Pelican Parts Forums

Pelican Parts Forums (http://forums.pelicanparts.com/index.php)
-   Off Topic Discussions (http://forums.pelicanparts.com/forumdisplay.php?f=31)
-   -   Which Knots To Know? (http://forums.pelicanparts.com/showthread.php?t=1182914)

jyl 08-23-2025 04:56 PM

Which Knots To Know?
 
In a lake cabin for the coming week, figure I should cut some cord from the hank I keep with the kayaks and practice knots. And learn knots. But which knots?

So, here is my PRIMARY question for you all:

If you could only know FIVE knots, which knots would they be, and for each knot you’ve chosen, what task(s) is it used for and why did you choose that knot as best for that task?

And if you will, a SECONDARY question:

What are the five knots you would know for
- General daily life
- Outdoors
- Fishing
- Boating

I ask this as someone who can only seem to remember a few knots. When I was a kid I had a knot book and learned many knots, but they’ve all gone like dust in the wind. As I sit here today, I could probably tie a bowline, a figure eight, a clove hitch, a trucker’s hitch, a fisherman’s knot, a dropper loop of some sort. If I had to splice two lines . . ., I’d probably do repeated overhand loops with each line around the other; I don’t know a splicing knot. If I had to make an emergency rescue sling . . . I’d probably make a big bowline on a bight and watch the victim fall to their death; I don’t know a real sling knot. If I had to tie a fly on a leader . . . i’ve got that covered. If I had to tie a package . . . I’d make a big old mess.

VINMAN 08-23-2025 05:10 PM

Barrel knot for connecting two ropes of the same size.

.

VINMAN 08-23-2025 05:16 PM

Double barrel or " fisherman's bend"

We use these all the time in rope rescue

http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1755998197.jpg

John Rogers 08-23-2025 05:55 PM

If the Chapman Book of Knots is still around I'd suggest getting a copy.
John Rogers

LWJ 08-23-2025 06:54 PM

I taught knot tying to Scouts. Have owned a sail boat or two. Went fly fishing today. So you might think I knew something about knots.

Not really. (pun intended.)

I think you have a very nice inventory listed above.

I do like a prussic knot / loop (foggy memory here...) to make a recovery line with 2:1 advantage. (talking out my backside. No idea the actual advantage.)
I use a surgeons knot, nail knot, and Albright knot for my fly line leader.

Square knot is essential...

I have pretty much faked it this far. Don't plan on learning more.

You are good!

jyl 08-23-2025 07:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by VINMAN (Post 12521310)
Double barrel or " fisherman's bend"

We use these all the time in rope rescue

http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1755998197.jpg

Oh I recognize that knot, used for building a tapered leader for fly fishing.

flatbutt 08-23-2025 07:22 PM

I use this one alot

<iframe width="263" height="467" src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/TR6Zt44JwAg" title="Tying Two Half Hitches" frameborder="0" allow="accelerometer; autoplay; clipboard-write; encrypted-media; gyroscope; picture-in-picture; web-share" referrerpolicy="strict-origin-when-cross-origin" allowfullscreen></iframe>

and this one too

https://www.animatedknots.com/clove-hitch-knot-rope-end

masraum 08-23-2025 07:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by LWJ (Post 12521337)
I taught knot tying to Scouts. Have owned a sail boat or two. Went fly fishing today. So you might think I knew something about knots.

Not really. (pun intended.)

I think you have a very nice inventory listed above.

I do like a prussic knot / loop (foggy memory here...) to make a recovery line with 2:1 advantage. (talking out my backside. No idea the actual advantage.)
I use a surgeons knot, nail knot, and Albright knot for my fly line leader.

Square knot is essential...

I have pretty much faked it this far. Don't plan on learning more.

You are good!

I was a boyscout and knew a bunch of knots. I maybe remember 4 now, square, clove hitch, 2 half hitch, and maybe bowline (the fact that I'm not 100% on that one surprises me). I am also a little surprised that I can picture a sheepshank, but not sure if I could tie one.

Probably 15 years ago, I stumbled across a website on knots and got some line and started practicing. I had a bunch down, but stopped and have forgotten all of them. THere are a bunch of cool knots out there. I think this was the site. It is an excellent site with categories of knots and how-tos on how to tie them all.
https://www.animatedknots.com/

LWJ 08-23-2025 07:55 PM

^^^I have used that website. It is fantastic!

HobieMarty 08-23-2025 08:05 PM

Can't go wrong with a good ol Bowline.

https://youtu.be/Q9NqGd7464U?si=z3xCKPrMidm2CyQm

Sent from my SM-S916U using Tapatalk

craigster59 08-23-2025 08:31 PM

Square knot
Half hitch
Trucker's hitch
Bowline
Clove hitch

And always remember, after tying you need to proclaim "That's not going anywhere".

masraum 08-23-2025 08:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by HobieMarty (Post 12521352)
Can't go wrong with a good ol Bowline.

https://youtu.be/Q9NqGd7464U?si=z3xCKPrMidm2CyQm

Sent from my SM-S916U using Tapatalk

That one was considered super important in the Boy Scouts because with that one you could put a loop around someone and pull them up a cliff or let them down from someplace high without the rope tightening around them.

