Pelican Parts Forums

Pelican Parts Forums (http://forums.pelicanparts.com/)
-   Off Topic Discussions (http://forums.pelicanparts.com/off-topic-discussions/)
-   -   Drone counter measures (http://forums.pelicanparts.com/off-topic-discussions/1160580-drone-counter-measures.html)

Tobra 04-20-2024 04:13 AM

Drone counter measures
 
I saw a story about drones flying around a suburban neighborhood, the cop they interviewed talked about the number of reports, did not find operator, which would be tough to do. Could be benign, maybe nefarious. I got to thinking, best I could come up with is a pressure washer to knock it down, laser to blind it maybe. Getting into falconry is too much, I was thinking more along the lines of Macgyver using the stuff in the shed.

Seahawk 04-20-2024 04:25 AM

Good synonym here:

https://www.usatoday.com/story/tech/columnist/komando/2023/02/09/how-legally-avoid-drone-surveillance-around-your-private-property/11205343002/

Arizona_928 04-20-2024 04:49 AM

Quote:


The FAA legally protects drones from being:

• Shot at: Firing a gun into the sky is dangerous and illegal. Just don’t do it.

• Interfered physically: This includes lasers and other objects.

• Disabled or otherwise tampered with: Using a jammer and hacking are criminal acts.

So they’re allowed to operate with impunity…

Wait until they start strapping rpg’s to the front like in Ukraine…

Arizona_928 04-20-2024 04:52 AM

Based on the videos out of Ukraine.

Using your drone to knock out the other drone is a thing. Nets. Jammers (https://tass.com/defense/1694687)…

Seahawk 04-20-2024 05:11 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Arizona_928 (Post 12235278)
So they’re allowed to operate with impunity…

I didn't make the rules!

We have teamed with a company in Huntsville (Army guys) and are working three counter drone efforts. We do the drone, they do the sensors/countermeasures.

We are also working a cheap, armed ducted fan drone for a one way flight.

It is serious.

KNS 04-20-2024 05:40 AM

If you buy a drone these days you are required to register it. There is now an app (more than one, I think) which you can use to look up to see who’s flying outside your kitchen window. With that info you report them to the authorities.

Problem is tons of people are buying drones and not registering them. But the app is a place to start.

DavidI 04-20-2024 05:44 AM

Once drones are in-flight, they are aircraft and have the same protection as any other aircraft such as a small plane or commercial airplane. As crazy as it sounds, shooting at one would be the same punishment as shooting at one of these. In addition, they are extremely difficult to hit. We attempted this at various ranges and even the best shooters were unsuccessful. Some companies make a net-type round fired from shotguns to entangle the blades, but this has to be done at close range.

In addition, if you were successful in either taking control of the drone by electronic means or physical means, you become responsible for the results if it crashes and injures someone or destroys property.

The military has methods of dealing with them, but not the civilian population.

jyl 04-20-2024 05:56 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DavidI (Post 12235312)
Once drones are in-flight, they are aircraft and have the same protection as any other aircraft such as a small plane or commercial airplane. As crazy as it sounds, shooting at one would be the same punishment as shooting at one of these. In addition, they are extremely difficult to hit. We attempted this at various ranges and even the best shooters were unsuccessful. Some companies make a net-type round fired from shotguns to entangle the blades, but this has to be done at close range.

In addition, if you were successful in either taking control of the drone by electronic means or physical means, you become responsible for the results if it crashes and injures someone or destroys property.

The military has methods of dealing with them, but not the civilian population.

Ooo, tell us more. What ranges, what loads used? Why are they so hard to hit (other than the obvious).

GH85Carrera 04-20-2024 05:58 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Arizona_928 (Post 12235278)
So they’re allowed to operate with impunity…

Wait until they start strapping rpg’s to the front like in Ukraine…

Talk to the FAA. They "own" the skis in the USA and make the rules governing any "aircraft" from drones to the airlines and even hot air balloons and model rockets that get above a few hundred feet.

As an aerial photographer, unless there is a TFR (temporary flight restriction) or a restricted airspace like area 51, and places like the Ft. Sill artillery practice range, we can fly over it. We have mapped several airports even USAF bases and Army bases. Even the FAA facility itself.

We had one client that is in the waste water disposal business. He was looking to buy a competitor that was wanting to sell, but would not allow anyone on the property to see the operation. We flew the competitors site and our client could see the various dirt moving equipment, and the evaporation ponds. It let him know what that business was worth.

