Pelican Parts Forums

Pelican Parts Forums (http://forums.pelicanparts.com/)
-   Off Topic Discussions (http://forums.pelicanparts.com/off-topic-discussions/)
-   -   What lifetime benefits do wounded/disabled vets get? (http://forums.pelicanparts.com/off-topic-discussions/896857-what-lifetime-benefits-do-wounded-disabled-vets-get.html)

Rick Lee 12-31-2015 05:30 PM

What lifetime benefits do wounded/disabled vets get?
 
Mrs. Lee just asked me this after seeing one of the ubiquitous Wounded Warrior Project commercials. She couldn't believe vets wouldn't get all the gov't. assistance they need, having been wounded while serving in the military. I kind of wonder this myself. Are their rehab and healthcare needs taken care of for life? If they're disabled, what kind of payments do they get and for how long?

allaircooled 12-31-2015 05:48 PM

I'm 20% disabled and get a payment of $265 or something like that once a month. Buddy of mine was 30% or so but he got medically retired so he still has his ID and base privileges, plus a check every month.

tevake 12-31-2015 06:17 PM

Had hepatitis at the end of AIT, then Malaria while in Nam. All with in 18 mos. time of service.
Got 10% for one year only. But do qualify for V A medical services. After recontacting them a few years ago.

Still have minor impacts, but not bad

I sure hope current returning vets get the treatment they need. I think they do encounter a little better approach/ attitude from the V A. These days. If sometimes too long a wait for treatment. Get in line.

Cheers Richard

M.D. Holloway 12-31-2015 09:03 PM

My Dad gets a couple hundred a month plus he could get med treatment at a VA hospital.

flatbutt 01-01-2016 07:12 AM

My older brother was exposed to Agent Orange in Nam and VA covered all of his cancer treatment. He also gets a small monthly check and property tax relief. He is content with it all.

My Dad had VA medical through all of his troubles. And since Dad was a combat veteran my Mom gets a small housing subsidy from VA.

afterburn 549 01-01-2016 07:32 AM

To answer your question- it all becomes a bureaucratic hurdle and to put it bluntly, impossible for some Vets to do or cope with.
Getting a monetary anything can be a 10-year endeavour. ( or longer )
Next for anything specialized from the VA , one might as well forget it.
Go to the Civilian side like "Wounded Vets" ETC and get the help.
Each VA hosp has its own SOP.
Some are excellent, others could care less.
I got asked to leave the VA hosp in Seattle in about 1978. ( Agent Orange Problems )\They did not care

gamin 01-01-2016 09:33 AM

I get emotional when I think about this problem. We should not need a wounded warrior project to take care of our vets period. It exists because of the abject failure of the VA to do it's promised job and the failure of the congress we elect to hold their feet to the fire. Wounded warrior project and like organizations are symptoms of gross failure. These young men with brain trauma and loss of limbs deserve better. It's more than 20% disability. We owe them big time.

Rick V 01-01-2016 09:41 AM

The treatment of our Vets is deplorable. Anyone looking for any kind of assistance for the job they do or has done should work for congress, they is where the big benefits package is.
Thank you to all who have put on a uniform regardless of the outcome of your service, it means a lot to me

Rick Lee 01-01-2016 09:41 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by gamin (Post 8939612)
I get emotional when I think about this problem. We should not need a wounded warrior project to take care of our vets period.

I agree. I see these commercials and wonder why those charities are necessary. I find it hard to believe our gov't. doesn't make vets whole in some way or another. A few hundred dollars a month won't even make a dent in prescription drugs for seriously disabled vets. Why is the VA even a cabinet level dept. if this is still going on?

crustychief 01-01-2016 09:45 AM

I am also at 20% and get the 200 ish check from the Gov't.

Rick Lee 01-01-2016 09:48 AM

Why doesn't the VA just buy private longterm disability insurance for every soldier? It would have to be cheaper than what they do now and would pay a lot more benefits.

MBAtarga 01-01-2016 10:07 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rick Lee (Post 8939633)
Why doesn't the VA just buy private longterm disability insurance for every soldier? It would have to be cheaper than what they do now and would pay a lot more benefits.

