Here's another view, with one of the cleaner heads (#6). Valves are still dirty, as I intend to replace them.

http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1506910969.jpg

http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1506910969.jpg

http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1506910969.jpg



I suppose I should ask, what is valve recession, and how do you see and/or measure it?

Cheers-

Jake

Yep- makes sense. I'll definitely re-run all the measurements/calcs when I get to that phase.


According to the chart, 2.2E pistons have a dome volume of 28.4, which results in a CR of 9.64:1. That's much closer to what I was thinking. Perhaps I was a bit over exuberant on my purchase of the 2.2S pistons! Anything with an S just sounds so cool :)


Yeah, that was the plan. Can I infer from the question that maybe you'd recommend otherwise? The pistons are coming from a well-known Pelican, who I have no reason to doubt when he says they're totally in-spec. Obviously, I'm new at this- but I'd imagine that the critical specs are the ring-groove gaps. Any other suggestions on what to verify before re-using them? (assuming I stick w them...)


Great suggestion. I'm seriously considering it. I love the idea of re-using the OE 2.2S's, but at the same time, there's some piece of mind that comes along with new parts. Did you end up using your stock cylinders?


Great catch! I missed that as well. Does seem to confirm my initial math, at the least...


Thanks again for the great feedback.

Best,

Jake

Valve recession is when the valve sinks into the head due to seat and or valve face wear. The seat and valve can be re-ground but this positions valve even lower which is a real hindrance to low lift flow according to people who flow heads for a living. I imagine slightly less compression as well.

You can search this forum for an idea of how much new valves stand “proud” in new seats.

Jake, are you in Washington?? Your location says "SF Bay" but the license plates say otherwise.

I think I would go with the JEs or other new pistons. You are talking about 45+ year old pistons with the 2,2s. They MAY be OK, but for a little extra money, new would be the way to go IMO.

It really comes down to your expectations. If you just want to get a motor running or do you want a freshly rebuilt motor that will last for a generation?

The other issue is the iron cylinders you have. They might be OK for a mild street driven motor. Are yours in spec? If you have to hone them, then the old pistons may no longer be a match.

Maybe others that have used iron cylinders in a hotrodded motor will chime in. If you order new pistons, make sure you let them know what type of cylinder you have.

BTW, I used my old cylinders. HOWEVER, they are Mahle nicasils.

Good to know- I'll check it out. According to receipts there was some head work way back when, so I can imagine the valves have receded a bit.


The car had been in the Bay Area its whole life, until it found its way to a dealer outside of Portand OR, where I picked it up while living in Seattle. I've since moved back to the Bay Area, so it has been a homecoming for both of us :) Wish I could find the original plates somehow...


Thanks for the feedback. My original priority list had reliability at the top- so your advice on the pistons is well received.

Not sure if my C's are in spec, but I hope to measure them soon.

I would consider a new matching set of P's and C's if I could find something that makes sense (both from a $ and CR standpoint)... closest thing our host appears to offer is a new set of 84mm 2.4S P's and nikasil C's (911-103-944-01-OEM); $4k for a slight CR bump to 8.5:1. Seems a bit spendy for what I'm after.


More to come...


-Jake

I'm right in the middle of rebuilding a very original '72 911T MFI motor for a customer.

Since he is retired and on a budget, we went with simply regrinding the T cams to E spec, and sourcing some low mileage 2.2E pistons which will go in the original cast iron cylinders which were still well in spec. Leaving the ports stock. This should net around 170hp, which is right at the limit of power output before you need an auxiliary oil cooler.

This makes for a really nice street motor with a very wide power band, and doesn't necessitate a bunch of other upgrades which can drive up the cost. It's easy to get carried away with upgrades, and the cost adds up in a hurry.

There is nothing wrong with a set of used Mahle pistons, so long as they are within spec. The most critical measurement is the ring land gap.

BTW, Mahle pistons are very overstated on their compression ratio. Theoretically when you put 2.2 pistons in a 2.4, it should bump the CR up another .55 points above what it would be with the short stroke. But when you actually measure everything out, it usually ends up just a tad under their supposed 2.2 spec.

Agree that the used Mahle pistons should be okay. I don't have any experience with the JEs and Ted steered me away from them. Maybe talk to Ted and see if his opinion of JE has changed since you're working with him anyways.

You need a new valve to check it, measure from the spring pocket to the top of the new valve stem there is a spec for this. If it’s to deep you need new seats to correct it.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Good to know! I figured the actual CR must end up below the formulaic CR, but couldn't figure out which part of the equation was typically off. Sounds like the Mahle piston dome volumes might work out to be a bit lower than spec- that would definitely explain it.



