![]() |
I saw this a while back. This is an interesting video and UFC guy. Japanese guy born in Brazil, mostly does Karate.
<iframe width="720" height="480" src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/V3_OMp-8Pio" title="YouTube video player" frameborder="0" allow="accelerometer; autoplay; clipboard-write; encrypted-media; gyroscope; picture-in-picture" allowfullscreen></iframe> |
^^^ Glove size has a lot to do with the trauma to the opponent, just like in real fights.
I never worked a door, I was always a bartender. I never got in the way when the fur started flying unless they were coming at me, which happened once. The end is always near unless numbers get involved, then I was really out, like GTFO out. We had an app for that. |
Lyoto Machida got put to sleep with a guillotine choke by John Jones. :p:p:p forward to 3:55 BJJ wins again. :D
<iframe width="560" height="315" src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/ZhE6wvM2Tkw" title="YouTube video player" frameborder="0" allow="accelerometer; autoplay; clipboard-write; encrypted-media; gyroscope; picture-in-picture" allowfullscreen></iframe> |
For sure but both super tough guys…could have gone either way.
|
So I guess at the end of the day anything can happen. Can a non trained super violent person beat an MMA fighter in a street fight? Technically yes because fights are unpredictable, but this would be a rare possibility or outlier situation.
If you took 10 MMA fighters and had them fight 10 random guys all comparable size in a street fight I would guess the MMA guy would win 9 if not 10 out of 10 times. That's like saying an untrained driver whos going off pure adrenalin will beat a trained, skilled drivers lap time on a race track. I'm sure there's that one crazy guy who will push it 100% and edge out a win with some luck, but I'd go with the trained driver every time. I deal in probabilities not possibilities. |
Quote:
|
And Jon Jones has a LOT more than JJ in his tool box.
|
Quote:
the untrained person. Anyone I’m going to wind up in a fight with is not a trained fighter, just an ass hole. :) |
Quote:
I was a lowly ranked boxer then went into French Kick Boxing (for about 15 years), which is fairly much MMA but decades before MMA was even thought of. Devastating fighting when the other had never seen it before LOL And I lost more than half my fights in the ring but won about 80% of my street fights and bar fights. I knew very quickly as to whether of not the other guy was trained, and if not it was all over in about five seconds. |
Quote:
However, Holmes was transitioning into cage fighting so had some experience. <iframe width="560" height="315" src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/d8DWEU6IhlQ" title="YouTube video player" frameborder="0" allow="accelerometer; autoplay; clipboard-write; encrypted-media; gyroscope; picture-in-picture" allowfullscreen></iframe> |
Quote:
You are still assuming some level of fairness and civility. I bet every fight you have ever been in, and have ever seen, has been in a ring. I bet both combatants were either bare footed or, if boxing, wearing boxing shoes. Or wrestling in wrestling shoes. Wearing regulation gloves. And I bet those rings are notably free of things like fire hydrants, wrought iron decorative railings with spikes on top, curbs, heavy glass beer pitchers, and on and on and on. The guys I'm talking about like to wear things chosen for their effectiveness in a street fight, because they know they are going to eventually be in one. Like big, heavy, stout (sometimes even steel toed) motorcycle boots. I saw a guy kicked in the shin so hard it shattered his lower leg. I saw a guy get his foot stomped on so hard it crushed his instep. All while having the other guy's upper body tied up attempting some kind of a takedown. Ever see how many rings some street toughs like to wear? This has become ubiquitous in at least the biker culture. "Club rings", with their insignia on them, in sharply raised relief. That's not just to look pretty... Every finger of every hand with a big, prominent, square edged (and very sharp) ring on it. Full time "brass knuckles" everywhere they go, 24/7. They are not wearing regulation eight ounce gloves... Quote:
Quote:
The real thing is so, so different. It's now become clear that you have absolutely no idea of how different. Which is a good thing. Believe me, you never want to find out. |
