Fit of aftermarket 69-73 fenders

[ddubois]

I have rusted out headlight buckets on my 71 911T that have resulted in some rust migrating to the fender at the lower edge of the buckets. I'm tempted to purchase new aftermarket fenders rather than have someone cut out the buckets, repair the surrounding areas of the fenders, and install new buckets. I'm thinking that by the time I buy new buckets, pay someone to do the repairs, sell my current fenders which are otherwise in good shape, I'll be getting close to the cost of new fenders. I have some concerns with this though and could use some opinions.

1.) Will I be happy with the fit of new aftermarket fenders? The car is original and the gaps are perfect now.
2.) Who makes the best aftermarket fenders?

Thanks,