View Single Post
cool_chick cool_chick is offline
Living in Reality
 
cool_chick's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: Chicago, IL
Posts: 5,671
Send a message via Yahoo to cool_chick
Quote:
Originally posted by fastpat
In addition to the voluminous lists I've already presented?

All right. Here's The Journalist's Guide to Gun Policy Scholars and Second Amendment Scholars which should keep you busy for some time reading the research. Though I must tell you that I don't see how you've waded through what I posted earlier, nevertheless, I've presented yet more.
Ok, thanks. That's a lot to go through though, looking for lawyers and analysts stating that the amendment as written it clear. Can you point to where whomever states that the clause as written is clear?

And I did "wade" through your one link you provided here. Personally, I didn't find it "voluminous" but hey, whatever. It was one person's interpretation of the amendment, not any sort of proof that the constitution as written is clear. It was one of the two interpretations that can be mete with this vague clause.

You claimed you're a master at grammar, why are you having such a difficult time understanding this painfully simple question?

Quote:
The evidence is simply overwhelming that the Second Amendment protects an individual's right to any arm; and those that seek to define it differently have ulterior motives involving the curtailment of access to other rights as well as the right to be armed.
This is one interpretation by people on a pro-gun site (which means they're not going to put arguments which present another interpretation.....go to an anti-gun side for the other interpretation....this analysis is one-sided and not an effective demonstration that the clause is clear as I've requested from you, surely with your master grammar skills, you can easily understand the question presented for the umtheenth time, right?).

This link, at first glance, still does not appear to be an indication that the clause as written is clear.

Last edited by cool_chick; 01-14-2007 at 08:09 PM..
Old 01-14-2007, 08:06 PM
  Pelican Parts Catalog | Tech Articles | Promos & Specials    Reply With Quote #55 (permalink)