Quote:
So I guess what your saying is that training has no value. Don't train, don't learn martial arts of any kind, because its all just for fun and useless. Just walk around wearing steel toe boots and brass knuckles..... and if you do end up getting in a fight, poke him the eyes or kick him in the balls.:rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes: I guess you'd take out John Jones by poking him in the eye. Its kind of a pointless discussion. I'm arguing about fighting with a guy whos never trained in fighting.... |
Well Jeff keeps moving the goal post. It started talking about a fight with 2 people on the street, one trained and one untrained, but has now morphed into the untrained guy is a 6'5 sociopath, wearing steel toe boots and brass knuckles with a history of street fighting every Friday night. This is called the "extreme" argument. Why not keep morphing into the untrained guy now has a gun since this occurs "on the street" he shoots the MMA guy and wins. end of story. lol
|
Quote:
I have never discounted the value of training. Never. I would defy you to go back and show us where I did that, in this thread. You can't. Quote:
I hate to burst your little bubble, but I worked my way through the entire Golden Gloves program as a kid, until I was 18 years old, starting at whatever young age they would let us first sign up (I can't remember, maybe ten? twelve?). It is partly through that experience in the ring that I have arrived at my position. I had skills. I won fights. I thought I could fight, that I could "handle myself" outside of the ring, in the real world. That's why my dad insisted I sign up. And, well, against your average drunk in a bar or tough guy on the street, that proved to be true. As I said earlier, though, my world was shaken by what i saw from "the real deal". Guys who are seriously fked up in the head, violent psychos who live to hurt people. I knew right away, despite my training and (compared to many of them) relative youth and fitness, there was no way in hell... Quote:
I went on to explain (as speeder did) just why we never see these kinds of fights go to ground. Why grappling skills never seem to come to bear. Somewhere along the line, you felt the need to interject someone trained in your sport vs. the street fighter. You are convinced, even having never actually witnessed an honest to God, no holds barred street fight between two vicious psychopaths, that someone trained in your particular discipline would prevail through the use of superior training and skills. As you continued down that path, I merely tried to clarify, to illustrate, just who you might find yourself up against in such a situation. It's obvious that you are hopelessly naive. I was trying to help you understand, I was not moving any goalposts in any way, shape, or form. I've actually witnessed everything I described. I was trying to help, trying to provide information gleaned through having actually witnessed these things. A "dose of reality", if you will. Things you had clearly not considered, because you have never seen them. But, no, you very much appear as though you need to "win" some kind of an argument. Typical PPOT conversation with an uninformed, inexperienced contributor desperately trying to argue something with which he has no personal exposure. You have never experienced, never seen fights like those I have, and have tried to describe here. Yet you are absolutely God damned sure you know how it would go. I'm only trying to help, by providing perspective from someone who has seen this. So drop the straw men, drop the assumptions, drop the veiled insults. They don't help your case. They just make you sound like kind of a dick... |
Quote:
|
Quote:
Drop the assumptions? LMAO coming from a guy who never met me but just wrote an entire paragraph about my assumed life experience. Drop the veiled insults? your very next sentence is calling me a dick lol. |
I come from a wrestling background. When my sons were hitting puberty I wanted to steer them towards a discipline that was real world and would give them confidence everyday life. I didn’t choose boxing or karate. They wrestled. They both did Judo as well and my oldest son is a Black belt in Judo and a Brown belt in JJ. The last thing I or they would want is to stand and trade punches with someone in a street fight. That’s ludicrous.