Do you realize how many government jobs that would make obsolete?

afterburn 549 01-01-2016 10:16 AM

The VA is another Fat pork project that gives the insiders a LOT of Cash.
I got a letter late 1970 early 1980s NOT to have kids! ( I worked with a lot of Agent Orange) Now years later, they find out the stuff causes genetic defects!
It screws up one's whole life .
Did they offer me a disability of any kind ?
NO!
No kids for me, no feelings in ANY end things on my body, fingers, toes nose etc. (Plus a LOT of other problems)
There is no compensation that can fix me, Yet I by far do not have it as bad as the current batch of Vets who have to been put on a roundy round war with no end in sight.
They are sure to get wounded at some point .
like said they get minimum treatment.
However a congressman gets full bennies and retirement.
They take care of themselves FIRST !
Tell me again, Why are people pissed ?

jyl 01-01-2016 10:28 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rick Lee (Post 8939633)
Why doesn't the VA just buy private longterm disability insurance for every soldier? It would have to be cheaper than what they do now and would pay a lot more benefits.

Have you looked into that? Private LTD insurance requires a lot of underwriting, would that be a problem for this population (if you were an insurer, would you write any insurance to a guy potentially headed to a war zone?) It doesn't include any medical coverage. Disability benefits require full inability to work (no partial), and end at retirement age. If you have actually run the numbers, I'd be interested to see them.

Seahawk 01-01-2016 10:41 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jyl (Post 8939687)
If you have actually run the numbers, I'd be interested to see them.

I have run the numbers, actually, and they do not work out in Rick's favor.

I negotiated a lot of support contracts for civilian employees in drone ops from 2004 to 2009, everything from land ops to sea ops.

Our single most expensive item(s) was personal insurance: Life, health, death etc.

The comparison is not between military members eligible for retirement, rather a straight look at the numbers in situ, direct costs, for deploying personnel.

I have not seen a straight line analysis of the cost of the VA (inclusive) infrastructure versus private care. I will do some digging.

A cost of war: Soaring disability benefits for veterans - Apr. 27, 2012

tevake 01-01-2016 10:45 AM

I hear you LOUD AND CLEAR Afterburn, our returning vets are in no condition to have to fight the burocresy for the help they need. And should not have to considering the $$s put into the V A. This is a stain on our nation!

Hell just look what's is done to my speeling

BE911SC 01-01-2016 11:00 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by gamin (Post 8939612)
I get emotional when I think about this problem. We should not need a wounded warrior project to take care of our vets period. It exists because of the abject failure of the VA to do it's promised job and the failure of the congress we elect to hold their feet to the fire. Wounded warrior project and like organizations are symptoms of gross failure. These young men with brain trauma and loss of limbs deserve better. It's more than 20% disability. We owe them big time.

Just like the NYC 9-11 first responders, we pay them all the (free) lip service we can and then slam the door in their faces in the halls of congress. One congressman explained to the 9-11 first responders that they themselves had to find the money in the budget for funding any legislation meant to help them.

Corporations are now people and congress now acts like a corporation. Make us help you. Otherwise, we'll shut the door in your face.

fintstone 01-01-2016 02:06 PM

A lot of folks drawing some sort of VA disability have little wrong with them or problems that really do not affect their ability to work (just like disabled from other parts of society). I work with many folks every day the served a few years and receive disability (who have a lot less physical problems than I do).

If you are clearly disabled from military service now, you get pretty decent care and compensation IMHO. The problem is that you can't really compensate someone who lost a limb, eyesight, etc.). Folks who only get a few bucks each month now do so because they are general considered able to work although they may need some accommodation. Many serve a full career in the military and get a military pension and VA disability. Lots of them never were in combat but just have a bad back, etc. Women are much more likely to be disabled...most often for having a noncombat injury or illness (like a hysterectomy).

Wounded warrior is really not about basic care, but rather more concerned with nontraditional means to reintegrate wounded veterans into society (including those with no visible injury). A lot suffer from depression etc.. Face it, there are a lot of folks who have not served that are suicidal and/or unable to reintegrate into society. Having a serious traumatic injury is not exactly the stuff dreams are made of. Especially for someone in their late teens or early 20's when they are usually much more concerned with physical ability and appearance than us old folks. Wounded Warrior also does advocacy for veterans who are having difficulty receiving appropriate benefits.

A lot more badly injured soldiers survive their wound now due to better battlefield medicine, evacuation capability (generally no enemy aircraft after initial day or two of war) and body armor.

While I appreciate the program, I hate the commercials as they sometime paint veterans a pitiful and helpless. Most, injured or otherwise, are just the opposite of that.

