Quote:
Originally Posted by drcoastline
You guys saying she would lose? I am not so sure. Maybe if he had the opportunity to grab her and pull her in? But he is just a fat load, being small, fit, trained to fight and presumably fast she could very easily taken him out. In and out, a shot to his knee a kick to the face. Like a Mongoose on a Cobra. I would have loved to have seen her whoop his Azz.
|
Being a Black Belt in Brazilian Jiu Jitsu, I'm going to have to go with my instincts. I consistently train with larger opponents and in my experience a disparity of 100 lbs is significant for two
men in the ground game. Now add in the fact that one is a female and IMO its just too much to overcome. This is why weight classes were created. Size does indeed make a difference to a degree.
Also, don't assume the guys out of shape just because he's fat. We have several guys at our school who may look to be out of shape (275 lbs plus) but you'd be in for a rude awakening if you engaged them on the mats. (Think Big Country, Tank Abbott)
The odds are extremely slim she could knock him out before he grabbed her and physically overpowered her with extreme violence. She isn't trained for that type of event. She's trained for sport "points" karate. If she has no grappling experience, once its on the ground you basically have two untrained people. a 110 lb. female vs a 220 plus lb. male. With two untrained people the bigger stronger person usually wins.
Having said that, yes fights are unpredictable. Is there a chance she could knock him out with a well placed sport type kick or strike? Absolutely, but if you ran a simulation 1000 times, she would probably get destroyed and by destroyed I mean critically injured 95% of the time.
Stop believing all this TV crap... she has zero physical advantage and the disparity in size is so great she would need to be trained in all aspects of fighting: strikes, kicks, preventing a take down, being able to take down, and than know chokes and submissions on the ground.
Than she would have a decent chance...and guess what that is? an MMA fighter!