Thread: animal carnage
View Single Post
Overpaid Slacker Overpaid Slacker is offline
Super Jenius
 
Overpaid Slacker's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2002
Location: Syracuse, NY
Posts: 3,491
Send a message via AIM to Overpaid Slacker
Yargk -- I'm not saying it's "right" in any moral sense; that'd be a category error. That's why I put the words "steal" "injustice" and "know" in quotes. Scavengers certainly have a role to play in the Big Picture.

However, in considering the q Moses raised, it occurs to me that there are notions of property in the Animal Kingdom, whether it's "turf" or a den or lair -- or a killed animal, animals have a rudimentary concept of property.

Again, Moses' q was why do we (humans) root for the lion almost instinctively. Well, we're not scavengers (by and large...) and as a species tend to kill what we eat and view property rights from a position more sympathetic to the lions.

If we, as a species, better identified with antelope, this would be a whole different conversation, no? It just "is", I agree, but we're going to view the sit. from our own Kantian perspective, and tend to anthropomorphize the animals one way or another -- I was attempting to recognize the lens through which we view this sort of thing and provide to it some definition; no "right" or "wrong".

JP
__________________
2003 SuperCharged Frontier ../.. 1979 930 ../.. 1989 BMW 325iX ../.. 1988 BMW M5 ../.. 1973 BMW 2002 ../..1969 Alfa Boattail Spyder ../.. 1961 Morris Mini Cooper ../..2002 Aprilia RSV Mille ../.. 1985 Moto Guzzi LMIII cafe ../.. 2005 Kawasaki Brute Force 750
Old 01-07-2005, 06:52 AM
  Pelican Parts Catalog | Tech Articles | Promos & Specials    Reply With Quote #14 (permalink)