Pelican Parts Forums

Pelican Parts Forums (http://forums.pelicanparts.com/)
-   Off Topic Discussions (http://forums.pelicanparts.com/off-topic-discussions/)
-   -   GMC Transmission -- Failure at Speed! (http://forums.pelicanparts.com/off-topic-discussions/1026716-gmc-transmission-failure-speed.html)

stomachmonkey 04-15-2019 08:55 AM

Don't over complicate this.

The 4L60E and 70E are solid units. The only really common failure is the Sun Gear and everyone that rebuilds them upgrades the Sun shell and does the Vette servo pack upgrade. They add virtually nothing to the cost, it's like an extra $25.00 in parts cost so stupid to not address them.

Unless the weather is inclement where you are this is a driveway job.

Figure 4 hours for the swap.

https://www.jegs.com/i/JEGS+Performance+Products/555/603026/10002/-1?mrkgcl=1239&mrkgadid=3333715648&adpos=1o3&creati ve=330726016739&device=c&matchtype=&network=g&gcli d=EAIaIQobChMIktu_wLnS4QIV8ZFbCh3-pAEYEAQYAyABEgKKGPD_BwE

https://www.monstertransmission.com/4L60E4L70E-Transmission-Heavy-Duty-2WD-2006-2009-Merch-Purple_p_12288.html?gclid=EAIaIQobChMIktu_wLnS4QIV 8ZFbCh3-pAEYEAQYASABEgJTv_D_BwE#.XLSqEnaZ124

That tranny will last another 200k at least.

EDIT: toss in a new converter cause, you're already in there.

VincentVega 04-15-2019 09:00 AM

4hrs? I'm still soaking rusty bolts at that point :)

agree this can be straight forward

stomachmonkey 04-15-2019 09:14 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by VincentVega (Post 10427621)
4hrs? I'm still soaking rusty bolts at that point :)

agree this can be straight forward

My trucks been in TX for the last 11 years.

No road salts to screw **** up.

speeder 04-15-2019 09:59 AM

The shop I use is in Hollywood and has been in business for decades, family owned. There are many others. They are a transmission only shop and they R&R transmissions and rebuild them all day long. Reasonable prices.

I know how to remove a transmission from a car or truck and have done it countless times. It's a no-brainer to have them do it instead. I've actually reached the point in my life where I will gladly pay someone else a couple hundred dollars rather than bench-press an automatic transmission into a vehicle on the ground in my driveway. Call me crazy. I know how to dig a ditch and I could probably bring my own trash to the landfill, some things you gladly pay for in life.:)

Have it towed to a good transmission shop and pick it up the next day w basically a new transmission w a warranty. Automatic transmissions are wear items, (at least the parts inside are), they do not last forever. This is a normal vehicle owner experience. Any talk about putting a transmission from another vehicle in it is not very smart, IMO. Just fix it and go.

fastfredracing 04-15-2019 10:48 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by stomachmonkey (Post 10427615)
Don't over complicate this.

The 4L60E and 70E are solid units. The only really common failure is the Sun Gear and everyone that rebuilds them upgrades the Sun shell and does the Vette servo pack upgrade. They add virtually nothing to the cost, it's like an extra $25.00 in parts cost so stupid to not address them.

Unless the weather is inclement where you are this is a driveway job.

Figure 4 hours for the swap.

https://www.jegs.com/i/JEGS+Performance+Products/555/603026/10002/-1?mrkgcl=1239&mrkgadid=3333715648&adpos=1o3&creati ve=330726016739&device=c&matchtype=&network=g&gcli d=EAIaIQobChMIktu_wLnS4QIV8ZFbCh3-pAEYEAQYAyABEgKKGPD_BwE

https://www.monstertransmission.com/4L60E4L70E-Transmission-Heavy-Duty-2WD-2006-2009-Merch-Purple_p_12288.html?gclid=EAIaIQobChMIktu_wLnS4QIV 8ZFbCh3-pAEYEAQYASABEgJTv_D_BwE#.XLSqEnaZ124

That tranny will last another 200k at least.

EDIT: toss in a new converter cause, you're already in there.

I think you are off on the hours there . Book pays 8.8. Id be happy to have one out and sitting on the bench in 4 hours.
You've done this in your driveway? 4x4 with a transfer case ?

Racerbvd 04-15-2019 11:09 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by speeder (Post 10427697)
The shop I use is in Hollywood and has been in business for decades, family owned. There are many others. They are a transmission only shop and they R&R transmissions and rebuild them all day long. Reasonable prices.

