Pelican Parts Forums

Pelican Parts Forums (http://forums.pelicanparts.com/)
-   Porsche 911 Technical Forum (http://forums.pelicanparts.com/porsche-911-technical-forum/)
-   -   Shift coupler broken (http://forums.pelicanparts.com/porsche-911-technical-forum/1140356-shift-coupler-broken.html)

David Inc. 05-25-2023 10:24 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ramonesfreak (Post 12008248)
yes thats it. give it a try and let me know if i am overreacting

i bought it because i wanted something shiny and new. if there is one thing i have learned with these cars that usually dictates every decision is that if it is not broken, do not fix or replace. leave it alone. in this case, i failed myself :mad:

I was really only replacing mine because the bolt seems to have been overtightened in the past and bent the ears of the coupler in. If I get around to it I'll let you know, but seven week old baby says "**** that you're not allowed in the garage". :(

JWest 05-29-2023 01:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ramonesfreak (Post 12007578)
Yea it’s nice.

About the clamp, any one handed clamp that is supposedly easier to adjust with one hand….my observation is that they are actually more difficult to get the adjustment perfect because you no longer have the counter force from opposing wrenches. Instead you gotta hold the rod in place by holding the shift knob against the force of the one wrench tightening the clamp…not easy or precise. A bit of a scam the way they are promoted. Noticed it immediately and it pissed me off

Interesting. The way I adjust is to hold the shift knob and tighten the coupler, and I designed the one-handed clamp to assist my preferred method. Before the one-handed clamp, I had to awkwardly use one hand on both wrenches to tighten enough to hold the adjustment, then complete the tightening of the nut and bolt with two hands.

I find holding the knob allows for great precision in positioning, since you have distance and leverage to work with. For me, it is a huge time saver and I do a lot of installs and readjustments.

I'm sorry your experience was less than satisfactory and you considered it a downgrade. You could drill through the threads and put a nut on the end with a longer bolt and still have an upgrade from the original (that was probably bent and scarred).

James

winders 05-29-2023 02:14 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ramonesfreak (Post 12007578)
About the clamp, any one handed clamp that is supposedly easier to adjust with one hand….my observation is that they are actually more difficult to get the adjustment perfect because you no longer have the counter force from opposing wrenches. Instead you gotta hold the rod in place by holding the shift knob against the force of the one wrench tightening the clamp…not easy or precise. A bit of a scam the way they are promoted. Noticed it immediately and it pissed me off

I have a JWest one wrench clamp and absolutely love it. I hated the Factory clamp as it was damn near impossible to tighten while making sure the shifter stayed in the right place. I use this clamp in my race car and I would never go back to a clamp that requires two wrenches. I don't get needing a "counter force". Just don't be hamfisted when tightening and it works perfectly....

ramonesfreak 05-29-2023 02:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by JWest (Post 12010830)
Interesting. The way I adjust is to hold the shift knob and tighten the coupler, and I designed the one-handed clamp to assist my preferred method. Before the one-handed clamp, I had to awkwardly use one hand on both wrenches to tighten enough to hold the adjustment, then complete the tightening of the nut and bolt with two hands.

I find holding the knob allows for great precision in positioning, since you have distance and leverage to work with. For me, it is a huge time saver and I do a lot of installs and readjustments.

I'm sorry your experience was less than satisfactory and you considered it a downgrade. You could drill through the threads and put a nut on the end with a longer bolt and still have an upgrade from the original (that was probably bent and scarred).

James


I’ll continue to use it. You’re not the only one that makes a one handed clamp so I figured I’m missing out on something not having one. I did struggle getting it clamped tight without the adjustment moving but maybe it’s my technique because I’m so used to the stock clamp. No worries. sorry for talking negative about your product. i feel bad now

Your shifter remains the greatest improvement I’ve made to my car by far

pmax 05-29-2023 03:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ramonesfreak (Post 12010859)
I’ll continue to use it. You’re not the only one that makes a one handed clamp so I figured I’m missing out on something not having one. I did struggle getting it clamped tight without the adjustment moving but maybe it’s my technique because I’m so used to the stock clamp.

Sounds like you're missing the "other hand on the knob" part of the technique otherwise with the factory setup, the equal and opposite forces aspect to it is an interesting technical observation on your part in its own right !

JWest 05-29-2023 03:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ramonesfreak (Post 12010859)
i feel bad now

Please don't feel bad, I am always interested when there is another perspective or another approach. All part of learning and improving.

James

ramonesfreak 05-29-2023 04:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by pmax (Post 12010886)
Sounds like you're missing the "other hand on the knob" part of the technique otherwise with the factory setup, the equal and opposite forces aspect to it is an interesting technical observation on your part in its own right !

I never had to hold the knob with the stock setup…just line up my indexing lines and gently tighten. Whatever method, doesn’t really matter as this is only something the gets adjusted on rare occasions.

DavidMn 05-31-2023 03:07 PM

Installed the Stomski. Wow, what an improvement (especially when compared to a coupler with losose bushings).

Also noticed a poster from Minneapolis (I am Woodbury). Nice to see someone from MN.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 04:37 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.6.0
Copyright 2025 Pelican Parts, LLC - Posts may be archived for display on the Pelican Parts Website


DTO Garage Plus vBulletin Plugins by Drive Thru Online, Inc.