[FOG]

Shaun,

The single best source that I have seen (doesn’t mean that better ones do not exist) is the Naval Post Graduate book store. Also check the Commandant’s reading list.

The Small Wars Manual is print again, get a copy. One of the better basic primers in expanding the thought/scope of Special Operation is “From Troy to Entebbe” by John Arquilla.

After reading the two above you’ll have a better idea on where to start looking to inform some more in-depth thoughts and perspective.

The problem from my POV is the excessive reliance on a relatively single source of thought and methodology. Just as an example the far different tactics and procedures employed in the same towns by different teams in Anbar to get the same result. The very different TTPs for want of a better description meant that those who relied on quantifiable metrics were stymied. The lack of metrics means higher is unhappy as they don’t have a bland simplified product for consumption.

Think of it as martial arts training and study. You should see what is available, what has worked in the past, applicability to your situation, etc.

As I said before I am speaking as an individual, not as for the DoD or the USMC. I may have some insight into the General Officer’s thoughts and preferences from either personnel conversations or friends on various Staffs but these are not for public dissemination.

Lastly please keep in mind that the job of U.S. is fighting high intensity war. Parts of the DoD and individual services are better than others right out of the block but it doesn’t mean they were/are not good at their primary mission.

S/F, FOG

You have read Dereliction of Duty by H. R. McMaster as required haven't you?