Another attack from the infamous Pit Bull breed

[sammyg2]

Humans have not been selectively bred for the past bazillion generations to to fight and kill.
Humans have not developed physical attributes to make them better at killing, such as stronger bite, massive jaws, and a deep-seated tendency to attack violently when provoked.

Sure, a toy poodle is almost as likely to bite a human as a pit bull is but a toy poodle typically gives a little nip and is lucky to break the skin.

A pit bull attack is likely to result in serious blood loss, missing skin and tissue, faces ripped off, and kids or grown-ups being DEAD.

To ignore these facts or to argue against them is just dishonest.
SHAME.

[javadog]

I'm not politically correct, so my arguments are less to do with that and more to do with the fact that people that know nothing much about a subject ought to not have such strong opinions about it. Of course, that's the opposite of current trends in this country.

Humans may not have been bred specifically to kill each other but they sure do a damn fine job of it. Sammy is 160 times more likely to die from his neighbor killing him, than from his neighbor's dog, but why interject actual facts into the discussion? Horse**** is so much more fun.

Enjoy your opinions, boys. Don't own a dog, I'm quite fine with that.

JR

[Crowbob]

Originally Posted by javadog

Dogs are entirely predictable, far more so than humans. They have a very definite sense of order in their world and have problems with us when we do not act like a dog would in a given situation and this confuses them. The problem you have is that you don't understand how they think and act, you can't read their body language and understand the clues they give you as to their mood, therefore you cannot predict what they will do next.

Read a book about how dogs think. It might teach you a few things.

JR

Sure. But if you insist on carrying on your phantasy, think about this for just a minute. For argument's sake let's assume a child is not as dog savvy as you claim to be. Let's further say that child happens to grab some dog by the ear or poke him in the eye or step on his foot. I'd rather that dog be a Lab or just about ANY other breed than a Pitt.

[javadog]

No argument. But a dog owner shouldn't put a large dog next to a small kid. That's where the problem starts.

JR

[masraum]

This thread has some similar arguments in it as threads about what is a good first car for a 16 year old. You can give a 16 year old a corolla or civic or mustang or WRX STI. Some arguments are, "tThey can go 100mph in any of the vehicles, so what difference does it make?" I don't think that argument is any more valid. Yes, any dog may be "mean" by disposition/character (dogs have personalities much as people do. Any dog may be mean/violent/dangerous by nature or nurture. But, if you get in a situation where the dog becomes violent and dangerous, I'd rather have it be a teacup chihuahua or my mini dachshund than a pit bull, rottweiler, German Shepherd, etc... (and I love German Shepherds).

And some dogs will just be dangerous regardless of the owner or how they were raised. They may be well trained and socialized 99.999% of the time, but it only takes that one time....

[Rikao4]

come on folk..
we give murderer's , rapist and the like more than one chance..
supposedly they can think like we do and make decisions..
nobody rushing to put them down..

I've owned & own big dogs..
I never assume anything..
do my best and more..
but more often then not..
it's stupid humans / actions that start the event..

Rika

[Alan A]

Originally Posted by sammyg2

Humans have not been selectively bred for the past bazillion generations to to fight and kill.

Of course they have. Who do you think gets to breed?
The winners or the losers of wars?

If that's not selective, I don't know what is.

[Spud]

Just another couple data points, against pitbulls.

Christmas day 2016. Family comes over to my house, nephew brings his pit/rottweiler mix rescue. Within minutes of arriving the dog has attacked and bitten my yellow lab on the face, requiring a trip to the vet for staples. My yellow lab would not hurt a fly, and does not even bark because she scares herself. The pit was out for blood, and was within inches of killing her, just missed her throat.

August 2016. I'm in my backyard, and hear a dog yelping and lady screaming out front. I run out there and find a pitbull attacking a golden retriever who was being walked by her owner. The lady was on the ground, having been knocked down by the pit bull and her own dogs leash, and the pit bull was in the process of trying to get to her dogs throat. I tried yelling, but there was no stopping that dog short of violence, so I proceeded to kick it in the gut as hard as I could.. six times.. before it let go of the golden. Turned out the pit was a neighbors dog, and had broken through their fence to get at this lady and her dog.

Pitbulls seem to have the capacity to "snap" and resort to primal kill mode more than most/any other breed. No amount of training seems to completely remove this capacity.

[87maniac]

Defenders of Pit Bulls and other potentially dangerous breeds:
I've got two words for you : Diane Whipple (google it)


Diane was my neighbor for a few years. A beautiful young woman,
she was a two-time All-American lacrosse player in high school,
and later at Penn State. She was twice a member of the U.S. Women's
Lacrosse World Cup team.

Diane was savagely mauled to death by her neighbors two Presa Canario dogs.
Bane, the larger of the dogs (weighed 140 pounds) attacked the 33-year-old
lacrosse coach outside of her doorway on Jan. 26, 2001.

The owner, Marjorie Knoller, got the dogs from a Pelican Bay State Prison inmate
named Paul "Cornfed" Schneider, whom they had represented and legally adopted
as their son. The case revealed bizarre detailsabout Knoller and her husband,
who adopted "Cornfed", an Aryan Brotherhood white supremacist convict
they claimed owned the two Presa Canario dogs in theirhome. The dogs were featured
in pornographic prison photos that involved Ms. Knoller, found in the convict's cell.
The case rumbled through the Californiacourt system, slowed by appeals and reversals.

[Baz]

Originally Posted by 87maniac

Defenders of Pit Bulls and other potentially dangerous breeds:
I've got two words for you : Diane Whipple (google it)


Diane was my neighbor for a few years. A beautiful young woman,
she was a two-time All-American lacrosse player in high school,
and later at Penn State. She was twice a member of the U.S. Women's
Lacrosse World Cup team.

