Pelican Parts Forums

Pelican Parts Forums (http://forums.pelicanparts.com/)
-   Off Topic Discussions (http://forums.pelicanparts.com/off-topic-discussions/)
-   -   Why carry a gun? (http://forums.pelicanparts.com/off-topic-discussions/435060-why-carry-gun.html)

competentone 10-11-2008 05:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Oh Haha (Post 4232911)
Competentone:

I don't think carrying a FE in a vehicle is the same as a gun. I guess you could spray the bad guy with it but...


I know myself well enough that if I did carry, it could all go wrong quickly on the wrong day in the wrong mood.

Oh, I am not against guns or folks having them. My dad had a .38 he carried when he was younger and in repo business in Flint in the early 60's. We did not hunt or even target shoot when we were kids. On the other hand, my wife has been around hunting rifles her entire life and has taken several deer.

I appreciate your honesty, guys.

I think you kind-of missed my point.

Let me explain: I carry a fire extinguisher in my car (and keep one in my home) even though I recognize that the odds of me ever needing it, to put out a fire, are extremely small. If I do need it though, it may very well be a matter of life-and-death.

I carry a firearm wherever possible and keep one accessible in my home. I recognize that the odds of me ever needing one are quite small, but I know that if a situation arises where I do need one, it will be a matter of life-and-death.

I'd rather have a firearm available most of the time and not need it, rather than not have one available when I really need one.

If you, personally, feel that you might shoot someone unprovoked (I'm referring to your comment "it could all go wrong quickly on the wrong day in the wrong mood), I will compliment you on understanding your own propensity toward "rage" and your precautions in assuring you won't hurt someone with a firearm you had in your possession.

Personally, I can have bad days and be in bad moods, but the thought of using a firearm against even someone who provoked me, with anything less than potentially lethal force, simply does not enter my consciousness. Even if confronted by a potentially deadly threat, my first reaction will be to "Get the hell away from the threat!" not try to confront the threatening person with my firearm.

I learned at a very early age -- from bullies on the school bus -- that there are (sadly) people in this world who are just plain mean. I see a firearm, particularly a handgun, as an extremely practical tool which I can use to defend myself against one, or multiple numbers, of those "just plain mean" people if any of them decide to attack me.

I wish I lived in a world where I could determine that the probabilities of me needing a firearm were so low, that it didn't make sense to actually carry one, but I look at the world as it is and live my life as I determine I need to based upon what I see around me.

I live in a nice neighborhood and town, but every week, within walking distance from my home there are robberies and other crimes of violence. I can't stop such things from happening, but can take precautions in case they happen to me.

Hugh R 10-11-2008 05:12 PM

Can't and don't carry in El Aye. I did carry for a few days after the Rodney King Riots.

Rick Lee 10-11-2008 05:16 PM

I carry just about all the time. I usually leave it in the car when I go to a restaurant that serves alcohol, but not always. The only gun-free zones I always observe are those where I see a metal detector. I always open-carry on my motorcycle. I have never come close to unholstering. The one time I needed a gun, I was in NJ, where I can't carry. I had a knife pulled on me, but was able to get to my car before they decided to chase me. Had that happened anywhere other than 10' from my car in a deserted parking lot, I would have been in real trouble. No doubt those thugs have done the same to others, since they did not get shot by me and the cops didn't care at all when I reported it.

Today I rode a 175 mile route through Prescott Nat. Forest. I saw few cars and I was way, way out in the middle of nowhere. No one was gonna help me if I got into trouble, either by stumbling upon a meth lab or a hungry mountain lion. I carry because I refuse to rely on dial-a-prayer 911 and police response times to save my butt. If it were illegal to carry, I'd just do it extra concealed. All the usual sayings come to mind here - I'd rather be judged by 12 than carried by six and I'd rather have it and not need it than need it and not have it.

Rick Lee 10-11-2008 05:19 PM

BTW, I've never heard of a single case of a legal CCW'er using their carry gun to commit a crime. All those warnings have never materialized.

