Brent,
Yes it will look very close if not identical but be sure to mention the year of your 911. If you're curious you can have him email you a photo of what the plate looks like.
When you get it contact International Merchantile. I think they can stamp it for you. The numbers may not match exactly but it should be close.
1-800-356-0012
Then there is the question of the correct rivets (see how this goes
). I am not sure about those but I will look around.