Pelican Parts Forums

Pelican Parts Forums (http://forums.pelicanparts.com/index.php)
-   Off Topic Discussions (http://forums.pelicanparts.com/forumdisplay.php?f=31)
-   -   Compensation Plan Review........ (http://forums.pelicanparts.com/showthread.php?t=1139347)

Instrument 41 05-03-2023 10:53 AM

Compensation Plan Review........
 
So our management has hired a new area manager for this region. She is 33, has only 5 years of actual experience in what we do. And is very quick to tell you about her wife and their 2 kids.
Get an email with a meeting notice for a Compensation review. This has occurred to 3 other folks, and on average they were cut but 25% but the commission rate increased by 2 points, on the profit. Not sure what the correct response should or will be. I am 59, not looking to make a change and age discrimination is a real issue.....

masraum 05-03-2023 10:56 AM

Good luck. I wonder if there's a lawyer that you can consult that can tell you what they can legally do.

Zeke 05-03-2023 11:38 AM

Lots of thoughts here but I've never faced that situation, KC can probably tell you.

stomachmonkey 05-03-2023 11:51 AM

Most of the US is at will as is Louisiana.

Given advance notice an employer can generally reduce your compensation whenever they want.

Since it's a commission role there may be something in any contract OP has signed but don't hold your breath.

The way to do this from the employee end is to counter with not a reduction in rate but a reduction in days / hours.

As in a 20% compensation reduction means a 4 day work week.

monoflo 05-03-2023 12:04 PM

Get to the Chopper!!!!

gacook 05-03-2023 12:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by stomachmonkey (Post 11989781)
Most of the US is at will as is Louisiana.

Given advance notice an employer can generally reduce your compensation whenever they want.

Since it's a commission role there may be something in any contract OP has signed but don't hold your breath.

The way to do this from the employee end is to counter with not a reduction in rate but a reduction in days / hours.

As in a 20% compensation reduction means a 4 day work week
.

Not sure of OP's position but this may not be very doable going forward. The entire market is shifting from employee-centric back to employer-centric. Strange times ahead.

stomachmonkey 05-03-2023 12:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by gacook (Post 11989810)
Not sure of OP's position but this may not be very doable going forward. The entire market is shifting from employee-centric back to employer-centric. Strange times ahead.

The point is OP can't just roll over and take this.

He really has no option but to suck it up if that is what the company chooses to do so he looses nothing by negotiating something that makes it suck less.

The reduced work week results in the cash savings the company is looking to achieve so they may be receptive to it.

Now if they respond that they need OP 5 days a week then they've established his worth to the organization and he has another way to push back.

That could be a commission rate increase of 5% instead of just 2.

The basic mindset OP should have is, if my compensation is being reduced then "I am investing in the company, what is the benefit / reward to me for doing that?

Never take this stuff lying down.

David Inc. 05-03-2023 12:37 PM

Only thing to do is look and see if the commission bump is worth it and try to negotiate. If they figure you're not interested in changing jobs though it weakens your negotiating position tremendously.

mgatepi 05-03-2023 01:21 PM

Sadly in this world, "You are only worth as much as your NEXT job will pay you"
And at our age, not sure this is going to be good.

gacook 05-03-2023 01:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mgatepi (Post 11989863)
Sadly in this world, "You are only worth as much as your NEXT job will pay you"
And at our age, not sure this is going to be good.

Very true. Very "first world problem" but my wife is kinda in that boat. She's performed very well over the years for her company and has been compensated in kind. She's at a point where she wants to do something else but she can't find a position that'll pay anywhere near what she's currently making...so feels "stuck."

mgatepi 05-03-2023 01:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by gacook (Post 11989865)
Very true. Very "first world problem" but my wife is kinda in that boat. She's performed very well over the years for her company and has been compensated in kind. She's at a point where she wants to do something else but she can't find a position that'll pay anywhere near what she's currently making...so feels "stuck."

Yep the "Ole Golden Handcuffs"

stomachmonkey 05-03-2023 01:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by David Inc. (Post 11989828)
Only thing to do is look and see if the commission bump is worth it and try to negotiate. If they figure you're not interested in changing jobs though it weakens your negotiating position tremendously.

It doesn't really weaken his position.