Oh Haha 10-11-2008 05:21 PM

Well put, Competentone. I understand what you meant now.

VaSteve 10-11-2008 05:24 PM

You know Rick...I was up in Shenandoah last weekend and thought about you then. You can be pretty alone out there. I read about some guy that killed a couple of people on the AT 20 years ago, and did it again recently. I took a trip out west about 9 years ago. I was mountain bike through the middle of nowhere in Moab, but myself. What a stupid idea. Hell I used to do it all the time in GA. I was scared of a Deliverence episode then. I can see why you'd wanna carry out there in BFE....I just read an article about people running huge pot operations on public land. Irrigation and everything. I'd hate to find that **** by accident and not be protected in some fashion.

Interestingly enough, I don't think I have ever shot a real gun.

VaSteve 10-11-2008 05:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by competentone (Post 4232944)
I live in a nice neighborhood and town, but every week, within walking distance from my home there are robberies and other crimes of violence. I can't stop such things from happening, but can take precautions in case they happen to me.

I live in a decent neighborhood as well...this happened this week. :eek::eek::eek::eek:

http://www.nbc4.com/news/17653569/detail.html

Rick Lee 10-11-2008 05:32 PM

I've been out riding on trails here where nothing but a dirt bike or a helicopter could come to get you. It's amazingly remote and desolate. First time I took an offroad ride here, I made to a general store about 20 miles from any pavement. Every single male I saw there was openly wearing a sidearm. There must have been about 50 folks there with quads or bike. All openly armed. Funny how I never heard about any shootouts because of that.

Rick V 10-11-2008 05:34 PM

You will never meet a politer bunch than at a shooting range..................think about it.

onewhippedpuppy 10-11-2008 05:49 PM

Interesting thread, lots of good points on both side. I don't have my CCW, but will probably get it in the near future. I've never wished I had a gun while outside my home, but I'd also prefer to never be in that situation. I'd mostly like to legally carry inside my car, especially when going to unknown areas.

A shooting outside my rental duplex prompted my gun purchase. I never want to be in the situation of not being able to defend my family.

MT930 10-11-2008 05:49 PM

You just never know what you may run across.

If you have a weapon you have one more option that you wished you had with out it.

nostatic 10-11-2008 05:55 PM

I don't agree with the fire extinguisher analogy - it trivializes the gun. They do not equate in application or need. There is no downside to having a fire extinguisher and using it in public. There are huge possible downsides to having a gun and using it in public.

I don't carry, don't have a nightstand gun, and don't plan to do either in the foreseeable future. I just do not live in that state of fear. ymmv.

Civil unrest? Totally different ball o' wax...

Tobra 10-11-2008 06:21 PM

I always liked my wife to carry when she was doing home health nursing.

Only even showed it to one person, one of her drivers, who was appalled she would even go to the 'hood she was in, telling her not to get out of her car until he got there.

She did have it in her hand one time, when approached by some road rager in a shirt and tie, who beat on her window, cursing voluminously. He got to talk about his manners to several large hispanic men changing a tire on the shoulder who had precipitated the traffic jam in the first place.

"How would you feel if someone talked to your mother like that?"

My wife, "I don't have any kids"

"Sister, whatever, are you all right ma'am?"

She was, so she drove away, with the pale man talking about how women should be treated"

VaSteve 10-11-2008 06:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by nostatic (Post 4233065)

Civil unrest? Totally different ball o' wax...


Go read in the PARF forum. :)

andytheturtle 10-11-2008 07:19 PM

Even if there is one person in a million that would kill you in cold blood, there is 6,000 people in this world that would still do so. My safety is worth more then a scum bags life. case closed.

Hugh R 10-11-2008 07:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by nostatic (Post 4233065)
Civil unrest? Totally different ball o' wax...