Nickshu 01-01-2016 02:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by fintstone (Post 8939977)
A lot of folks drawing some sort of VA disability have little wrong with them or problems that really do not affect their ability to work (just like disabled from other parts of society). I work with many folks every day the served a few years and receive disability (who have a lot less physical problems than I do).

If you are clearly disabled from military service now, you get pretty decent care and compensation IMHO. The problem is that you can't really compensate someone who lost a limb, eyesight, etc.). Folks who only get a few bucks each month now do so because they are general considered able to work although they may need some accommodation. Many serve a full career in the military and get a military pension and VA disability. Lots of them never were in combat but just have a bad back, etc. Women are much more likely to be disabled...most often for having a noncombat injury or illness (like a hysterectomy).

Wounded warrior is really not about basic care, but rather more concerned with nontraditional means to reintegrate wounded veterans into society (including those with no visible injury). A lot suffer from depression etc.. Face it, there are a lot of folks who have not served that are suicidal and/or unable to reintegrate into society. Having a serious traumatic injury is not exactly the stuff dreams are made of. Especially for someone in their late teens or early 20's when they are usually much more concerned with physical ability and appearance than us old folks. Wounded Warrior also does advocacy for veterans who are having difficulty receiving appropriate benefits.

A lot more badly injured soldiers survive their wound now due to better battlefield medicine, evacuation capability (generally no enemy aircraft after initial day or two of war) and body armor.

While I appreciate the program, I hate the commercials as they sometime paint veterans a pitiful and helpless. Most, injured or otherwise, are just the opposite of that.

Well said. The process is very bureaucratic and cumbersome. Unfortunately it has become this way in part due to large bureaucracy, but also due to people who have milked and abused the system. Our veterans deserve the very best, but as you said how do you compensate someone? There are many factors going on here, secondary gain, emotional distress, things that really can't be compensated for and expectations are never met. Much could be done to improve the health system veterans get, but many don't realize how many people are in the system trying to get benefits for things that have nothing to do with "in the line of duty" sickness or injury. It was only a few years ago the VA stopped giving distability benefits for hemorrhoids. "Well the Army made me sit down lot, so it's their fault I have hemmorhoids 20 years later"....really? It's a tough job the VA has, to separate the BS from those who truly are eligible for help, in their defense they have a very tough job. But I agree they could do it a lot better.

To answer the OP's question, at the time of discharge everyone is supposed to go thru a VA screening process that is a comprehensive physical exam, review of records, etc which determines what, if any, health problems were related to being in the military. For those items one can earn disability payments if it's above a certain percentage on the disability scale, as well as health care for anything related to that injury for life. I believe recipients of the Purple Heart get full VA benefits for life as a benefit of the award.

afterburn 549 01-01-2016 03:04 PM

Govt does what is best for them , not the soldiers.
They have the best of the best, They dont pay social security.
They dont have to mess with AHC
Also they Get full retirement with no risk .
Fly around for free ( on our money ) on private jets.
They spend more on launch then what they spend on any vet in a month .
When I got back from Nam I could not figure out why the big guys would not hire me.
Turns out there was a trick number attached to the coveted honorable discharge. ( DD214)
They tried to wash the Viet Vet soldiers dwn the drains of society.
I don't know what they are doing to the soldiers of the latest wars, But I am sure it something disgusting.

rcooled 01-01-2016 03:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by fintstone (Post 8939977)
A lot of folks drawing some sort of VA disability have little wrong with them...

A friend of mine broke his foot while in the Army because he was smoking opium while on guard duty in Vietnam and fell out of a guard tower. He was put on 10% disability and has been receiving a check for a little over $200/mo. since 1970. He called it his 'foot check'. He then got wind of the Agent Orange controversy and badgered the VA thru his congressman (himself a disabled vet) for compensation and was granted 100% disability. He never even saw any Agent Orange but was briefly stationed at a firebase where it was stockpiled. He does have some heart issues, which may or may not be related to this, but all things considered, he's in fairly decent health. He never did tell me how much he receives now, but he was able to pay off several debts and buy a small house in Florida during the 'Great Recession' for cash. His story may not be typical, but there are people milking the VA in much the same way as those who are milking the welfare system.

