I think it's healthy. If you place an ad on ebay for a Porsche 911 - you will be open to criticism. Bring your a-game, bring a thick skin. Be able to back your claims. Sort of an ebay net nanny.
I personally love the color.
but loose the rubber bumpers, they look like boobies.
Love the seats -
but man the carpet looks dirty and worn
Door sills look good -
but where is the under pan shots (which should be a requirement of any early car ad)
No dash crack - which means to me it has been well taken care of (or replaced)
Some of the best looking door pockets I have seen in a long time on an early car
There are many posters on this thread that have more knowledge on early cars than you can shake a stick at - and I would defer judgement to them, or those that have actually touched, driven, or know the car.