[Jeff Higgins]

Avoid the 1873 unless you really need one to fit into a particular class in some sort of shooting competition, like cowboy action or something. It's a weak, inferior action compared to the others on your list.

The Rossi is an inexpensive, not all that well made example of the 1892. It's serviceable enough, but a little rougher and a little less durable than the Winchesters.

The new, Miroku made Winchesters are about the best guns ever made bearing the Winchester brand. They are kind of expensive, though. If you don't mind spending a little more, though, you really can't go wrong. Again, avoid the 1873 - go with the 1892. One of Mr. Browning's best designs.

The Marlin 1894 is the best bang for the buck. Avoid the first few years of Remington ownership. Find a used one just preceding that, or get the newest one you can find. Great rifles for half the cost of the Winchester. Not the same level of fit and finish, but smoother actions and similar accuracy.

So, for me, it would be down to the Winchester 1892 or the Marlin 1894. There are variations of both available, as far as barrel lengths, straight or pistol grips, etc. Either one will fill the bill. The Winchester will be prettier, if that's important.