[teenerted1]

as a renter with a dog and older carpet...i would say they are being unreasonable.
new puppy on old carpet is probably better for them anyway. hardwood floors are easier to clean though. don't refund any of the pet deposit until they move out. who's to say there won't be an issue after a year. adult dogs aren't angels just because they are older.

the old carpets stain were noted when i moved in. after a couple of years there, my parents got me a dog for xmas. i then put down a dog deposit as my original lease did allow pets, but i didn't have to pay a pet deposit unless i added one to my household. a hardwood floor is under neath the carpet and would be much easier to clean. and actually would look better with the age/style of the house. but since the carpet is old my landlord said not to worry about it when i move out since it would have to be replaced after all these years anyway. there are sections near the front door that are showing signs of wear more than if it was just people living there.

dogs can be tough on floors so i would say take a wait and see stance for now on the carpet.
new dog on new carpet doesn't sound like a good idea for both sides.