Ted hasn't changed his opinion :) But, to his credit, he's quick to point out that he's a machinist, not an engine builder.



Very cool- I wasn't planning on ordering my new valves yet, but now I have an excuse...


Thanks all for the great feedback.


- Jake

Now that everything is out and apart, I've been spending a ton of time trying to clean everything and get it organized enough to send out to the corresponding experts (pretty much all from this forum) for whatever's needed (machining, grinding, blasting, coating, plating, et al).

I've been using a cheap Harbor Freight parts cleaner with mineral spirits for most things, and warm, diluted simple green for some of the other bits. I'm not trying to get everything perfect at this stage, as most everything will end up getting cleaned and/or blasted. I guess I'm embarrassed to send the parts out if they're too dirty. Plus, though laborious, it's kinda fun to get to know the ins and outs of each part.

http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1507524343.jpg

http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1507524343.jpg

http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1507524343.jpg



Ted from German Precision suggested that I get the major parts steam cleaned at San Jose Steam Cleaners. Those guys were great- fast and efficient. I'm not sure what I was expecting, but it's a really simple process. I just showed up, put my parts right on the ground, and they went blasting away with some impressively loud steam wands.

I shoulda done this first! They did in about 20 minutes what woulda taken me many, many hours hunched over the parts cleaner with a wire brush.

http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1507524483.jpg

http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1507524483.jpg



The mag case cleaned up pretty good, but did reveal a lot of corrosion on the outside (previously covered by a thick layer of oily gunk). After reading a ton about mag parts here, it seems that this is pretty normal- and as long as it's not affecting any machined surfaces (it's not) I can just leave it as is, and maybe coat everything with some Gibbs spray. I'd really like to clean it up though, but haven't decided which way to go. Consensus here seems to be soda blasting, or possibly elbow grease and a wire brush. I'm striking out trying to find a local soda blaster (I tried Accessories Plus in Belmont, but they don't do soda and couldn't recommend anyone. They're super helpful for other stuff, fwiw). So I'll probably hack at it w a brush and see if I get anywhere.

http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1507524548.jpg



Good times!

- Jake

So I decided to go after the mag case corrosion with various implements. I had the best luck with different wire wheel brushes mounted in a corded drill. I tried to stay away from all of the machined surfaces.

First pass at it:

http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1509166752.jpg


...then went back over with a finer grit, just to catch any of the larger scratches. Getting into all the nooks and crannies is pretty much impossible, at least with the tools I have, so I just tried to focus on the most visible areas.

Here's one half done:

http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1509166752.jpg


Lookin' pretty good! Gave everything a healthy spray with Gibbs.

http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1509166752.jpg


All in all, I'm not sure it was worth the trouble. It's nice to see everything shiny, but there's basically no chance it'll stay that way. It'll probably end up looking like it did within the first 1000 miles of driving... and some would say that's an optimistic view :)

Still, especially as a first-timer, it's fun to see what's really underneath.


-Jake

While I'm waiting on some other parts, I thought I'd try to restore my yellow engine shroud. Fortunately, it's totally intact, and without too much damage, so I won't need to do a bunch of fiberglass repair.

I was initially tempted by the high-gloss, show-car look of a freshly painted or coated shroud, but then decided to stick with the "patina" of the original fiberglass. You can really see the imperfections and discolorations in the glass, and I've convinced myself that that's how it woulda looked straight out of the factory :)

Here's what it looked like when I pulled the motor. Super gunky, but intact:

http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1509170139.jpg


After a thorough cleaning with warm water, simple green, and a scotch pad:

http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1509170139.jpg


At this point I decided I could live with the discolored areas, but I wanted to try to do something about the areas that still look a little dirty. I wet-sanded everything, but I don't think that helped much, other than to dull the yellow a bit. Looking more closely, I could see a lot of tiny cracks in the outer surface (gel coat, I assume), which have been filled with oil/dirt over the years to make each tiny crack darker in color. My experiment with the wet-sanding suggested that I'd have to sand the heck out of the shroud to take out all those micro-cracks... not worth it! Let's keep 'em and call it "character".

I did buy a gel-coat repair kit, which comes with a two-part clear epoxy resin and some coloring agents. I tried to match the color as best as I could, and patched the areas with the biggest scratches and pits.

