Duc Hunter |
06-03-2019 11:54 AM |
Classic Retrofit A/C Experience & Guide
NOTE SOME PEOPLE ARE SEEING SOME OF THE PICTURES UPSIDE-DOWN. Let me know if that is the case. On my systems they all seem to be correct.
Disclaimers This is a long one, sorry. It just kept growing and growing. I am by no means an expert, just wanted to pass along what I learned.
I paid for my Classic RetroFit (CR) A/C System and Alternator myself. I have no affiliation with CR, other than being a customer.
I live in the Florida, USA. I am tried to use Celsius as much as possible as my outside air temp gauge, my evap temp gauge, and the systems ECU all read in Celsius. I also tried to convert to Fahrenheit as much as I could but to be honest, I got tired of converting everything.
Yes, I repeat some things throughout this write up. That is mostly on purpose, because I feel they need to be emphasized, or are pertinent in several different areas. BLUF (Bottom Line Up FrontI loved the idea of the CR A/C before I bought it and knew my particular case would be a tough installation. I also knew my climate would be about the toughest there is for an A/C system given the heat and humidity we have here. Throughout my install CR have been very supportive and helpful, even when I screwed things up myself. I did that at times, royally to be sure. They were wonderfully patient and positive.
So, what do I think of the system? I have an A/C system that works very well! That is even though I am in a miserably difficult climate for an A/C system, and in a car that is almost as bad as a stripped-out race car for and A/C system. I believe that if it works the way it does for me in my car, it would be even more amazing in a car like my 1989 3.2 Carrera (nice factory interior, never been a stripped out race car, has all its sound deadening, etc), let alone how it would work in places that are less humid, or hot.
In short, on any day but the hottest days here the car is very comfortable, I turn off the footwell/crotch vents, and turn down the blower rather quickly. On the hottest days, the car cools off after being heat soaked in the sun and is plenty comfortable to drive. In fact I have been daily’ing the car all this summer, a first in any of my air-cooled cars. My Goals for this writeupTo provide people looking into, or who have the Classic Retrofit A/C system some guidance on getting the install & settings right, and the benefit of my testing and experience.
To provide the information in a way that will help others avoid some basic pitfalls that I ran into during my installation & setup, and that can enable people to “rapidly” test their newly installed system, and arrive at really good settings that are adjusted to their personal installation. Installation technique has a big effect on where the settings need to be for comfort.
To provide a good understanding of how the system works, where performance can be gained through the settings or install, and where it cannot.
To provide good data to CR and others from one of the worst climates in the world for A/C, and CR’s development. Keep in mind that CR has no way to simulate humidity in their environmental chamber, as it gets drier the hotter the temp gets. Therefor they were taking a bit of an educated guess (and a good one) at the system’s settings and capabilities in humid climates. Because of this I wanted to do as much as I could to gather data for them in my heat chamber, called Florida. Just the other day it was 101F air temp and over 40% humidity here. Having lived in CA for 15 years, and spending time every year in the Nevada desert in the summer, I can say my climate is far tougher on man and A/C than a 120+ degree desert day. Based on my climate and experience I came to the ECU settings and testing procedures below. Jonny and the folks at CR have been very appreciative and supportive of my testing.
To try to give back a little bit to this community that has given me so much over the years. This has ranged from actual advice, to entertainment, and inspiration. I also wanted to give back to the historical record that this board is, and how that history of information has been so invaluable in my Porsche Journey to date. My A/C Setting TheoryIn a heat-soaked car I want to cool the car as fast as possible and get it to my desired temp ASAP. Many modern A/C systems (like my 2012 BMW X5) start to back off well above the set temp, and therefor never really get to the set temp. In my X5 I have to lower the temp below where I want it, then once the car gets close to how I want it to feel I move the temp setting back up to let the car back off and keep the car cool. This is rather annoying in a hot and humid climate. My desire was to have the system “cold crash” the car as fast as possible, and not back off until right before the set temp, while still giving the system enough resolution to back off without over cooling the car. I think I have achieved that, though come cooler fall weather I may need to make some minor adjustments. Time will tell.