IIRC you own heat. So do I. In El Aye when the big bell rings, like a 7.8, things are going to go to crap real fast. Nothing like the Northridge Earthquake which in the big picture was really nothing. Three things you need food, water and something to protect the first two. At my employer one thing they tell you, besides having some long distance walking shoes, a hat, coat and emergency supplies in the trunk of your car in a backpack ,is that after the BIG BIG Bell rings, people who see you two days later still hiking home with a backpack will instantly know what you have in your backpack and try to take it from you.

red-beard 10-11-2008 07:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dd74 (Post 4232888)
The only time I've thought I needed to carry a gun, oddly enough, is when I'm cycling. Why? I'm an easy target for anyone who might want to 1) inflict their road rage on me/challenge me to a fight; 2) steal money, credit cards, ID, etc; 3) steal my bike. And yes, it's true, people have intentionally tried to run into me. I've been pushed off my bike while riding. I've even been shot at. A trucker tried to do a Terminator on me by coming after me with his semi. Great stuff!

Even today, I watched a guy on a Harley that was far too large for him, nearly wipe out on sharp mountain turn. I was on my bike, just passing by, and he shouts at me, "What the **** are you looking at?" Now what if that guy wants to come after me? Other than sheer speed, dropping my bike and getting out of the clips with my fists up, I have no recourse.

So, yes, I've seen and considered small .38s, even a .40 caliber that could easily fit in a zipper back jersey pocket. But here's the thing: the sweat there can't be good for the weapon. Secondly, the time it would take to bring the gun out to defend myself would definitely give my adversary an advantage.

Anyway, that's the only time I would carry one. I know there are other cyclists in Los Angeles with much the same thought.

IIRC, it's how they roll in Colombia: the national team there never rides unarmed. Why? Road bandits who steal and sell the bicycle parts on the black market.

I carry my .380 when I'm cycling. I'm more concerned with animals than humans. And yes, some of the areas I cycle through I've been concerned someone would take my $2500 worth of cycling equipment.

As far as sweat is concerned, I clean the pistol at least bi-monthly. It is in a small case, but it is not water proof. I have at times put a piece of plastic in between.

red-beard 10-11-2008 07:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by andytheturtle (Post 4233204)
Even if there is one person in a million that would kill you in cold blood, there is 6,000 people in this world that would still do so. My safety is worth more then a scum bags life. case closed.

We had 500 murders last year, and 4,000,000 residents. So the odds are not 1 in a million but one in 8000.

Think about it.

Jeff Higgins 10-11-2008 07:53 PM

I find it interesting to hear from so many that don't carry because they have done a fair assessment of their own personalities, and have determined that they would be more likely to escalate a situation if they were armed. My personal assessment runs the other way. I was a pretty fair fighter (boxer) in my day, and carried the confidence that came from that. And, admittedly, the b.s. ego that came along with it. Combine that with an innate stubborn bull-headedness intrinsic to an Irish/German make-up, and we are talking a recipe for trouble.

Not so since I started carrying. I go an extra measure out of my way to avoid anything that even starts to smell of a confrontation. I'm too old and slow to fight anymore. I would say "too wise", but you guys know better... That, and I don't feel as though I should have to. When the chips are really down, I no longer feel any need to risk personal injury (or to prove myself). I'll be looking for overwhelming force to end the situation as decisively as possible with as minimal risk to me as possible.

Another reason I carry is simply because I can. It's symbolic. Only free men get to do this. It's like voting; I will never take either for granted, and will exercise both rights until the day I die. Others have died so that I can do that. There is nothing I can ever do to repay them; I know that. Exercising the rights they have secure for me makes me think of them, makes me remember what they have done for me. And keeps me vigilant against those who would impinge upon those rights.

Hugh R 10-11-2008 07:57 PM

Thinking about my own post, I'm going to think about putting one of my small calibers in the trunk of my car with my earthquake backpack.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 05:43 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.6.0
Copyright 2025 Pelican Parts, LLC - Posts may be archived for display on the Pelican Parts Website


DTO Garage Plus vBulletin Plugins by Drive Thru Online, Inc.