we aren't an organic family so I haven't tried that PB.
I love PB right from the jar. I have purchased most brands including the cheap dollar store versions. I usually buy 2 jars of the smaller size so that a standard table spoon can be used for enjoying from the jar. Too big of container and you risk PB getting on the hand or the neck of the utensil. I HAVE used a spatula but something is "off" if not using a spoon. Yes, a wooden spoon could be used but then you risk splinters in your tongue.
For me, Peter Pan creamy is the best. Good flavor and very smooth texture.
Velvet is good but I don't know that it is available nationally.