[stomachmonkey]

It's all very subjective.

You can look at the records and he's up there at the top.

If he retires before Brady then Brady will probably surpass him on pure record.

But the thing about Manning is he is probably the smartest quarterback to play the game.

It's one thing to have the physical abilities to throw a ball on a play called in from the sideline.

Manning runs the offense.

They may come to the line of scrimmage with a play in mind but no one is better than Manning in reading a defense multiple times before a snap and changing plays, reassigning routes and generally adjusting everything on the fly in a matter seconds.