[argonaut]

Finally a topic I feel qualified to contribute to! I have been in the bike industry for quite a while. I think Nostatic is right on with his input.

Additionally, while there is nothing inherently wrong with compact frames, I do have a problem with manufacturers selling them as fitting a larger number of riders. This is simply manufacturers cutting their tooling costs and passing the disadvantage down to the consumer. Standover height is a terrible way to fit frames. Cockpit length is cockpit length, no matter which direction the tubes connect. Get a bike that fits, less compromise the better.

I get the opportunity to ride a wide variety of bikes for work. I would say with the prevalence of carbon fiber, engineering and construction will have a much bigger impact on how a bike feels than frame style. I would go with the one that you feels best, 'eyes closed'.