I know how to remove a transmission from a car or truck and have done it countless times. It's a no-brainer to have them do it instead. I've actually reached the point in my life where I will gladly pay someone else a couple hundred dollars rather than bench-press an automatic transmission into a vehicle on the ground in my driveway. Call me crazy. I know how to dig a ditch and I could probably bring my own trash to the landfill, some things you gladly pay for in life.:)

Have it towed to a good transmission shop and pick it up the next day w basically a new transmission w a warranty. Automatic transmissions are wear items, (at least the parts inside are), they do not last forever. This is a normal vehicle owner experience. Any talk about putting a transmission from another vehicle in it is not very smart, IMO. Just fix it and go.

I'm with Dennis, did this with my 2500 Suburban 4X4 a few years back.

JackDidley 04-15-2019 11:21 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by speeder (Post 10427697)
The shop I use is in Hollywood and has been in business for decades, family owned. There are many others. They are a transmission only shop and they R&R transmissions and rebuild them all day long. Reasonable prices.

I know how to remove a transmission from a car or truck and have done it countless times. It's a no-brainer to have them do it instead. I've actually reached the point in my life where I will gladly pay someone else a couple hundred dollars rather than bench-press an automatic transmission into a vehicle on the ground in my driveway. Call me crazy. I know how to dig a ditch and I could probably bring my own trash to the landfill, some things you gladly pay for in life.:)

Have it towed to a good transmission shop and pick it up the next day w basically a new transmission w a warranty. Automatic transmissions are wear items, (at least the parts inside are), they do not last forever. This is a normal vehicle owner experience. Any talk about putting a transmission from another vehicle in it is not very smart, IMO. Just fix it and go.



Speeder knows how to pick his battles. At 66 years old I have to do this. Yes I will R&R the trans in my truck. It is easier than most. I paid someone to do the clutch in my Cayman. He has a lift and I do not. I do not feel like I have to do everything myself.

piscator 04-15-2019 12:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by stomachmonkey (Post 10427615)
Don't over complicate this.

The 4L60E and 70E are solid units. The only really common failure is the Sun Gear and everyone that rebuilds them upgrades the Sun shell and does the Vette servo pack upgrade. They add virtually nothing to the cost, it's like an extra $25.00 in parts cost so stupid to not address them.

Unless the weather is inclement where you are this is a driveway job.

Figure 4 hours for the swap.


That tranny will last another 200k at least.

EDIT: toss in a new converter cause, you're already in there.

Thanks Stomach! I'm certainly in favor of not over-complicating! I appreciate your letting me know the corvette servo and Sunshell is a common upgrade.

I'm just starting to learn what some of these things are and appreciate everyone's input. It's helping me gain an understanding of AT's.

It's likely that I'll use a local rebuilder and have my mechanic friend do the drop and install. Even though I'm comfortable doing that part and have the equipment, I think my time is better spent getting the Porsche back together.

However, FYI, I spoke to the owner of Performa transmission and he was very helpful. Since my truck is 4WD/AWD he recommended this version:

https://www.performabuilt.com/product/heavy-hauler-4l60e/

At $2895, this transmission may be more than I need, but I do trailer a heavy lobster boat a few times a year. Anyway, it gives me a benchmark for comparison. JEGs offers a 4WD 4L60E transmission restored a company named Hughes. Price is $2995.

I learn something new every day, I guess. Thanks again!

e

stomachmonkey 04-15-2019 12:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by fastfredracing (Post 10427759)
I think you are off on the hours there . Book pays 8.8. Id be happy to have one out and sitting on the bench in 4 hours.
You've done this in your driveway? 4x4 with a transfer case ?

I've done 4x4 with transfer cases in the driveway, have not done this particular vehicle because I'm old and I have no appetite for it anymore. Last time I did anything under "The Hoe" was to drop the tank, that was enough to convince me to shop out the tranny.

Anyway, that was the labor hours from my shop, but, it's all the shop does all day every day so agreed, not a good benchmark for what it would take a shade tree wrench. The OP and me, not you.

VincentVega 04-15-2019 12:43 PM

Lots of good info out there, I have this bookmarked for reference. The tables layout common weaknesses pretty simply.

https://www.gmtransmissionparts.com/700r4-4l60e-4l65e-rebuild-kit-buyers-guide/

speeder 04-15-2019 01:37 PM

This is my place:
 
In case anyone in L.A. needs a good transmission shop. Family owned, unfortunately the father died a couple years ago and now it's just his son, John and an excellent mechanic/technician. They do it all, you just tow the broken buggy to them and pick it up a day or two later, rebuilt w warranty.

