My firm works with a lot of small businesses. This is a common problem. We refer them to an HR consulting company called Inspirity
HR Outsourcing & PEO Services from Insperity for Small to Medium Sized Businesses. One of their specialties is providing health insurance plans to small businesses at group rates. You might be able to get coverage for yourself, and/or your company for a significant after tax reduction from what you're paying now for yourself.
Basically what they do is buy large blocks of health insurance as the employer themselves and they let you buy into the group. They have high underwriting standards so they won't sell to just anyone, which keeps the pool relatively low risk. The benefit to you is that you're able to join a larger risk pool of lower risk members, which allows lower premiums. They offer a suite of services but they don't try to sell you on their product. Their approach is to price things for you and let you make the decision. They are smart enough to know that if the price point is right they make the sale and if it's not, they won't, so they don't push.
I'd give them a try if I were you. I'd be happy to forward my contact's name if you're interested.
Otherwise, what you want to do is find a couple of health insurance brokers and let them prepare a bid for you and/or your business. They would shop the market and would be able to tailor a plan for you. I don't know any brokers in your area but I could probably get some referrals if you're interested. Just drop me a PM.