I'm from FL. I moved to the gulf coast of Texas. Both places are damn flat. About the highest place that I'd ever have to raise or lower someone from is a curb. I've NEVER needed a bowline. But I can't get out of my mind that it's a good knot to know. LMAO!

The rabbit comes out of the hole, goes around the tree and then goes back into the hole, or something like that.

masraum 08-23-2025 08:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by craigster59 (Post 12521356)
square knot
half hitch
trucker's hitch
bowline
clove hitch

and always remember, after tying you need to give it a tug and proclaim "that's not going anywhere".

fify

porsche tech 08-24-2025 03:18 AM

Anybody have one of these? Specs about anything and everything…love looking through it!

http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1756034189.jpg

About 10 illustrated pages of knots and their usage.

http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1756034278.jpg

Dpmulvan 08-24-2025 05:16 AM

For tapered leaders blood knot is the cleanest, on the water a double or triple surgeons knot is easier to tie.

VINMAN 08-24-2025 06:26 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by porsche tech (Post 12521403)
Anybody have one of these? Specs about anything and everything…love looking through it!

http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1756034189.jpg

Someone gave me one about 20 yrs ago. I was hooked. Always got the updated versions after that.

.

gregpark 08-24-2025 06:47 AM

Just like kids with their velcro shoes I've forgotten my knots because of my ratcheting straps

Scott Douglas 08-24-2025 07:49 AM

Story about the most impressive knot tying I've ever seen.

My Dad got involved with some guy who was buying a mothballed ship from the Navy. It was up in the mothball fleet up in SF area.

As we got it to a dock in SF right under one of the freeway bridges going into SF, we tossed a line to a guy drinking a cup of coffee on the dock. The line was easily 3-4" in diameter, maybe bigger. He caught the line with his free hand, and while holding the cup of coffee proceeded to toss the line up and around with the other hand. He ended up with a perfect bowline which he dropped over a cleat on the pier.

He didn't spill a drop of coffee.

KFC911 08-24-2025 09:45 AM

I use a Palomar knot to tie on hooks and lures. I had to look up the name and I tie it my own way .... but ya do gots to wet it an cinch it properly :).

And a few of the others already mentioned....

I cheated and had to ducksearch for the name too :D

KFC911 08-24-2025 09:49 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by craigster59 (Post 12521356)
Square knot
Half hitch
Trucker's hitch
Bowline
Clove hitch

And always remember, after tying you need to proclaim "That's not going anywhere".

A Bo-line ain't goin' nowhere...

Do you tie up the stern with a bow-line?

A Bolin might just go somewhere :D

How do y'all pronounce it?

3rd_gear_Ted 08-24-2025 10:46 AM

If you want to fish someone out of the water a bowline does the trick.
To get rated for sailboat rentals, you need to be able to tie that knot floating in the water.

The marriage knot will usually cost you about $300K to untie that sucker.

Synchro Joe 08-24-2025 11:45 AM

Clove Hitch
Square (or Reef) Knot
Sheet Bend
Bowline
Double Fisherman’s Knot (grapevine)

Bill Douglas 08-24-2025 11:54 AM

A trucker's hitch is a good one to know. It effectively doubles the tension on the rope.

http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1756065258.jpg

GH85Carrera 08-24-2025 12:09 PM

I did knot know that. ;)

fanaudical 08-24-2025 04:54 PM

Am not commenting on fishing knots (haven't been fishing in ages); I think I generally get by with just these:

- Two half-hitches
- Square knot
- Figure-8
- Bowline
- Taut-line

And ratchet straps for any load in the truck... :)

gwmac 08-24-2025 04:58 PM

buddy was an industrial painter, said "If you gotta trust your life to a knot make sure its a Bowline"
HI HO!

70SATMan 08-24-2025 08:32 PM

Had an uncle that knew Don. I never met him.

The only guys that were taught knots in the Nav back in the day were the undeclared SA’s that went through general shipboard school after boot or Boatswains.

I was a little jealous actually.

masraum 08-25-2025 10:23 AM

THE knot book is the Ashley Book of Knots.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Ashley_Book_of_Knots

Quote:

he Ashley Book of Knots is an encyclopedia of knots written and illustrated by the American sailor and artist Clifford W. Ashley. First published in 1944, it was the culmination of over 11 years of work. The book contains 3,857 numbered entries and approximately 7,000 illustrations.[1] The entries include knot instructions, uses, and some histories, categorized by type or function. It remains one of the most important and comprehensive books on knots.
Use as a reference

Due to its scope and wide availability, The Ashley Book of Knots has become a significant reference work in the field of knotting. The numbers Ashley assigned to each knot can be used to unambiguously identify them. This helps to identify knots despite local colloquialisms or identification changes. Citations to Ashley numbers are usually in the form: "The Constrictor Knot (ABoK #1249)", "ABoK #1249", or even simply "#1249" if the context of the reference is clear or already established.[2]

Some knots have more than one Ashley number due to having multiple uses or forms. For example, the main entry for #1249 is in the chapter on binding knots but it is also listed as #176 in a chapter on occupational knot usage.