In a hot climate I want to avoid having the compressor start cycling on/off to maintain temp. In hot climates and/or humid climates this causes larger temperature swings than I find comfortable. This is especially true if the car is heat soaked (just started after being parked in the sun), and you are sitting at a stoplight. With CR’s electric A/C it should be possible to have the compressor always running and let the ECU control it such that the cabin is comfortable. I built a computer model of the PID controller that is this systems ECU. This model enabled me to play with settings in a virtual environment so I could arrive at settings I thought would work. With these setting the system will run at max cooling power until it is within about 1.75C (2.8F) of the Cabin Set Temperature (CTS). In my testing this works well in the hot summer. A/C Things to Know.
I have proven this system has the capacity to handle very hot and very humid climates. When an A/C system runs out of capacity the condenser output temperature rises well above the ambient air temp. Conversely in a properly running system the output fitting on the condenser is near ambient at all times, once the system has stabilized. CR and I occasionally talked about the possibility of adding a second condenser to the system to help with my really hot & humid climate. To-date though my condenser output has never been more than 3C above ambient (using my IR Gun), and that includes on 100+F days with 40%+ humidity.
Humidity is a killer on all A/C systems, as I keep saying. Dry desert air at 120F degrees is far easier on an A/C system than 92F and 56% humidity, which is a “feels like” of 102. If you live in dry climate you are far better off. If you are in a humid climate, I am about as humid as possible, and the system works very well for me.
Below is a chart from Porsche. This is the designed performance of the 993 A/C system, based on outside air temperature. This is outside air temp vs center vent temp, after the car has cooled off the cabin. Why do they use this metric? As I mentioned above, the condenser is a freon/air heat exchanger. As a result, if this system had 9 of its condensers daisy-chained (instead of the 1 it has) they would only ever get the output down to ambient. Therefor the hotter the ambient, the hotter the output of the condenser, which means you are losing efficiency. The best way to gain performance would be a larger evaporator, and this one seem about as big as can be fitted in our cars very limited space. I am getting far better performance than this chart says a 993 would, with my blower on high and all my vents open. Just the other day my outside air temp gauge (VDO I put in) read 42C, and my center vent temp was 10.4 (been driving for 30 minutes). Based on this chart a properly running 993 system would not have seen any lower than 13C vent temps, if you extrapolate the chart out to 42C.
https://pbase.com/mrcjb60290/image/169278116.jpg
Below is an image from Honda regarding the performance of one of their A/C systems. Their test wants all of the vents closed except the center dash vent, and the cars blower on low. My CR System has been outperforming this as well, once the car cools off. That is also with my system on blower on high and all of the vents open. Lowering the blower speed and closing off vents will lower the open vents temp dramatically. This is because the air moves more slowly over the evaporator, which gives the evaporator more time to cool the cabin air, which of course gives lower vent temps.
https://pbase.com/mrcjb60290/image/169278121.jpg
Good A/C is about turning over the air in the cabin to cool it fast FAR MORE than a cold vent temp. To that end I have learned the car cools off fastest, and you are cooler faster, if you have all of the vents open including the footwell/crotch vents. The center vent temp will be higher this way by a few degrees C vs closing off the crotch vents, but the car will take longer to cool off and you will feel warmer if you close them, as you will have less air blowing on you. Opening the crotch vents also reduces the air volume coming from the dash vents. Do not be deceived into thinking cold air falls, the more air out of the dash the better. Trust me! Been down that path and back. When you see a vent temp of 18.3C (65F), you might think the system sucks. In my heat-soaked car, as it cools off, I see those temps. When I do though the intake air is often above 25C (77F). Remember the system can only take a certain amount of heat out of the air every time it passes over the evaporator. My X5 can run vent temps of mid 50’s F and the cabin can cool down to low 70’s no problem. Again, vent temp is a smaller part of a much bigger equation.
|