[Talewinds]

- Mustang GT (or ideally a Shelby although, even if older model, will be difficult to find with my budget)
Great looking and an instant classic, but no.

- Chevrolet Camaro SS '10
Even greater looking but GOD no. (This from a previous Camaro-'s owner)

- Chevrolet Corvette
You've lost your mind. But truthfully the newer Vettes are GREAT cars.

...this three options will give me the chance to drive a true American Sport car (I am coming from abroad!!)
Ok, Ok, I think I can understand your perspective. In that case, how about a Z06???????? Can they be had for $35k yet? Probably not. But I think that Z51??? is that what it's called? Those can be had for around your budget.
Entirely age dependent though, you must have either A: Grey hair, B: No hair, or C: a combination of both. You must show your AARP card here in the midwest to be allowed to purchase one. How am I so certain of that assertion? I live ON Route 66.
Not that there's anything wrong with greying hair, I've got quite a collection started myself.


Why not a Viper? I know the older ones can be had for $35k these days, and they're WICKED fun.

You've already got a 911 you love, so unless you're going to replace it completely, why buy another one? There are SO many cars and so little time on this rock.
My $$$:
M5 or M3. You've already got a SUV and a pure sports car, the M5/3 slots right there in the middle in your stable.
CLK55 AMG
E55 AMG
Jag XJR
Audi S4
335 Coupe or Sedan
300C SRT8
CLK55 AMG