For me it's:
1. Hotel California,
The Eagles.
I can't fault it in any way and I still have a good copy on vinyl. (I was 11 in 1976)
- My son pinched it about 6 weeks ago and wont give it back.
2. And Justice for All,
Metallica. 
I know he has a tainted legacy but we should also mention Thriller,
Michael Jackson.