On the other hand, as a veteran myself, I strongly support any policies aimed at getting veterans who truly need it all the help & resources necessary to make their transition back into society as easy as possible. Especially in light of all the money our government pisses away on welfare cheats and other misguided endeavors.

fintstone 01-01-2016 04:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by afterburn 549 (Post 8940025)
Govt does what is best for them , not the soldiers.
They have the best of the best, They dont pay social security.
They dont have to mess with AHC
Also they Get full retirement with no risk .
Fly around for free ( on our money ) on private jets.
They spend more on launch then what they spend on any vet in a month .
When I got back from Nam I could not figure out why the big guys would not hire me.
Turns out there was a trick number attached to the coveted honorable discharge. ( DD214)
They tried to wash the Viet Vet soldiers dwn the drains of society.
I don't know what they are doing to the soldiers of the latest wars, But I am sure it something disgusting.

I understand your annoyance/pain with the VA system, but most of what you post about "Govt" is currently incorrect. They pay social security, (Don't know what AHC is), They get full retirement after 30 years work, they generally don't fly around for free (except for work), etc. The military has a much better benefits package.

afterburn 549 01-01-2016 05:26 PM

I was focusing on congress .

fintstone 01-01-2016 05:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by afterburn 549 (Post 8940146)
I was focusing on congress .

Most benefits that people believe they have are not accurate. They currently have essentially the same retirement, benefits, etc. as civil service. They even pay social security since 1984. They don't fly for free, etc. (unless on business). They do generally get free parking.

Drbraunsr 01-01-2016 06:06 PM

Whatever it is....it's not enough.

afterburn 549 01-01-2016 06:12 PM

Ok
I am wrong.
Is good to know

afterburn 549 01-01-2016 06:18 PM

Back on point-If one goes to the VA and sees some of the guys there.....there is no amount of money I would want or trade for their problems.
When we all signed on to uncle Sam, we just presumed if we got shot to hell we would live or die,End.
That there would be no in between.
There is a LOT of in between.
Experience is a HELL of a teacher .

flyenby 01-01-2016 06:18 PM

100% disabled if you are single 2907.00 per month tax free, all medical free, property tax deduction. Free state and national park pass. Px access on base to shop.Children under 27 , education benefits 1k per month for 48 months, 12 units are more...tax free

afterburn 549 01-01-2016 06:22 PM

How much money did the POS president just give to Iran?

fintstone 01-01-2016 06:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by afterburn 549 (Post 8940189)
Ok
I am wrong.
Is good to know

I am not sticking up for them. I just want us to be accurate regarding their compensation for serving. It distracts from real issues. Many are still dirt bags and make a fortune on insider trading and selling influence.

The real issue in this thread is disabled vets and how poorly many have been treated. Although, as noted... there are some that scam the system, I just don't know how a grateful nation could ever find a way to compensate some of the seriously disabled or killed. I do know that I am forever grateful to those who have sacrificed so much hope we are doing everything possible to help them (and their families) as much as possible to live a normal and fulfilling life.

flyenby 01-01-2016 06:39 PM

When I got back from 14 months in Vietnam....Infantry, all I recieved was the finger..as in get F#CKED.....

fintstone 01-01-2016 06:55 PM

Yep, the same for my brother. He returned to a nation that did not respect or appreciate his sacrifice in the least. Nothing but the GI Bill, and he had a family to feed, so it was wasted on him. He had problems adjusting to civilian life and was burdened with personal issues for many years. The folks who did not go had seniority in most employment and when the big recession/stagflation of the 70's came along, they were the first let go.

It is shameful how this nation treated Vietnam and Korean vets. It is a bit better now, because there are not so many (which makes it easier), they are volunteers (which changes /motivation a bit for most) and some of the veteran hiring preference programs, etc. make a pretty good impact on the veteran population.

tevake 01-01-2016 06:58 PM

That sounds like my memories too, Flyenby . And Afterburn comments ring true also.
For me the mental / emotional adjustments took a long five + years of focused personal effort. And trying to deal with the V A at the time seemed like trying to sign on with an insurance co. That was intent in screening out any potentionaly costly patients.

Those were different times, and a very different social atmosphere to come home to.

My concerns for these returning vets is the unwieldy process of getting the needed help fron the V A.in a timely and manageable way.
Recent reports of the long wait times at V A facilities are not encouraging.

flyenby 01-01-2016 07:59 PM

Well we must attend to the Syrian refugees first....after all look at what we OWE them

Rick Lee 01-01-2016 09:00 PM

Very eye opening thread. I just can't believe so little is paid out to vets who come back disabled.