The company is in cost containment mode which is never a great sign.

They company can do a right size and lay people off and that may still happen but letting people go costs money.

The company is fully aware that salary reductions will cause some staff to leave on their own and in fact are counting on it. People who quit don't get severance, it's cheaper.

The company will deal with each person individually and decide whether to let them leave or make an effort to retain those they deem valuable.

Unless you know you are an invaluable rockstar threatening or intimating you would quit is not a place to negotiate from as they are more likely to call your bluff. Remember, they are counting on people leaving.

gacook 05-03-2023 01:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by stomachmonkey (Post 11989882)
It doesn't really weaken his position.

The company is in cost containment mode which is never a great sign.

They company can do a right size and lay people off and that may still happen but letting people go costs money.

The company is fully aware that salary reductions will cause some staff to leave on their own and in fact are counting on it. People who quit don't get severance, it's cheaper.

The company will deal with each person individually and decide whether to let them leave or make an effort to retain those they deem valuable.

Unless you know you are an invaluable rockstar threatening or intimating you would quit is not a place to negotiate from as they are more likely to call your bluff. Remember, they are counting on people leaving.

Very valid points, SM.

One of the reasons I'm glad to be a fed employee...I'll never get rich here but I'm damn comfortable and ya can't beat the security.

Arizona_928 05-03-2023 02:36 PM

Age discrimination.

That schit is illegal.

Instrument 41 05-03-2023 02:53 PM

Well I got it the rear. Cut my salary by 30% and commission of only 8% on the profit. Take it or leave and that's it. Said it didn't matter what experience I bring the the table, its all based on their budget for the territory. The resume is getting hot.....crap..

masraum 05-03-2023 02:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Arizona_928 (Post 11989917)
Age discrimination.

That schit is illegal.

Unless they say "we're gonna can yer azz cuz yer old", I think it's pretty hard to prove.

Jeff Hail 05-03-2023 02:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by stomachmonkey (Post 11989817)
The point is OP can't just roll over and take this.

He really has no option but to suck it up if that is what the company chooses to do so he looses nothing by negotiating something that makes it suck less.

The reduced work week results in the cash savings the company is looking to achieve so they may be receptive to it.

Now if they respond that they need OP 5 days a week then they've established his worth to the organization and he has another way to push back.

That could be a commission rate increase of 5% instead of just 2.

The basic mindset OP should have is, if my compensation is being reduced then "I am investing in the company, what is the benefit / reward to me for doing that?

Never take this stuff lying down.

Nailed it. I know a lot of HR folks and owners that would serious reflect on that.

Instrument 41 05-03-2023 02:58 PM

what they are doing is putting lipstick on a friggin pig to make things look attractive for a new buyer. They go around buying 3 legged dog companies so it can raise that EBIDA number. Easier to buy weak companies and pull their numbers in to make the entire thing look enticing.

gacook 05-03-2023 02:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Instrument 41 (Post 11989930)
Well I got it the rear. Cut my salary by 30% and commission of only 8% on the profit. Take it or leave and that's it. Said it didn't matter what experience I bring the the table, its all based on their budget for the territory. The resume is getting hot.....crap..

Damn, man...sorry to hear. :(

911boost 05-03-2023 03:06 PM

First off I am really sorry to hear it.

I debated starting a separate thread on this back in February when it happened, but after 26 years my employer did a "job realignment", the three individuals in my position that made the most for the company and hence were paid the largest bonuses were "job eliminated". All of us were over 45 and represented a growing list of experienced individuals this new "President" has let go to hire cheaper talent from outside the industry.

I was crushed, I had put my heart and soul into that company, when I stated the group that I was in we were about $100M in revenue and last year were $1.4B.... It didn't matter, if you weren't one of the chosen few and played tennis like the CEO and his minions, you were looked down upon. The days of making your numbers (I exceeded prior year profit by almost 30%) were gone, and the do as I say and not as I do crowd are leading that company into the toilet.

I have just started with a new company and could not be happier.

Hang in there and LinkedIn is your friend right now.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 12:03 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.6.0
Copyright 2025 Pelican Parts, LLC - Posts may be archived for display on the Pelican Parts Website


DTO Garage Plus vBulletin Plugins by Drive Thru Online, Inc.