|
Quote:
Still, wrestling is a great martial art and could be extremely handy in an altercation. |
Quote:
This was my logic when I took up BJJ. I wanted a solid self defense martial art that would be effective against a larger person. After watching the old UFC and Royce Gracie, I went with BJJ because it was the most effective against other single styles. We all instinctively know how to throw punches and even kick to a degree so when two untrained people fight the winner is usually the bigger, stronger, overall tougher guy. BJJ neutralizes this because anyone that trains grappling knows that instincts are completely wrong when it comes to ground fighting. It takes years of drilling and sparing to create the muscle memory needed to instinctively move in the correct manner to control a person on the ground. Things like eye pokes and getting kicked in the balls are always possible but very unlikely, and not highly probable against an efficient grappler. These are not new ideas and we train to defend and prevent these common silly techniques that an untrained person may attempt. I started training in 2010 and got my Black Belt in 2021 so its definitely a long journey and that's training 4-5 days per week. So is it possible that some random tough guy would get the best of me in a street fight? Absolutely! Street fights are very different and I acknowledge that, however BJJ is predicated on street self defense so I would much rather go into a fight as a conditioned BJJ grappler vs going in with no training and simply relying on physical prowess. |
Quote:
I've been doing anything but. And the only things I have mentioned about you come from what you have told us about yourself in this very thread. I've made no assumptions about you whatsoever - you have told us (several times) that you have never been involved in any kind of street fighting. I've actually commended you for that, at least a couple of times. It's clearly been you, and no one else making assumptions. Ignorant, uninformed assumptions in some effort to discount my opinion. You have also made accusations concerning what I have said in this thread, unfounded accusations that you clearly cannot support. I've called you out on both, and you have avoided addressing either. Again, all I have been attempting to do is to convey the deepest, darkest, ugliest side of street fighting. There are folks out there whom, from your apparently sheltered existence, you simply cannot imagine. A word of warning, if you will. Guys who live for that stuff, who dearly enjoy harming others, and "dress appropriately". The boots, the rings, and so much more. Just one more example of what is out there: Motorcycle "club" guys have embraced the 16 oz ball peen hammer, because it's not legally a "weapon". Most are felons, and live in fear of a "felon in possession" charge, so they don't carry "weapons" that are legally defined as such. They used to carry a length of "spare chain", but now that most of their bikes are belt drive, that excuse is gone. These guys are creative... I could go on and on regarding what we might be up against if we are ever faced with defending ourselves against one of these psychos. And that is all I have been trying to do. Shine a little light into the darkest side of this. Why on Earth that has elicited the response I've seen from you is beyond me. You're taking this way, way too personally, getting all butt hurt, leading to your invalid assumptions and accusations in some ego driven need to "win" an argument that only you are having. And, in the end, not even man enough to address the false accusations you have leveled against me, nor the erroneous assumptions you have made about me. So, yes, you are acting like a real dick, for no apparent reason. |
I'd categorize that fight as "typical." More specifically, the subcategory would be "typical/Non-Boring." Most folks go down after a few punches. What is much more impressive is a good boxing match. In those, guys get hit many dozens of times. It is impressive how long they can remain standing under those conditions.
|
It's kind of dumb to be fighting over a discussion about fighting, with hypothetical situations and anecdotal stories galore. We've all seen what we've seen, (or not), and no one's mind is being changed over the effectiveness of one type or another.
I was once having an herbal tea at Urth Cafe with Mike Tyson, (true story), and I told him about the best street fighter I've ever seen back in Minneapolis. I'll keep the guy's name out of this but he was about 5'10" tall with long blond hair in a pony tail, average/athletic build and no one had ever seen him lose a fight. He did not cherry pick his opponents, some were almost twice his size and solid muscle. He had a mouth on him and loved to fight, all punching and his record in South Mpls. was something like 43-0 with 35 KOs. Ok, I made up the statistic but you get the idea. He could put together punches. I told Mike that the guy I'm talking about once told me, "the guy who wins is the guy who wants to win." Mike started nodding and told me that was completely true. :) |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
I should know it used to be a hobby of mine (still is LOL)
What I usually or try to do is when the other guy starts throwing punches. Block dodge, stay loose and don't get hit. After about 15 seconds he will slow right down. Probably got a big dumb grin on his face because he thinks he's winning. Fake a couple of lefts at him which he will try to block. Then clean him up with a massive right to the jaw. This flips his head in such a way that the brain switches off and he should hit the deck unconscious. If he doesn't drop he will be staggering around holding his face, then give him a huge kick in the middle of the chest. Nothing arty like you see in MMA, but rather like you would do when trying to kick a barn door open. Two things "Never show mercy to your enemies, and have fun out there." |
That’s not a fight that is a gang attack.
