Pelican Parts Forums

Pelican Parts Forums (http://forums.pelicanparts.com/)
-   Off Topic Discussions (http://forums.pelicanparts.com/off-topic-discussions/)
-   -   Torque wrench how to question (http://forums.pelicanparts.com/off-topic-discussions/1102525-torque-wrench-how-question.html)

Esel Mann 09-19-2021 03:38 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by island911 (Post 11461655)
This ^

A 200 lb person stand on a 1.5-ft bar will do it too.

Alternatively two 100lb strippers with 1.5 ft of their dance pole cut out would go well beyond satisfying the minimal requirements and permit the OP to simply supervise the task.
Hehe, it's important to not overthink this....

GH85Carrera 09-20-2021 05:43 AM

For the nut on the rear axle of my 911 the torque value is some crazy number like 360 pound feet. I would have to look it up to get the exact number and it is irrelevant right now.

I stood on a scale, and pushed down on a 3 foot bar until I weighted the proper amount on the scale. Again, I don't remember the numbers, as it does not matter. I then knew I was pretty close, but I don't do "good enough" when it comes to holding my rear axle on. I brought my socket to a local truck stop and pulled up by the work bays. Of course an old guy in a 85 911 with a $20 bill in hand attracted some attention. One mechanic walked over and I told him I would give him the 20 if he would torque the two nuts to the proper number. He grabbed his 4 foot long torque wrench, and click click twice and he made 20 bucks. I went home and put the cent caps back on and I was done.

aschen 09-20-2021 06:27 AM

I think 300ft lbs is right on the edge of most half inch drives capacity. Can grab a decent ratchet and torque til it breaks and you will be close

if you have the right 3/4 drive socket and breaker bar you can get something like this for relatively reasonable amount. https://www.amazon.com/Neiko-20743A-Digital-Adapter-Foot-Pound/dp/B009GLITFW/ref=sr_1_2?dchild=1&keywords=torque+adapter+3%2F4& qid=1632147711&sr=8-2

matthewb0051 09-20-2021 06:38 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Esel Mann (Post 11461867)
Alternatively two 100lb strippers with 1.5 ft of their dance pole cut out would go well beyond satisfying the minimal requirements and permit the OP to simply supervise the task.
Hehe, it's important to not overthink this....

Do the strippers need to be clothed or is your math based on them at the end of their act?

I have a DeWalt 20v impact. Used it for axel nuts that are around the same torque. Prior to that it was a 3/4 drive socket and 3.5 ft breaker bar with my fat ass standing on it.

speeder 09-20-2021 08:38 AM

Any really strong impact wrench should do it. You would need to torque it to 250, or however tight you can accurately get it with your wrench, mark the bolt with paint and then blast it with an impact that moves it a hair. Just a hair, at those torques. Threads only stretch so much.

The suggestions about having strippers or 4 German Shepards standing on a pipe assume that there is no friction to overcome in initially moving the fastener. That is an incorrect assumption.

speeder 09-20-2021 08:40 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by GH85Carrera (Post 11462230)
For the nut on the rear axle of my 911 the torque value is some crazy number like 360 pound feet. I would have to look it up to get the exact number and it is irrelevant right now.

I stood on a scale, and pushed down on a 3 foot bar until I weighted the proper amount on the scale. Again, I don't remember the numbers, as it does not matter. I then knew I was pretty close, but I don't do "good enough" when it comes to holding my rear axle on. I brought my socket to a local truck stop and pulled up by the work bays. Of course an old guy in a 85 911 with a $20 bill in hand attracted some attention. One mechanic walked over and I told him I would give him the 20 if he would torque the two nuts to the proper number. He grabbed his 4 foot long torque wrench, and click click twice and he made 20 bucks. I went home and put the cent caps back on and I was done.

This is the winning post and what I've done in the past for axle nuts but those are easy because you can get them part of the way tight and then drive to a tire shop or somewhere with a huge torque wrench. It's a little tougher with a crankshaft bolt.

gordner 09-20-2021 01:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by speeder (Post 11462430)
Any really strong impact wrench should do it. You would need to torque it to 250, or however tight you can accurately get it with your wrench, mark the bolt with paint and then blast it with an impact that moves it a hair. Just a hair, at those torques. Threads only stretch so much.

The suggestions about having strippers or 4 German Shepards standing on a pipe assume that there is no friction to overcome in initially moving the fastener. That is an incorrect assumption.

So if that is true, how does a torque wrench set for the correct value account for that any more than the strippers or dogs do?

The torque value is given with drag torque included. Where it is not, then it would have to be measured and added to the total torque, and the torqueing procedure would indicate that.

RANDY P 09-20-2021 01:40 PM

TQ wrenches aren't exactly accurate at the top of the scale they are rated for. Min / Max tq. measuring capacity +/-20% IIRC.

I'd seek a tool rental place out, frankly.

rjp

speeder 09-20-2021 02:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by gordner (Post 11462788)
So if that is true, how does a torque wrench set for the correct value account for that any more than the strippers or dogs do?

No, they do not. If a fastener is already tight, (i.e. anywhere close to final torque), it needs to be loosened slightly and then torqued. Torque wrenches absolutely do not account for initial friction and would *click* below final torque in that circumstance. They are made to measure while moving.

A930Rocket 09-20-2021 06:10 PM

I’ve always read the bottom and top scales of the torque wrench are not as accurate. That said, I torqued it to 250 and then used my breaker bar with a 3 foot cheater bar to move it a little more.

1990C4S 09-21-2021 05:42 AM

Speeder is correct. Torque a moving bolt, not a tightened bolt. And adding lube for good measure may not be advisable.

The accuracy is typically a percent of full scale. So you want to use your torque wrench near the top of its range. The top end is the more accurate region.

KFC911 09-21-2021 06:03 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 1990C4S (Post 11463353)
...

The accuracy is typically a percent of full scale. So you want to use your torque wrench near the top of its range. The top end is the more accurate region.

Is this accurate? I've always tried to pick a torque wrench where the "desired" torque is in the middle of the wrench's range and not the upper end... but I dunno.

1990C4S 09-21-2021 06:56 AM

I will modify my statement to say 'it depends on the wrench'. Read the docs that came with your wrench.

What I stated is 'typical'. So it might be both accurate and repeatable...

KFC911 09-21-2021 06:59 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 1990C4S (Post 11463433)
I will modify my statement to say 'it depends on the wrench'. Read the docs that came with your wrench.

What I stated is 'typical'. So it might be both accurate and repeatable...

I'm gonna have to take your word for it.... what docs :D?

I have 20 year old Craftsman TWs ... anyone know about them?

Learned something new.... thanks!

David 09-21-2021 01:17 PM

I'm surprised that BMW would have torque value like that rather than a pre-torque value and then a turn X degrees number. That's what modern Porsche's do for flywheels and such.

Torque wrenches aren't super accurate for determining bolt stretch anyway. You could calculate the turn by degree method with the thread pitch and desired bolt stretch.

gtc 09-21-2021 01:47 PM

Just give it 7 Ugga Duggas and you should be fine.

hcoles 09-21-2021 04:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by speeder (Post 11462835)
No, they do not. If a fastener is already tight, (i.e. anywhere close to final torque), it needs to be loosened slightly and then torqued. Torque wrenches absolutely do not account for initial friction and would *click* below final torque in that circumstance. They are made to measure while moving.

This is correct.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 02:32 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.6.0
Copyright 2025 Pelican Parts, LLC - Posts may be archived for display on the Pelican Parts Website


DTO Garage Plus vBulletin Plugins by Drive Thru Online, Inc.