I can't see the need to have one mechanic R&R trans and another rebuild it but if you need to(?)

Interesting that he has one terrible Yelp review but you need to weigh it against all of the others, which are almost unanimously positive. Makes you wonder about the other side of the story on that guy.

https://maps.apple.com/place?address=6020%20Santa%20Monica%20Blvd%2C%20Lo s%20Angeles%2C%20CA%20%2090038%2C%20United%20State s&auid=2069221577293693919&ll=34.0905903%2C-118.320839&q=Choi%27s%20Transmission%20Center

908/930 04-15-2019 03:05 PM

Is it not shifting past 3rd or is it staying locked in 3rd?

Bob Kontak 04-15-2019 03:14 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 908/930 (Post 10428108)
Is it not shifting past 3rd or is it staying locked in 3rd?

Now that's where a higher end scanner would be beneficial on a little road trip.

Trans module or ECU may indicate 4th.

Arizona_928 04-15-2019 03:23 PM

Doesn't GM offer a new crate trans that is back compatable with the 4l60's??

I would go local route as well. I would hate to get a doa unit

piscator 04-15-2019 04:03 PM

Bob, 908, Not shifting past third

wdfifteen 04-15-2019 05:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by fastfredracing (Post 10427759)
I think you are off on the hours there . Book pays 8.8. Id be happy to have one out and sitting on the bench in 4 hours.
You've done this in your driveway? 4x4 with a transfer case ?

PFFT. I had them out, changed the clutch packs and torque converter clutch, flushed the valve body, and had them back in and running while the case was still warm.
Of course they were mounted at waist height in a test cell that had a trolley to wheel engines and transmissions in and out. :D

fastfredracing 04-15-2019 05:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by wdfifteen (Post 10428241)
PFFT. I had them out, changed the clutch packs and torque converter clutch, flushed the valve body, and had them back in and running while the case was still warm.
Of course they were mounted at waist height in a test cell that had a trolley to wheel engines and transmissions in and out. :D

When I was a youn un, I was an R@R and tear down guy at a transmission shop . We had no lifts, and those guys were faaast.
I was young and green, but they whipped me into shape pretty quickly .
I think my best time out was like 27 minutes , for a rear drive full size chevrlolet car. Out and on the bench. We had 2 creepers, one to lay on, and another full of all the tools you needed . I remember like it was yesterday. Battery,shift linkage , driveshaft . starter, flywheeel cover, flywheel bolts, lines, remove all bell bolts, except 2,put the trans jack under it, pull crossmember, remaining 2 bell bolts, and on the ground.
Id pull one monday morning, tear it down and clean all the parts, then the rebuilder would get it . I would usuallly be putting it back in the next afternoon. We also had units on the shelf ready to go. We would buy up cores, and rebuild them on slow days.
I sometimes miss those days and the constant smell of burnt trans fluid . .

Bob Kontak 04-15-2019 06:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by fastfredracing (Post 10428267)
I think my best time out was like 27 minutes

I got one decent transmission story.

Pal in Anchorage with a maybe 1979 Rabbit needing a clutch. 1988-ish.

He had it all ready to go. Just chickin' to pull it.

Got under it and dropped it on my chest. All 80 pounds.

I was Batman.

Bob Kontak 04-15-2019 07:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by piscator (Post 10428175)
Bob, 908, Not shifting past third

I think we get that. ECU may say you are in fourth even though the vehicle cannot mechanically do that.

piscator 04-16-2019 08:04 AM

Gentlemen, here’s where things stand

My mechanic agrees that this transmission needs replacement. Labor charge is $1,045

GM Factory Remanufactured 4L60E is $2,525

https://www.gmpartsonline.net/oem-parts/gm-transmission-89037492

Performabuilt ‘Heavy Hauler’ upgraded 4L60E with Corvette Servo, heavy duty ‘Sun Shell,’ etc., etc. – $2,895

https://www.performabuilt.com/product/heavy-hauler-4l60e/

My question is, should I opt for an upgraded 4L60E or go with factory stock? I realize that I can get better pricing on comparable transmissions, but price is not my main concern, at this moment. I’d just appreciate hearing if you would go for the upgraded unit – StomachMonkey?

I need to make a decision on this and will certainly appreciate your continued guidance. As always, you guys are great!


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 04:46 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.6.0
Copyright 2025 Pelican Parts, LLC - Posts may be archived for display on the Pelican Parts Website


DTO Garage Plus vBulletin Plugins by Drive Thru Online, Inc.