Regarding MMA guys, Fighting is what these they do. The only difference between these guys in the ring vs them on the street is that they would splatter your head on the pavement where no rules exist. These guys are no joke. |
Quote:
People make the mistake of assuming that just because a person is trained they have to play by the rules and that dirty fighting is only applicable to one side. The eye gouges, ball kicks, all that stuff, the trained fighter is more than capable and willing to do the same thing. We actually teach a class called "mean" street Jiu Jitsu where we drill moves to break someone's neck, fishhooks, all that good stuff. I grew up in Southern California around tons of gangs of all races and IMO the motorcycle guys don't start problems. Yes they will finish them and if you end up fighting one you best believe they may have weapons, but they don't go around starting crap with people. Most street fights are usually reserved to a younger demographic, typically in a group late in the evening near bars and alcohol. These are the guys that end up sucker punching and jumping you. |
Quote:
The perspective I have been trying to add is, admittedly, from the very extremes, from the nastiest, dirtiest end of the spectrum. A spectrum that ranges from some belligerent drunk in a bar to the most incredibly deranged, evil, fked up psychopaths the streets have to offer. While those of us who have some level of training (regardless of which particular martial art it may be, from boxing to JJ), would likely have no trouble with the former, the latter is a whole different ballgame, a level of insanity most of us (thank God) have never, and will never find ourselves facing. I thought it might be valuable to share a perspective on that. No more, no less. Why this "Rodsrsr" character took such an affront to that, why he felt the need to elevate this to "a fight about fighting" escapes me. There were no misrepresentations about what others had said, no false assumptions about others' experiences, no insults - none of that. It was a great discussion wherein we shared our experiences and perspectives. And then, God knows why, he started in with that nonsense. Just totally inexplicable to me. So, yeah, I'll insult him again - he was acting like a real dick. For no apparent reason. Maybe we can get back on track? |
Quote:
This has been my problem with your position (bolded above) you've been arguing extremes and I argue from generalities. You cant have a rational argument with extremes because as I mentioned before I can just go to the next extreme and say "the other has a gun" for example. Its silly to try and out-extreme each other. I deal in most general situations. Is is possible I can run into the deadliest psychopath guy with weapons the streets have to offer? Absolutely, but its just not very likely. Its similar to when women use rape & incest as an excuse to support abortions, but the reality is that only 1% account for this. This is what I call the extreme argument, and its usually when someone has difficulty supporting their position in a general sense. However I do understand how you may dismissive of BJJ because it sounds like you did some boxing back in the day when you were 18. During that time BJJ wasn't even around in the states so its likely you've never encountered a grappler so see first hand how defenseless you'd be once taken to the ground. Not meant to be an insult its just facts. Most of the guys here who get MMA understand the effectiveness of ground fighting. Fun Fact: Jiu Jitsu actually means "Gentle art" It means that the grappler has a level of control which will allow him subdue/submit his opponent without having to cause major harm like an eye gouge would for example. Those moves are done out of desperation and it wouldn't necessarily be something a good grappler would need to do as a go to... |
Quote:
And therein lies a problem I've pointed out several times already. I'm having a "discussion", and adding relevant information from a perspective most here have been fortunate enough to have never seen. You, however, believe you are engaged in an "argument", one which you feel you must "win". I'm not arguing anything, I'm merely adding information which I noticed others were not considering. In sharp contrast to my approach, you evidently feel some burning need to "prove" the "superiority" of your chosen skill. All I have been saying is that yes, that skill (and others) might serve you well against the "average" belligerent drunk. I've never denied that. I've agreed with that premise across this entire thread, and I fully understand that one skill set may be "better" than another when practitioners of each meet one another. I get it. But I wanted to add a dimension that had not yet been introduced, that I feel is worthy of consideration, regardless of how remote the possibility of encountering such a situation. Like I said, "worst case" is an integral part of any risk assessment. So, yeah, in that spirit, I have endeavored to point out that there is always the chance of meeting "that" guy, the guy I have been trying to describe to you, and warn you against. It would be a disservice, and "irrational", to not include my observations concerning this as a part of this discussion. Quote:
