Hard to compare as they drove entirely different types of race cars.
I'm sure Paul is faster in his car and maybe Patrick faster in his newer car.
Paul Newman's long driving history tops most in bench racing.
But his history was in old race cars with no nannies, H pattern manual, heal and toe downshift and a brake bias control.
Paul Newman
Patrick Dempsey has an impressive driving record too.
In newer cars with ABS, traction control and stability control software that have the ability to manipulate each wheel independently.
Patrick Dempsey
I just give more credit to racing with H pattern gear boxes (and 935 turbos/no nannies).