[Zeke]

I'd day keep your present underwear and use a jock strap. That may not always be comfortable and if not, I don't have any suggestions beyond what has been said and probably will be.

I have noticed that certain non posture friendly seating positions need to be altered as this underwear can bunch up. No problem with briefs. I never wore boxers because of physical work pretty much 7 days a week. Just didn't like the boys hanging and knocking around while bending, stooping, on my knees, etc. I like to know where they are before I catch one in a bad place.

Thanks to this forum (or maybe another) I have being wearing boxer briefs for a few years. I wanted to mention that they are at their best for only a dozen washings, then they are just good. Couple months later and, although they are plenty good enough to wear, they aren't anything like new. I have been buying Hanes; perhaps there is something better.

Lastly, how about heat and swelling? If that's the case, then having things tight is not the answer.