapons could be co-opted into the U.S. biological warfare program, as had happened with Nazi researchers in Operation Paperclip.[6] On 6 May 1947, Douglas MacArthur, as Supreme Commander of the Allied Forces, wrote to Washington that "additional data, possibly some statements from Ishii probably can be obtained by informing Japanese involved that information will be retained in intelligence channels and will not be employed as 'War Crimes' evidence".[5] Victim accounts were then largely ignored or dismissed in the West as communist propaganda.[7]

RANDY P 09-04-2018 11:22 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DaveE (Post 10166536)
I argued with a holocaust denier in a Topix forum once. That place is almost as bad as PARF.

Which means you just convinced someone new it never happened SmileWavy

rjp

RANDY P 09-04-2018 11:23 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sammyg2 (Post 10167492)
Never met one who would admit it, but then again I'm particular in whom I associate with.

Lots O'crazies out there that need to believe in UFO, bigfoot, lock ness, etc.
Mental illness.

EDIT: I have met one douche who denied that Unit 731 was real.

I've run across skinheads who deny it, some militant Muslim / black power groups as well. Mostly one-off stuff, that kind of thing.

rjp

tabs 09-04-2018 01:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Por_sha911 (Post 10167388)
To be clear, of the number of people killed by the Nazi hate machine, only half were Jews. The numbers vary depending on who you talk with but I have heard and go by 6 million Jews and then another 5 million others. This included Christians (any anyone who stood against the Nazis), Roma gypsies, and all people who had a disability of any kind.

Hitler put all his eggs in one lunatic basket. He gained power and united the German people upon the foundation of a pure Aryan race that would create a super-power nation. As we know in life, to have a hero, there has to be an enemy. Hitler chose the Jews as the enemy of the people. His system spent a huge amount of money eliminating the Jews but he also stole property, bank accounts, jewelry (even gold filings), art, and slave labor to make up for it. The one place he couldn't offset his loses was in the brain drain of scientists who fled and businesses and workers who quietly did less than their best (a la Schindler).

Not all Germans were Nazis. Some feared reprisal and quietly went along. Sadly, IMO, Dr. Porsche is in this group. Others who were vocal were silenced by force or simply "disappeared". Everyone knew what was happening. The ones in denial put on their rose colored glasses and ignored the elephant in the room.

Reinhard Heydrich was the guy who was instrumental in setting up the Concentration Camps (including Death Camps after the Wansee Conference) and coalescing power unto the SS and Gestapo secret police mechanism as being able to declare you an enemy of the state. Hitler once said that, "Heydrich was cold hearted." Yet Heydrich saved Jewish athletes and once said that if Hitler started to lose the war that he would eliminate Hitler.

The Europeans needed little prompting in processing the Jews as they were almost universally hated everywhere. . It seems that nobody likes God's chosen people. So it being a Nazi hate machine is laughable

Arizona_928 09-04-2018 01:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tabs (Post 10167678)
Reinhard Heydrich was the guy who was instrumental in setting up the Concentration Camps (including Death Camps after the Wansee Conference) and coalescing power unto the SS and Gestapo secret police mechanism as being able to declare you an enemy of the state. Hitler once said that, "Heydrich was cold hearted." Yet Heydrich saved Jewish athletes and once said that if Hitler started to lose the war that he would eliminate Hitler.

The Europeans needed little prompting in processing the Jews as they were almost universally hated everywhere. . It seems that nobody likes God's chosen people. So it being a Nazi hate machine is laughable

Share some more random facts!


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 09:09 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.6.0
Copyright 2025 Pelican Parts, LLC - Posts may be archived for display on the Pelican Parts Website


DTO Garage Plus vBulletin Plugins by Drive Thru Online, Inc.