Then I found this thread:
http://forums.pelicanparts.com/paint-bodywork-discussion-forum/416863-engine-shroud-restoration.html

... which includes an interesting suggestion of leather dye to help restore the shroud's color. The dye is pretty cheap on Amazon, so I gave it a shot- definitely helps. Take a look at the before/after here. Didn't do much against the dark fissures, but really helped even out some of the discoloration:

http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1509170139.jpg

http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1509170139.jpg



Then a couple of coats of rattle-can hi-temp clear, and I'll call it done:

http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1509170139.jpg

This is definitely good enough to mount to the engine (whenever I get it done...), and if for some reason it just doesn't look right I can always paint or cerakote it later.

Also, I now have a half-bottle of yellow leather dye- pay for shipping and it's yours!

- Jake

If you're thinking about powder coating your engine tin, cylinder air guides and painting your fan, a great place to take it is West Coast Powder Coating in South SF. AJ is the owner and does a lot of Porsche parts.

Great job! I just went through this early this year and it was one of the most enjoyable things when the engine starts up again for the first time! The way you're going, it won't be long. Only one thing I would do differently, is to not put any sealant on the bearing towers inside the case, and generally put less sealant. See last page of this thread:

http://forums.pelicanparts.com/911-engine-rebuilding-forum/941752-need-advice-re-build-rebuild.html

I would be really interested in knowing how much wear you have on your cylinders and by how much they are out-of-round (oval) after so many miles. If you get the chance, could you post the inner diameter of a cylinder near the top (horizontally and vertically)?

Good luck!

Dario

Thanks very much for documenting your rebuild and thought process so thoroughly! As a like-minded newbie I find it really informative and I'm sure it will be useful for when time comes for me to do something similar.

Hi All-

I'm finally back in action. Crazy how the days can click by... I welcomed a 2nd daughter to the family, which has slowed the progress on this project. I know, excuses, excuses...

Anyway, I'm catching back up. I've got the major machining done and back (thanks Ted @ German Precision), and still working on a bunch of the peripherals. I'll soon try to remember where I left off regarding my P's and C's and the whole compression ration calc.

I got a few minor things done during my down time. I had my heat exchangers blasted, with the intent of cera-coating them, but in some areas they're pitted like swiss cheese. Couldn't tell before they were blasted, because there was so much oil and dirt caked on. Anyone think these are salvageable? I've got basic welding/metalworking tools/skills, but I think this is beyond me:


http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1529292799.jpg

http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1529292835.jpg

http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1529292835.jpg

They're otherwise clean and intact. The guys at Accessories Plus (where I got them blasted) thought there might be a brazing technique that could work, but their general sense was that it wouldn't be worth the trouble.

Thanks, and glad to be back at it.

- Jake

I've been getting a lot of the parts back; nice to see them so clean and pristine.

84mm S Pistons:

http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1529452673.jpg

http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1529452673.jpg

Ring gaps all looked good, according to Ted @ German Precision.


Original cast cylinders, honed and looking' good:

http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1529453135.jpg

http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1529453135.jpg

Still not sure where I'm gonna land re. the compression ratio, so some chance I'll end up w a different set of Ps and Cs... but I'm hoping these are gonna work.


E cams:

http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1529454864.jpg


The folks at Pacific Oil Cooler did a nice job flushing and cleaning up my oil cooler:

http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1529454969.jpg


Resurfaced flywheel:

http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1529455134.jpg


...and a Glenn Yee modified 3-rib oil pump:

http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1529455258.jpg


A lot more to come, but at least the kit is taking shape.


- Jake

Side note: be careful what you teach your 4yr old daughter...

I showed her how to use my lift table:

http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1529683115.jpg


and then, like a dummy, I stored it under the back of my 911. I wasn't watching, and she lifted the table until.. Crunch! All of the weight was on the bottom edge of the rear bumper panel, which now has a funky new shape to it. So, off it comes:

http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1529683428.jpg

http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1529683115.jpg


I know this is an engine rebuilding thread, but looks like I also get to try my hand at some panel-beating. It'll have to be repainted as well. Lesson learned- kids practice tools on Mom's car now :)

- Jake

Pulled the oil tank out:

http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1529684207.jpg

http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1529684207.jpg


I guess that's what 285k miles of road grime looks like!

Cleaned it up:

http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1529684207.jpg

http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1529684207.jpg


I think I shaved 10lbs by removing all of that crust ;) ...Now off to Pacific Oil Cooler to be checked out, flushed, and repainted.


-Jake