Atheism. Outlived its usefulness?

[Nathans_Dad]

Originally Posted by Jim Richards

Each group thinks their god(s) exist(s), and is the only correct god(s). The worship of other god(s) is deemed sinful and must be eradicated. Other than that...no worries.

While true, Jim, that doesn't answer the question.

Why does the discussion of whether a supreme being actually exists or not have any bearing on a discussion of what man has done in the name of religion?

To me, the two are completely separate issues. If they are, in fact, separate issues, then why does the hatred of man's attempt at organized religion bleed over into a discussion of whether a supreme being actually exists?

[trekkor]

Jim, why do you even mention the false gods?

There is only one true God.



KT

[dewolf]

Originally Posted by Nathans_Dad

Ok, so here we have it. Confirmation that at least this one atheist's motivation is past transgressions made by man in the name of God.
?

You are assuming I am an atheist now. How did you come to that conclusion? Assumptions, that's all GB's have.

[dewolf]

Originally Posted by trekkor

Jim, why do you even mention the false gods?

There is only one true God.



KT

According to YOU Trek. We've been over this crud before.

[Jim Richards]

Rick, because there are people that get fighting mad when you deny or discredit the unproven deity that they happen to worship. Take men out of the equation, and all you have left is the animal and plant kingdoms to discuss this topic. Hmmm...maybe that's what we have now.

[Jim Richards]

Originally Posted by trekkor

Jim, why do you even mention the false gods?

There is only one true God.



KT

No god. All are false. Well, unless Ra makes his appearance on PPOT.

[trekkor]

Originally Posted by dewolf

According to YOU Trek. We've been over this crud before.

Not just me.

You are outnumbered by 7 million

In over 235 lands all around the earth.



KT

[dewolf]

Originally Posted by trekkor

Not just me.

You are outnumbered by 7 million

In over 235 lands all around the earth.



KT

And you are outnumbered by 1 billion Muslims.

[Jim Richards]

Hmmm, where's my prayer blanket?

[dewolf]

Originally Posted by Jim Richards

Hmmm, where's my prayer blanket?

LOl, if they keep expanding as they are we'll all need one.

[stuartj]

Originally Posted by dewolf

According to YOU Trek. We've been over this crud before.

JWs have some wacky beliefs, its true. I know a half dozen, and they are all lovely people, collectively and individually- I suspect Trekkkor is too. But Ive fallen foul of mainstream believers for defending JWs. A friends wife went me with white hot poker one night not so long back for defending another friends wife (a JW, who according to her beliefs, did not attend a birthday celebration). She was fully cogniscient, and extremely critical of, the irrational nature of the JWs beliefs, but unable to apply the same criteria to her own (Methodist) beliefs.

And these people have much more in common in their beliefs than they do apart. I wonder if an Islamist, say, would generally even acknowledge the difference? And at end of the day- they would arguing over which of their supernatural delusions is superior.

[Taz's Master]

Originally Posted by Jim Richards

I remove faith in god because there is no evidence that one exists. Do you remove faith in Odin, or Thor, or Ra? How 'bout Zenu?

Jim, I am sorry that I cannot ask my questions in a way that makes them understandable, I wish I were a better communicator.

[Jim Richards]

No worries..there's plenty of time to work out the kinks in communication. Some of us have talked past each other for weeks.

[Pazuzu]

Originally Posted by Pazuzu

The problem is, Trekkor plays the same way back...he is just as guilty of attacking others beliefs as they are of attacking his. Therefore, he lost my respect. You don't do that, so you're still on my "list of OK God-guys "

Originally Posted by trekkor

I don't think you can produce a single example of what you accuse.
KT

Originally Posted by trekkor

Jim, why do you even mention the false gods?
There is only one true God.
KT

Originally Posted by trekkor

Not just me.
You are outnumbered by 7 million
In over 235 lands all around the earth.
KT

Thank you for saving me the effort of looking for an example. You just told him that he is an idiot, a liar, and that 7 million (which seems an exceptionally small number...) are better than him.

No, you NEVER attack anyone.

But I will say, that last post was one of the longest I've seen you post. It still had nothing personal or original, but at least you're working on the substance.

[trekkor]

That's quite a stretch ( and an imagination ).


KT

[Pazuzu]

Originally Posted by trekkor

That's quite a stretch ( and an imagination ).
KT

If you told me that there were 7 million people in 235 countries that were not only more knowledgeable than me, but also BETTER than me concerning my belief system? All while saying that I was outright WRONG about what I BELIEVE???

I'd consider that an attack.

Maybe you're just not AWARE that you're doing it. well, here's your wake up call. If you REALLY HONESTLY don't intend on attacking people here, then you need to readjust the way you post in these threads.

[trekkor]

I'd consider that an attack.

Sorry, sir.

You are wrong. That's not an attack. That's a fact.

I was told I was all alone in my belief and I stated that there are 7 million all over the worls that believe as I do.

That's not an attack. It's called a statement of fact.


Please don't smear me.


KT

[JavaBrewer]

KT, pulled this off a website regarding how JW interpret the "end of days". Is this what the JW really believe? If not then please feel free to correct the paragraph.

Disfellowshipped Jehovah's Witnesses, Jews, Muslims, most Christians, and followers of other religions will be exterminated. The WTS teaches that only active adults in good standing of the Jehovah's Witnesses will survive the killing fields. The fate of children and of mentally disadvantaged adults will be up to God

Edit. Maybe this belongs in the Armageddon thread...

[dewolf]

Originally Posted by trekkor

Sorry, sir.

I was told I was all alone in my belief and I stated that there are 7 million all over the worls that believe as I do.

KT

I never said you were all alone. When did I say that? I said according to YOU. Should I have said, according to your religion? I think you know what I meant, just you being you I guess.

I guess your members aren't doing such a good job convincing people yours is the one true religion:

"However, there has been a decline in growth rates, from over 8% per annum in the mid 1970s, to 5% per annum in the mid 1990s, to about 2%–3% per annum since 1999"

[Taz's Master]

Originally Posted by Jim Richards

No worries..there's plenty of time to work out the kinks in communication. Some of us have talked past each other for weeks.

Then I will try again.

If I hold multiple beliefs that have no foundation in scientific evidence, does that make them all irrational, and should they be discarded?