[chudson]

I have this exact roof as well as an original version of the top that has recently been reproduced.

The roof offered here is my preference because it has:

A metal frame - same as almost every factory roof regardless of manufacturer

An outer seal - restricts debris intrusion and eliminates wind noise

Nicer hardware - IMHO

No bumps on top

I DO NOT own the reproduced version of the frameless top but my original version has all the wind noise you could ever want because it has nothing to fill the gap between the roof and the opening. My framed top with its outer seal has no wind noise.

I'm not bashing the newly reproduced top - it is a good deal. I'm just stating that IMHO the top offered here is the preferred unit.

GLWS