[KTL]

The Mahle wheels are older than the wheel with the info in the center. But both wheels are good solid quality wheels so no worries there. Obviously your only concern would then be that they don't match. No biggie.

I think the price on the wheel refinishing is decent. But you should check with Al Reed in CA (sorry, don't have his contact info. handy, but a search here will produce it) for his price. I bet his price will beat your quote. MANY people on this forum have used him and he does very good work for a reasonable price. His work is not absolute perfection, but his work is still high quality, quick turnaround and an all around great service to the Porsche community.