They do look a bit too shiny.
It's your car.
At the end of the day it goes in your garage and you admire it. Go with what you want and screw the rest. I'm running Venetian blue rims (polished) on a Arena read car. I could care less what people around me think of the color combo - I happen to like it
. The rims are not mine to repaint and they serve a utilitarian purpose.
I know, I just completed the circle on this and beat a dead horse.