Settle the Age Old Question - Whats the Best Girl Scout Cookie?
 

Got hit up by the girls nextdoor and at work - now we have mega boxes of Girl Scout Cookies. Discussions pursue at work and home as to which cookies are the best. Cast a vote and see where it leads. Also - how many boxes they get you for?

Samoas my fave, then thin mints. I usually get 4 boxes.

Tagalongs recently bumped my old favorite, thin mints, to second place. I like my thin mints right out of the freezer. Anybody else do that?

Heh-heh - how timely a thread is this? Last Sat. I rented a U-Haul to help move almost 200 boxes of G.S. cookies. I vote for the Tagalongs, though I should be eating the Lemon Coolers. :rolleyes:

Thin mints rock right out of the freezer :D YUMMY!

ive always prefered a brownie.

hehehe...I heard you were kicked out of the scouts for eating brownies...:eek:

Randy

better thsn getting kicked out of the brownies for eating scouts!

How do you get from girl scout cookies to the gutter in less than 6 posts.!!! Nice work perverts. Is there nothing you freaks can't leave unmolested?

Oh, and thin mints rule, and then the ones that have peanut butter in them (the cookies not the girl scouts).

At $4.00 a box, they had better all be good! Bought the Tagalongs for myself yesterday (my favorite) and the Thin Mints for my wife (her favorite). You can bet that I will be trying the frozen Thin Mints tomorrow...great tip! :)

Where are the Peanut Butter cookies in your poll ????? They are the best.

Those thin mints come in a close second though.

Having just demolished a box of them last night, the peanut butter ones are called Do-Si-Do's. Those and the samoa's rock.

Girl Scout Thin Mint Ice Cream. I believe it's a Dryers limited release flavor. I could eat a 1/2 gallon at a time.

Tag-a-longs are the peanut butter.... my fav.

I like frozwn somoas. (the cookies) :)

Tagalongs have the peanut butter inards and the choc coating - polished off a box last night as well,
the Do-si-Dos went the night before - they are the peanut butter filled sandwich cookie - very good when dipped in coffee!

I dunno about girl scout cookies but I got kicked out of Boy Scouts.........for eating a brownie :D

I bought $18 worth (5 boxes) from a lady at work...my wife bought just as much. A guy just stopped by my desk trying to unload some "extra" boxes.

It's all a conspiracy to make me fat!

Looks like I'll have to do another 1500 calories of cardio at the gym tonight just to keep even.

why is this even a question? Thin mints out of the freezer. The rest of you heathens get back to work.

crazy woman driver and I will retire to the kitchen...

The peanut butter ones. When I was a teenaged stoner, my best friend and I would get a couple boxes of those, get baked and then sit down and seriously greaze w/ the cookies and some ice-cold milk. :)

That is among my fondest childhood memories, along w/ going to the Minnesota State Fair and doing the same thing w/ fresh mini-donuts and the tanker truck full of cold milk in the agriculture section. Than go climb around on the giant farm equipment machinery. Ahhh, sweet youth. :cool:

Try this - a mouth full of Tagalongs while "loving" your lady! That my friend satisfys all the needs at once (she prefers the Thin Mints from the freezer). That makes the cookies season someting to look forward to.