Pelican Parts Forums

Pelican Parts Forums (http://forums.pelicanparts.com/index.php)
-   Porsche 911 Technical Forum (http://forums.pelicanparts.com/forumdisplay.php?f=8)
-   -   Ethanol pluses and minuses (http://forums.pelicanparts.com/showthread.php?t=985504)

chrismorse 01-26-2018 04:15 PM

EFANG ethanol...
 
Here in kalifoania, alcohol free gas is very hard to find, maybe two or three places in the entire county AND, it costs $5.50 a gallon, AND, you have to sign, in blood, that this "pure" gas will NEVER, ever, on pain of death, be used n our righteously pristine highways.
A couple of years ago, I was having trouble getting my home generator started. My mechanical friend worked on the carburetor, trying to get to work, when he found the carb so badly corroded that we had to replace it.
When having my lawn mower repaired, I asked the shop manager about alcohol related damage, on which, he became quite animated, pissed off, in fact. He said that fully 60% of his work was fixing damaged fuel systems, hoses, carbs from this f'ing trash, pseudo gas.
POLITICAL, imaginary, eco-groovy trash. Now, let me tell you how I really feel......
I need another beer to evolve...

Bob Kontak 01-26-2018 04:28 PM

With respect to ethanol.

It's been around for 20+ years.

No cars have melted.

Reminds me of flat earther youtube vids reading posts.

HarryD 01-26-2018 04:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bob Kontak (Post 9902112)
With respect to ethanol.

It's been around for 20+ years.

No cars have melted.

Reminds me of flat earther youtube vids reading posts.

Bob,

Agreed. The issues can be managed. The biggest real downside is reduced gas mileage.

I think much of the reported problems are related to cars that are used infrequently.

My 1973 911 and 1970 VW Bus has had no fuel related issues under my owner ship (since 2002 for the 911 and 2013 for the Bus). They both are driven regularly with no more than 2-3 weeks between use. I use 360 (formerly Marine) Sta-bil with every fill. When I replaced the fuel sender in my VW last year, the inside of tank looked great. When my 911 top end was done last year, there was no evidence of fuel related damage as well.

bpu699 01-26-2018 04:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by HarryD (Post 9902117)
Bob,

Agreed. The issues can be managed. The biggest real downside is reduced gas mileage.

I think much of the reported problems are related to cars that are used infrequently.

My 1973 911 and 1970 VW Bus has had no fuel related issues under my owner ship (since 2002 for the 911 and 2013 for the Bus). They both are driven regularly with no more than 2-3 weeks between use. I use 360 (formerly Marine) Sta-bil with every fill. When I replaced the fuel sender in my VW last year, the inside of tank looked great. When my 911 top end was done last year, there was no evidence of fuel related damage as well.

The 30 year old fuel lines get rock hard on the inside, and the ethanol doesn't damage them. Recently replaced some on a 80s Ferrari and they looked fine. Yet, 3 year old fuel lines melted and clogged...

HarryD 01-26-2018 04:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bpu699 (Post 9902124)
The 30 year old fuel lines get rock hard on the inside, and the ethanol doesn't damage them. Recently replaced some on a 80s Ferrari and they looked fine. Yet, 3 year old fuel lines melted and clogged...

Question. The 3 yr old lines. Were they made of modern materials which are compatible with ethanol? Or were they the old school lines which are not?

Ctopher 01-26-2018 05:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by HarryD (Post 9902117)
Bob,

Agreed. The issues can be managed. The biggest real downside is reduced gas mileage.

I think much of the reported problems are related to cars that are used infrequently.

My 1973 911 and 1970 VW Bus has had no fuel related issues under my owner ship (since 2002 for the 911 and 2013 for the Bus). They both are driven regularly with no more than 2-3 weeks between use. I use 360 (formerly Marine) Sta-bil with every fill. When I replaced the fuel sender in my VW last year, the inside of tank looked great. When my 911 top end was done last year, there was no evidence of fuel related damage as well.

Your post made me think. I’m curious if my leaking fuel pump that I just replaced on my 87 kalifornia car was mainly caused by the ethanol in the fuel. It was interesting that fuel was leaking from the positive terminal, I think I’m going to disassemble tomorrow to see what the internals look like. Interesting.

Ctopher

manbridge 74 01-26-2018 05:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bpu699 (Post 9902124)
The 30 year old fuel lines get rock hard on the inside, and the ethanol doesn't damage them. Recently replaced some on a 80s Ferrari and they looked fine. Yet, 3 year old fuel lines melted and clogged...

