jluetjen |
09-13-2006 11:35 AM |
Quote:
Originally posted by Jeff Higgins
You guys are all way off base. The greatest driver of all time is clearly John Force. He's won the most championships, hasn't he? Or Steve Kinser; he's won as many or more. Or Richard Petty, with the most race victories garnered by anyone.
|
I guess the issue that I have with that is that all of those guys were racing in essentially "National" series as opposed to an "International" series like F1.
Europe and Asia have little if any top fuel drag racing, nor any "Stock Car" racing built around 3600 lb 'merican sedans with 6 liter push-rod V8's or 1950's era formula cars with 6 liter push-rod V8's on dirt tracks. So 90% of the world is eliminated from being able to get even the most remedial experience in those formulae, let alone compete successfully. But everyone has series for formula cars on road courses. Just look at the number of FF and FV series across the world.
Force, Kinser and Petty are all great drivers, but they're not the best because they chose to be "big fish in a small sea". Gurney, Foyt, Andretti, Donohue, Al Unser Sr, and even D. Ernhart Sr. all chose to step out of the US tide-pool and try to compete on equal terms with the rest of the world at some point in their careers, and in all honesty, they all did pretty well.
But looking at the "Big Sea" that is F1, Shumacher has been able to beat all comers pretty regularly and decisively pretty much from the get-go, at a level that few except Mr. A. Prost have been able to accomplish. Except for his first year, he's also been somewhat lucky not to have another driver of his caliber to compete against. If Senna had lived longer, he undoubtibly would have taken some of the wins off of Schumacher's total. But Schumacher was still far more of the "total package" then Senna, and I suspect would have beaten Senna more often then not. But it would certainly have been a battle of titans! Imagine for a second what Prost's career would have been like if he hadn't competed against Lauda and Senna?
|