why goalies should keep their helmets on

[teenerted1]

Goalie Fight Video: Brent Johnson's 1-punch KO of Rick DiPietro - Puck Daddy - NHL* - Yahoo! Sports

[enzo1]

gotta watch for those LEFTIES ...

[UconnTim97]

ooops, it looks like he will be out 4-6 weeks. That can only help the Isle.

[Red88Carrera]

In what other team sport is that kind of crap allowed to happen?

[billybek]

Originally Posted by Red88Carrera

In what other team sport is that kind of crap allowed to happen?

Basketball, football, baseball, footy, lacrosse.......

[dentist90]

At the All Star "game" last week, the players voted 98% in favour of fighting in the NHL. Seems that most of these testosterone-soaked twentysomething macho dudes actually enjoy this. Go figure...

[scottbombedout]

Single punch can kill. What would happen then?

[Red88Carrera]

Originally Posted by billybek

Basketball, football, baseball, footy, lacrosse.......

Try having a duke-fest at any of these events and see what happens. Heavy fines and/or suspensions. Why is it allowed at NHL games. It's just because the game is so boring they need to encourage this behavior to promote interest in the game.

[rhogg]

From the article: DiPietro "has a hell of a bruise brewing on his right cheekbone" and said of Johnson: "He has long arms."

Fighting is part of the game, and if you think hockey is boring you must be watching the Leafs.

[ben parrish]

Relax Francis...it's hockey.

Don't like the fights, don't watch. Bet you boys with a problem got your butt whipped in a fist fight somewhere along the way.

I got clocked one time by a guy with a suprise left. My eyelid is still torn from it. His nose is still crooked from my response. We were fourteen...29 years later we still laugh about it. Silly kids.

[Red88Carrera]

Originally Posted by rhogg

Fighting is part of the game

That's the reason I don't watch it. Why not allow these antics in the NFL, NBA, or MLB?

[billybek]

Originally Posted by Red88Carrera

Try having a duke-fest at any of these events and see what happens. Heavy fines and/or suspensions. Why is it allowed at NHL games. It's just because the game is so boring they need to encourage this behavior to promote interest in the game.

Not that I am promoting fighting in hockey but it is a more intense game while playing than most sports and occasionally fighting is an outlet for the pressure.
You are correct in that it is a tool used by the teams to entertain fans during an otherwise dull game and also to invoke a change in momentum. Fighting can be considered to be a form of self policing too.
There are extra penalties for instigating and fines for when they are doing really stupid stuff just like other team sports.
You don't see bench clearing brawls in hockey anymore, but baseball there seems to be more than just a few every season. All it seems to take is a few brush back pitches and a few hit batters.
If you think that hockey is boring, then maybe you shouldn't watch the Islanders play!

[Roosterrusek]

Originally Posted by Red88Carrera

That's the reason I don't watch it. Why not allow these antics in the NFL, NBA, or MLB?

LOL, because the antics of the NFL, NBA and MLB revolve around steroids, gang signs, steroids and illegimate children. That and spousal abuse....just sayin.

[Red88Carrera]

Tough crowd here... or pretty sensitive when it comes to their hockey.
I agree that all professional sports have their bad side. This is different. The rules for fighting in the NHL are written right in the rule book. This essentially allows it, but puts parameters around how it is done. Nice way to promote team participation and athleticism at a family outing. I would probably watch the game if it weren't for the fights. This is in direct contrast to why the league allows it. It is amazing to watch a skilled player, but I just don't have the patience for the BS attempt at marketing the sport through brawling.

[pksystems]

That wasn't much of a fight at all. Dipietro better take it easy.... I think he only has 18 years left on his guaranteed contract

[1990C4S]

Every game that DiPietro misses helps the Isle. He is an anchor on the team finances and insurance kicks in when he's hurt.

He has played about 20% of the games since he signed the long term contract. Can you say 'fragile'?

[1990C4S]

Originally Posted by Red88Carrera

In what other team sport is that kind of crap allowed to happen?

The league has determined they would have fewer fans if they banned fighting. So be it, they choose to run their business as they see fit.

Ever, and I mean EVER, seen a crowd boo a fight? The paying masses stand and applaud, as do the players, and most people at home. Fighting makes money.

[1990C4S]

Originally Posted by scottbombedout

Single punch can kill. What would happen then?

What will happen? It's not 'if', it's 'when'.

It has happened locally, just not NHL. Yet.

Two 250 (plus) lb guys square of on skates, and without helmets. Who is going to testify this was unforeseen?

[Red88Carrera]

Originally Posted by 1990C4S

The league has determined they would have fewer fans if they banned fighting. So be it, they choose to run their business as they see fit.

Ever, and I mean EVER, seen a crowd boo a fight? The paying masses stand and applaud, as do the players, and most people at home. Fighting makes money.

That's pretty much what I've already stated.
So once again the almighty dollar wins, over teaching good values. Shoot me now please.

[RoninLB]

Hockey players think they're tougher in a fight than they are

they built a pro rink here in LB and local kids would beat the crap out of them in bars for saying stuff like "I can eat her better that you" to a small guy with his girlfriend