I used to DJ, so I have 1200s. They are indeed not built for audiophile applications. But it doesn't sound like thats a concern here.
I looked at craigslist in Minneapolis, and there a number of good options.
There are couple Technics SL-1700s
Vintage Technics SL-1700 Turntable
Nice old Sony
SONY PS-X55 Direct Drive Stereo Turntable
These old Dual turntables look great. Nice sound if its proper working order
Dual 606 turntable
Nice Bang & Olufsen
Bang & Olufsen Beogram 1602