[dd74]

My idea, in that regard, is to get the relatively simplest and cost effective newer vehicle, which IMO, would be the Subaru.

Now, I don't know about your area, but down here, Ford is heavily discounting last year's Explorers. I saw an Eddie Bauer (i.e. fully loaded) AWD Explorer for about $25K at the dealer. I'm mentioning this only because it comes with a good warranty, and to be honest, they're very capable and strong vehicles. Their highway mileage isn't too bad, IIRC. I think low to mid 20s mpg wise.