LakeCleElum 01-01-2016 09:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Drbraunsr (Post 8940183)
Whatever it is....it's not enough.

Sometimes, it's too much: - I am all for providing more for those in need. However, my wife has 2 sons:

1) In the Air Force, he caught his wife in a bar kissing his Superior Officer. Divorce. He whines Air Force won't demote and transfer his superior Officer. Been 15 years and gets a 30% "Stress" disability payment. Relatives ask what I think: "If the gov't paid a pension to everyone whose wife cheated, we'd all go broke much sooner."

2) Son #2 is a serious alcoholic. Was in the Navy in the Persian Gulf on an Aircraft Carrier working in the Personnel Office.....Years later, he wants a disability like his brother. Studied up and it and claims he has "ringing in his ears"....Sez his bunk was under the flight deck and hearing damage........Claim has been approved, not sure what percentage...... He is as healthy as any other drunk. His goal in life is to get a Teamster disability to go along with the military check and never work again......

Not proud of either.....

tevake 01-01-2016 09:46 PM

There certianly are scammers out there for any support system like welfare, social Security, the V A, etc. and that is undoubtly part of why the V A is intent on screening as hard as they do. And should for that sort.

This unfortunately can lead to big challenges for vets that really do need help. Particularly those with Phycological issues that are not visable, but still can weigh heavily on their ability to function in the civilian world. Or avoid suicide, something of a pandemic in these times.

I can't pretend to have the answers, but can see the problems and have experienced them first hand. And the statistics on our current Vets are not pretty.

fintstone 01-01-2016 10:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by LakeCleElum (Post 8940322)
Sometimes, it's too much: - I am all for providing more for those in need. However, my wife has 2 sons:

1) In the Air Force, he caught his wife in a bar kissing his Superior Officer. Divorce. He whines Air Force won't demote and transfer his superior Officer. Been 15 years and gets a 30% "Stress" disability payment. Relatives ask what I think: "If the gov't paid a pension to everyone whose wife cheated, we'd all go broke much sooner."

2) Son #2 is a serious alcoholic. Was in the Navy in the Persian Gulf on an Aircraft Carrier working in the Personnel Office.....Years later, he wants a disability like his brother. Studied up and it and claims he has "ringing in his ears"....Sez his bunk was under the flight deck and hearing damage........Claim has been approved, not sure what percentage...... He is as healthy as any other drunk. His goal in life is to get a Teamster disability to go along with the military check and never work again......

Not proud of either.....

Lots of scammers...just like anywhere. It makes it more difficult for military folks with real problems. It is pretty easy to claim some sort of back pain or hearing problem. I had quite a few problems when I retired after almost 26 years...but not much more than most folks my age because I stay fit. Getting no disability worked out well for me, because it allowed me to go back into the Reserve a few years later and serve another 11 years. They would not take guys with disabilities.

TheMentat 01-01-2016 10:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by LakeCleElum (Post 8940322)
Sometimes, it's too much: - I am all for providing more for those in need. However, my wife has 2 sons:

1) In the Air Force, he caught his wife in a bar kissing his Superior Officer. Divorce. He whines Air Force won't demote and transfer his superior Officer. Been 15 years and gets a 30% "Stress" disability payment. Relatives ask what I think: "If the gov't paid a pension to everyone whose wife cheated, we'd all go broke much sooner."

2) Son #2 is a serious alcoholic. Was in the Navy in the Persian Gulf on an Aircraft Carrier working in the Personnel Office.....Years later, he wants a disability like his brother. Studied up and it and claims he has "ringing in his ears"....Sez his bunk was under the flight deck and hearing damage........Claim has been approved, not sure what percentage...... He is as healthy as any other drunk. His goal in life is to get a Teamster disability to go along with the military check and never work again......

Not proud of either.....

That's crazy... Those guys are quite literally stealing from vets in need!

onewhippedpuppy 01-02-2016 04:40 AM

My father was a forward observer in Vietnam, and won a Purple Heart after being hit by grenade shrapnel while on patrol. Still has some pieces in him to this day. I know he gets care at the VA hospital, but I don't think he gets much else.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 08:11 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.6.0
Copyright 2025 Pelican Parts, LLC - Posts may be archived for display on the Pelican Parts Website


DTO Garage Plus vBulletin Plugins by Drive Thru Online, Inc.