We were flying another site that was next to a nuclear power plant. Our airplane had to fly directly over the power plant to make turns. A local county sheriff saw the airplane and read the tail number. He called the local airport to have them call the pilot and tell him to stay away from the power plant or he would shoot down the airplane! The tower told the sheriff he can't do that. He looked up the FAA registry of the tail number (anyone can) and found the name of the company, and asked what the home airport was. He met the pilot on the ground and was wanting to arrest him. Our pilot was a long time very experienced pilot and he told the sheriff he has no authority whatsoever over where he flies. The sheriff finally backed down when he talked to an air traffic controller at that airport.

That same pilot was around in the 1970s when a president in Air Force one changed his mind on where he wanted to go. There is always a TFR around Air Force one, and our pilot clipped the edge on it. He said all of a sudden a F-16 came screaming past as he trundled along at 100 knots running the aerial camera. He said the same F-16 came past again, almost standing on his tail to move that slow. He was met by the FBI when he landed and and had to show them why he was there, and they eventually admitted there was no danger to the POTUS.

masraum 04-20-2024 06:25 AM

I was on my way home from work a couple of weeks ago and saw a drone hovering ~50' over the eastbound lanes of I10. I was thinking that the authorities probably wouldn't be very happy about that.

Zeke 04-20-2024 08:00 AM

Too bad Silly String won't reach 100 feet or more.

The FAA control thing is strange. Aircraft are required to stay above 1000' over populated areas.
And 500' after take off before initiating a turn. I know because I live under a general aviation pattern that sees 200 planes a day. A drone here is a serious violation because of the GA activity.

So are any balloons. I'm talking about kids balloons. Hard to find the source of those too.

We had an incident about a drone where some fool went on the Nextdoor app and asked about his missing drone. You would have thought that the tar and feather squad was convening. I've never seen one flying in real life.

I have to emphasize the rules about shooting anything towards the sky in a flight pattern. You'll get a visit by the FBI if the cops don't get you first.

DRONE 04-20-2024 08:31 AM

Just give me a wave off and I'll leave

3rd_gear_Ted 04-20-2024 08:41 AM

There were drones flying faster than the Indy cars @ the LBGP and they follow the race course with uncanny ability.
Lots of insurance companies are reviewing their clients property conditions for upkeep or hoarding of stuff. My roof was drone reviewed per my agent to verify it was a new TPO type roof with solar panels as I stated. If you get caught falsifying, welcome to the high risk pool for 3 years minimum.

pmax 04-20-2024 09:07 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Seahawk (Post 12235296)
I didn't make the rules!

We have teamed with a company in Huntsville (Army guys) and are working three counter drone efforts. We do the drone, they do the sensors/countermeasures.

We are also working a cheap, armed ducted fan drone for a one way flight.

It is serious.

http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1713632740.jpg

DavidI 04-20-2024 10:39 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jyl (Post 12235323)
Ooo, tell us more. What ranges, what loads used? Why are they so hard to hit (other than the obvious).

We used law enforcement ranges and fired at Department-owned drones. We fired with shotguns (12 gauge 00 Buck), .308, .223, and a specialized round that opened up with a net. Even our best shooters were unable to strike a moving drone.

The variables with distance, height, and angles made the shots almost impossible.

We also printed 3D 40mm ordnance-dropping devices that attached to drones, similar to what is being used in Ukraine, to drop inert explosives over targets. It was scary how simple it was to do and how devastating the results could be.

I fear that it is only a matter of time before it becomes an issue in the US.

pwd72s 04-20-2024 10:42 AM

One of these?
https://outdoormoran.com/best-hunting-slingshots/

KFC911 04-20-2024 12:07 PM

Rocks!!!

signed....

Ernest T Bass

FWIW .... I've never seen one .... just a matter of time I reckon.

Alan A 04-20-2024 01:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by KNS (Post 12235311)
If you buy a drone these days you are required to register it. There is now an app (more than one, I think) which you can use to look up to see who’s flying outside your kitchen window. With that info you report them to the authorities.

Problem is tons of people are buying drones and not registering them. But the app is a place to start.

You mean like registering firearms. Where the people you would need to be registered aren’t…

stevej37 04-20-2024 02:34 PM

I've found the best counter for drone is to drop it down a gear and get those revs up over 3500.:)

masraum 04-20-2024 03:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by stevej37 (Post 12235606)
I've found the best counter for drone is to drop it down a gear and get those revs up over 3500.:)

LOL! Yep, that would do it!


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 05:32 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.6.0
Copyright 2025 Pelican Parts, LLC - Posts may be archived for display on the Pelican Parts Website


DTO Garage Plus vBulletin Plugins by Drive Thru Online, Inc.