Here's my NY house. You can see the front window isn't original. It would have had 7 or 8 foot windows, two of them. Also the front wrap around porch is gone. We paid about $150k in 2006 and sold it for $155k in 2009. Zillow estimate is about $223K now.
Edit: the house you see to the left is huge and same vintage as are all the houses on this and two other streets. The neighbor's house in the photo has a barn/garage that is as big as my house.