Diane was savagely mauled to death by her neighbors two Presa Canario dogs.
Bane, the larger of the dogs (weighed 140 pounds) attacked the 33-year-old
lacrosse coach outside of her doorway on Jan. 26, 2001.

The owner, Marjorie Knoller, got the dogs from a Pelican Bay State Prison inmate
named Paul "Cornfed" Schneider, whom they had represented and legally adopted
as their son. The case revealed bizarre detailsabout Knoller and her husband,
who adopted "Cornfed", an Aryan Brotherhood white supremacist convict
they claimed owned the two Presa Canario dogs in theirhome. The dogs were featured
in pornographic prison photos that involved Ms. Knoller, found in the convict's cell.
The case rumbled through the Californiacourt system, slowed by appeals and reversals.

Again....this was something that resulted from HUMANS doing STUPID stuff.....

Schneider and his cellmate Dale Bretches were attempting to start an illegal Presa Canario dog-fighting business from prison. They initially asked acquaintances Janet Coumbs and Hard Times Kennel owner/breeder James Kolber of Akron, Ohio to raise the dogs during their incarceration. Against Kolber's advice, Coumbs chained the dogs in a remote corner of the farm, which caused them to become even more aggressive.

How many dog owners on this forum chain up their dogs in a remote corner of your property. How many dog owners on this forum attempt to start a dog fighting business?

I didn't think so.

Exterminate the STUPID humans....not the dogs. Problem solved!

[Rot 911]

Personally, I don't care for sweaters either. On the other hand, my two dogs will put up with any amount of humiliation. Tilly and Axel on Halloween:

[javadog]

Originally Posted by Spud

Christmas day 2016. Family comes over to my house, nephew brings his pit/rottweiler mix rescue.

If I could offer a little advice... never let someone bring a dog to visit at your house. Apart from the fact that there is no good reason to do so, from either dog's point of view, there are two really good reasons to not do so.

The first one, you've seen firsthand.

The second one is that if the other dog has any health issues, that's a really good way to pass them onto your dog. From simple things like fleas, to more serious things like worms, you don't know how healthy the other dog is and people that bring their dogs everywhere they go are also more likely to take them to places like dog parks, which are really good places to make a healthy dog sick. Dogs that receive normal healthcare and stay in their own yard are usually healthy from birth to death.

The better kennels won't even accept dogs without an up-to-date vaccination/testing record, a thorough physical inspection and bath.

JR

[wdfifteen]

Originally Posted by Alan A

Of course they have. Who do you think gets to breed?
The winners or the losers of wars?

Both. I don't know the statistics, but I doubt there are significantly fewer Japanese now than there were in 1939. Ditto for the Germans.

[john70t]

Originally Posted by 87maniac

I've got two words for you : Diane Whipple (google it)

I lived in SF at the time and remember that story well:
Nice area, nice apartments.
It should have been an all nice people and all nice situation.

Then somehow there is some gutter humans and several large Cane Corso residents involved.
Add a litany of previous incidents of those dogs loose in the hallways with past aggressive incidents.
California the control state.

The whole thing didn't make sense.

[Alan A]

A cane corso isn't a pitbull.
They are molossors - guard dogs.
If you are going to blame specific breeds at least get the right ones.

[Alan A]

Originally Posted by wdfifteen

Both. I don't know the statistics, but I doubt there are significantly fewer Japanese now than there were in 1939. Ditto for the Germans.

Google genghis khan dna. Then think about the ramifications of that for a bit before you try a smart answer.

[Spud]

Originally Posted by javadog

If I could offer a little advice... never let someone bring a dog to visit at your house. Apart from the fact that there is no good reason to do so, from either dog's point of view, there are two really good reasons to not do so.
JR

We have had plenty of dogs over to the house without incident, other family members, neighbors etc., and everyone gets along just fine, dogs included . Having a dog should not mean solitary confinement for the dog or the family.

However, my experience with pitbulls leads me to acknowledge that there is something wrong with the breed. I don't blame the animals, but I do blame genetics.

[john70t]

Originally Posted by Alan A

A cane corso isn't a pitbull.
They are molossors - guard dogs.
If you are going to blame specific breeds at least get the right ones.

I was living near the SF beach at the time.
Across the street was a beehive apartment full of misc surfer dudes/dudettes.

Helped one tough guy find the bad spark plug on a pickup.
He busted his knuckles to the bone on the fan blade, and then arced a continuous spark from his blue jeans to the bumper.
'Tis merely a flesh wound he said. Wrap with duct tape.
Got it fixed.

They'd leave the big pit bull and rottweiler out on the sidewalk to lounge on the sidewalk.
Nice dogs. Liked a petting. Ignored traffic. Liked sunshine. A bit lazy also. Had to be yelled at to go back inside.


..The dog mentality is heavily influenced by the human mentality...

[wdfifteen]

Originally Posted by Alan A

Google genghis khan dna. Then think about the ramifications of that for a bit before you try a smart answer.

Tell me first how the losers of WWII were prevented from breeding.

[creaturecat]

i just came back from a walk. Britannia Park.
signs everywhere saying "all dogs must be on a leash" the sign as well notes that there is a dedicated large fenced area for off leash dog fun. it is a huge grassy area. fenced in.
the sign in front of the children's playground says "no dogs allowed".
the sign in front of the beach says "no dogs allowed".
probably 10-12 dogs in the park, all together. it's a slow day, due to icy conditions.
only one dog was on leash. dogs were in the playground, off leash, and on the beach, off leash.
not one dog in the designated area.