The only "position" (and it really isn't one by definition) I have stated is that "that guy" is out there. I have acknowledged that our chances of running into him are slim to none, virtually non-existent. But that doesn't mean he is not out there (in, unfortunately, greater numbers than we would like). It would be irrational to completely dismiss the possibility of being unfortunate enough to "meet" him. And, again, another very poor analogy. They are using misrepresented statistics to support their desire to change law, to persuade others to allow them to utilize abortion as a birth control option. In contrast, I'm not trying to persuade anyone into doing anything. I'm merely pointing out that this element of society exists, while suggesting any budding "street fighters" be aware of them and proceed accordingly. Big, big difference. Quote:
And, well, once again you demonstrate what has been a rather myopic view through this entire thread - you demonstrate the need, once again, to state BJJ's "superiority" over boxing. You simply cannot let go of that. Yet, with regards to this aspect of our discussion (and your argument), it's beyond irrelevant. That's the only thing you appear capable of taking away from this discussion - "my martial art is better than your martial art". We covered that earlier, in a different part of this discussion. It's not relevant to this part. The only thing I have had to say about any martial arts skill set is that they will do you no good if you are ever unfortunate enough to have to defend yourself against the type I have endeavored to describe. Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
You are not looking objectively at the way you communicate. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
All for what? "Winning the internet" today? All I've done is introduce some considerations regarding the worst side of street fighting, and you've gone completely off the rails. This is really, really getting weird... Edit: I see my old "sparring partner" chimed in while I was typing. MMA sux!!! ;) |
Quote:
Fair enough...waters can get a bit muddied when posting on a public forum with the intent to be directed at a specific person but not using the quote feature. :) No harm no foul. Good discussion overall though. Now its time to go train, gotta make 6:00 class. SmileWavy |
Quote:
Brother Bob K posted the Holm vs Rousey azz whoopin earlier in the thread, but while she had too much ego and too big of a mouth for me, I was a real fan of hers, so that fight result didn't delight me in that way. I have been a big fan of Holly since that point, however. <iframe width="640" height="360" src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/eGVxUHlsyWw" title="McGregor vs Diaz 1 | UFC 196 | Extended Highlights | • HD •" frameborder="0" allow="accelerometer; autoplay; clipboard-write; encrypted-media; gyroscope; picture-in-picture" allowfullscreen></iframe> <iframe width="640" height="360" src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/qvkfHv60YOw" title="Conor McGregor vs Dustin Poirier 2 Fight Highlights" frameborder="0" allow="accelerometer; autoplay; clipboard-write; encrypted-media; gyroscope; picture-in-picture" allowfullscreen></iframe> |
Quote:
Quote:
|
Quote:
<iframe width="640" height="360" src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/eQ1HQyj7_Wc" title="СЛОТ — Альфа Ромео + Бета Джульетта (Ин да хаос. Re-play)" frameborder="0" allow="accelerometer; autoplay; clipboard-write; encrypted-media; gyroscope; picture-in-picture" allowfullscreen></iframe> <iframe width="640" height="360" src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/FQkMbgq91W0" title="СЛОТ — 2 войны (Ин да хаос. Re-play)" frameborder="0" allow="accelerometer; autoplay; clipboard-write; encrypted-media; gyroscope; picture-in-picture" allowfullscreen></iframe> |
The only thing better than seeing Ronda Rousey get a beating is seeing McGregor getting one. Actually, it's a toss-up. They are both so hideous and overrated at the time. McGregor makes me embarrassed because he's Irish but isn't McGregor a Scottish name? That's what I'm going with. :)
Diaz is the schit, I love that guy. He is a stand-up dude from Fresno or something. |
As a fellow Irishman, Denis, I couldn't agree more. What an embarrassment. And yes, I believe McGregor is indeed a Scottish name, so at least there's that.
Still disappointing, though, in that there aren't many Irish sporting heroes to go around. As a child of the sixties, my favorite Irish fighter was one George Best. He made his fame and fortune, of course, as a striker for Manchester United, and even Pele himself called him "the best footballer the world has ever seen". But, well, he was an Irishman, from the "bad" part of town, and a renown bar fighter. Irish legend has it that he even kicked Bruce Lee's petulant ass in a bar fight one day. Who knows?... At the end of the day, though, all of the posturing and posing is all just a part of "the show", and their dedicated fans love that schitt. Keeps 'em tuning in so they can yell at their TVs and join in on the trash talk from the safety of their couch. I just see it as a part of the "pre-mating ritual". Two strutting, decorated roosters on full display, "sizing each other up" before our tatted up lovers start rolling around on the floor tea bagging each other. Most of these "fights" really aren't all that exciting to the average sports fan who divides his time between football, basketball, baseball, NASCAR, and others. So, in their quest to capture and hold the short attention span fans' interest, they have had to spice it up a bit with all of the nonsense we see today. Not all that far removed from WWF... Which is a shame, it does their real talent a disservice. |
| All times are GMT -8. The time now is 12:01 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.6.0
Copyright 2025 Pelican Parts, LLC - Posts may be archived for display on the Pelican Parts Website