[Vintage914Racer]

I do not think the 2.0t will be too anemic for you. Your current A4 has the 12v V6, which puts out 172hp and ~ 180 torque. The 2.0t puts out 200hp and 207tq. So, you will have more power than your current car and likely better fuel economy thanks to the direct injection and 6-speed (not sure if you're going auto or manual, but both come in 6 speed).

Obviously, the extra power of the 3.2 is nice and the 4.2 in the S4 is great, but you'll burn a lot more fuel in the S4. I like the 2.0t because it is a proven engine with widespread use. I had a 2006 A4 2.0tq and loved it and enjoy the engine just as much in my current A3.