The Ashley Book of Knots was compiled and first published before the introduction of synthetic fiber ropes, during a time when natural fiber cordage – typically twisted, laid, or braided rope – was most commonly used. The commentary on some knots may fail to address their behavior when tied with modern synthetic fiber or kernmantle style ropes.
And it's available online and downloadable in several formats (including PDF and ePub) from the Internet Archive
https://archive.org/details/TheAshleyBookOfKnots
PDF link - https://dn790008.ca.archive.org/0/items/TheAshleyBookOfKnots/the%20ashley%20book%20of%20knots.pdf

ckissick 08-25-2025 10:51 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by VINMAN (Post 12521307)
Barrel knot for connecting two ropes of the same size.

.

Another knot for joining two ropes together has the best name: the European Death Knot.

Steve Carlton 08-25-2025 11:29 AM

I prefer tying a Gordian Knot. Difficult to untie, but Alexander the Great showed us the way.

VINMAN 08-25-2025 11:31 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by gwmac (Post 12521713)
buddy was an industrial painter, said "If you gotta trust your life to a knot make sure its a Bowline"
HI HO!

We have pretty much phased out the bowline in the rope rescue world, years ago. It isn't a life safety knot. We will use it to connect a tag line on a litter or something similar., but thats about it.

.

jyl 08-25-2025 12:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by VINMAN (Post 12522010)
We have pretty much phased out the bowline in the rope rescue world, years ago. It isn't a life safety knot. We will use it to connect a tag line on a litter or something similar., but thats about it.

.

What do you use instead?

My buddy says the double figure 8 (figure 8 on a bight) with a double overhand safety knot on the tag end?

masraum 08-25-2025 02:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by VINMAN (Post 12522010)
We have pretty much phased out the bowline in the rope rescue world, years ago. It isn't a life safety knot. We will use it to connect a tag line on a litter or something similar., but thats about it.

.

Quote:

Originally Posted by jyl (Post 12522027)
What do you use instead?

Exactly my thought, you can't drop a bomb like "we haven't used the bowline as a rescue knot in years" without telling us what the replacement is.

VINMAN 08-26-2025 04:53 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by masraum (Post 12522061)
Exactly my thought, you can't drop a bomb like "we haven't used the bowline as a rescue knot in years" without telling us what the replacement is.

Lol. Sorry..

The figure 8 and it's many variations are our main go-to.
They are pretty much always our main tie-in knots. We have about five or six other different knots that are the primary ones we use, but a ton of others may come into play.

One of the issues with the bowline is security integrity, in that it can self loosen when load is removed. A figure 8 never will.

There are ways to secure a bowline a little better , one is what's called a "Yosemite finish" , which is a couple additional turns around the rope to secure it.

.

masraum 09-02-2025 07:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by VINMAN (Post 12522308)
Lol. Sorry..

The figure 8 and it's many variations are our main go-to.
They are pretty much always our main tie-in knots. We have about five or six other different knots that are the primary ones we use, but a ton of others may come into play.

One of the issues with the bowline is security integrity, in that it can self loosen when load is removed. A figure 8 never will.

There are ways to secure a bowline a little better , one is what's called a "Yosemite finish" , which is a couple additional turns around the rope to secure it.

.

So one or more of these?
http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1756871364.jpg

911_Dude 09-03-2025 08:34 AM

My top five for boat work:

-Bowline: Extremely useful loop type knot
-Cleat hitch: Most obvious sign of a boater hack if the boat is not using a proper cleat hitch
-Clove hitch: Great for hanging stuff up on a rail.
-Figure eight: Easy stopper knot
-Reef (square) knot: Tie up bundles, reef a sail, etc.
-(Bonus #6) Gasket coil: Neatly stow coils of rope.

If you can master those you can do most boat rope work without looking like a hack.

Side Note: I need that "Pocket Ref" book. Surprisingly, the cheapest place to get it is Harbor Freight of all places. On HF's website its listed under Home/Home Security/Toys/Childrens Toys/Building Toys. LOL!



.

VINMAN 09-03-2025 12:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by masraum (Post 12526269)


Yep! That's a couple of them.

.

jyl 09-04-2025 10:27 AM

The most useful knot I’ve learned since starting this thread is the Alpine Butterfly Loop (a dropper). Previously I tied droppers by tying a bight into an overhand knot - very crude and hard to untie.

I still need a fast-to-tie , hard-to-screw up bend knot.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 04:28 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.6.0
Copyright 2025 Pelican Parts, LLC - Posts may be archived for display on the Pelican Parts Website


DTO Garage Plus vBulletin Plugins by Drive Thru Online, Inc.