[stomachmonkey]

That's a pretty deep dent. I'd find it difficult to believe the sticker would not have been torn in that spot or at least indicate there was damage underneath.

Do you recall if any other fridges had that sticker in the same place?

Go to the store and check another of the same brand.

I would be insisting they intentionally hid the damage and agreed to a good price to move it knowing one of two scenarios would ensue.

You'd overlook the damage because you got a good deal or you'd be back spending $300.00 more.

Time to get medieval.