rem 17 vs ith 37
 

Which will hold its value better? Ithica model 37 12ga or Remington model 17, assume same grade/condition?

They are the exact same shotgun. Ithaca bought the right to produce the 17 from Remington.

That said, I think the Ithaca is worth a little more. I think the generation that lived by the Rem 17 is largely gone.

Did I mention that I own a Remington Model 17?