[LWJ]

Ok. Here are my thoughts. Plan one uses the space well. I somehow missed the reason why the counter was not continued towards the deck. I like lots of counter space. If possible, could you continue it? I also like great big drawers as opposed to cabinets on the bottom. I think for you, you may consider having open shelving (as opposed to cabinet doors) on the tops. This is much more functional and also significantly cheaper. It is mych easier to cook when you can grap stuff without opening and closing doors. It can look crappy however. Finally, I still am lobbying for a larger window if possible. I think the cabinets over the island really crowd the room. I like open rooms.

Good that you know your constraints!
Larry