[racer]

How do you plan to use the car? Stop and go commuter traffic? Sunday morning blasts down the highway or mountain roads? Autocross or DE events?

How important is it to have the "latest and greatest" gadget?

More importantly, these two cars are incredibly different to drive. The feel, sounds, seating position, engine characteristics.. you get the point.

Is a warranty important for you?
Do you like the spool of turbos?
Do you mind a 10 year old car?
Do you want to "order" a car to your liking? Want that new car smell?

You really need to make an honest assesment of how you will use the car and then go test drive a few in those conditions, if possible.