This is so true. Somehow they found a way to make black rubber hose with way less rubber. Same with CV boots. Guys here report short service life. Mine are from 74!

Tippy 01-26-2018 05:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bob Kontak (Post 9902112)
With respect to ethanol.

It's been around for 20+ years.

No cars have melted.

Reminds me of flat earther youtube vids reading posts.

Exactly. There's so much misinformation on this thread. Sigh...

I can't wait to fully convert one day.

adias 01-26-2018 10:38 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by uwanna (Post 9901725)
That new Stabil 360 is fine, but the Marine Stabil 360 is still the best at
abating water condensation. People in the marine industry will use nothing else! It is a tad bit more expensive than the 360 you show,
but I'll gladly pay the difference.

From their website:
Marine Stabil 360
Ultimate treatment and protection against ethanol and condensation
"enhanced water removal"

Is the Marine version totally safe for our engines? Too much of a good thing?

GaryR 01-27-2018 04:05 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bill Verburg (Post 9901824)
What octane was the chip designed for? A stock '87 has 9.5 cr and called for 95RoN is US AKI 91 Unless the chip called for reduced octane then you don't want to use 87

Yep, I agree 100%.

Bill, totally off topic but came across this picture today. Date says 3/31/2006, had to be opening day at Limerock that year and about my 3-4th DE day in my newly built Dan Jacobs 911!

http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1517058328.jpg

Bill Verburg 01-27-2018 06:00 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by GaryR (Post 9902394)
Yep, I agree 100%.

Bill, totally off topic but came across this picture today. Date says 3/31/2006, had to be opening day at Limerock that year and about my 3-4th DE day in my newly built Dan Jacobs 911!

http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1517058328.jpg

here's your 1st black car, 2009


http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1517065162.jpg

adias 01-27-2018 12:57 PM

My question for those using StaBil 360 Marine - is that safe in our engines?

I checked the manufacturer's site and the dilution for the Marine product is double the dilution of the standard product:

1oz for 5 gallons of gas - for regular StaBil 360

1oz for 10 gallons of gas for StaBil 360 Marine.

The Marine product is much cheaper - about half the cost of the standard land-based product.

But... the question remains - is the Marine product advisable in our engines? Issues regarding seals and stuff.

HarryD 01-27-2018 01:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by uwanna (Post 9901725)
That new Stabil 360 is fine, but the Marine Stabil 360 is still the best at
abating water condensation. People in the marine industry will use nothing else! It is a tad bit more expensive than the 360 you show,
but I'll gladly pay the difference.

From their website:
Marine Stabil 360
Ultimate treatment and protection against ethanol and condensation
"enhanced water removal"
http://forums.pelicanparts.com/uploa...1516995643.jpg

This is the one I use.

Frosticles 01-27-2018 03:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bob Kontak (Post 9902112)
With respect to ethanol.

It's been around for 20+ years.

No cars have melted.

Reminds me of flat earther youtube vids reading posts.

I beg to differ :mad::mad:

This was a direct result of Ethanol rotting fuel lines. The car was MOT'd the day before & given a clean bill of health. Was running quality braided fuel hoses & the ethanol rotted them from the inside out within two years.

https://farm9.staticflickr.com/8498/...1c4d7501_b.jpgUntitled by Kevin Frost, on Flickr

adias 01-27-2018 03:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by HarryD (Post 9902917)
This is the one I use.

The question is, is that Marine version too much of a good thing for non-marine designed engines?

The manufacturer recommends 1oz per 10 gallons for that Marine version, whereas the standard car 360 is 1oz per 5 gallons of fuel.

I think that I will stick with the orange standard StaBil 360 ethanol treatment.

uwanna 01-27-2018 04:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by adias (Post 9903042)
The question is, is that Marine version too much of a good thing for non-marine designed engines?

The manufacturer recommends 1oz per 10 gallons for that Marine version, whereas the standard car 360 is 1oz per 5 gallons of fuel.

I think that I will stick with the orange standard StaBil 360 ethanol treatment.

I have used Marine Stabil in my 911 for many years. Started using it in my boat which is put up for seven months of the year and it preserves the fuel and especialy keeps it water free. Always cranks right up after
its seven month rest. Started using it in my 911 after the first good experience with boat storage. I can't imagine what you think could be in the Marine version that would harm anything in your car, after all boat motors and fuel systems are very close to auto internal combustion engines. In fact most smaller boats with inboard motors mostly use repurposed automobile engines. My Supra skiboat uses a Ford GT40 motor that is basically the same as the one in a high performance Mustang.

Tippy 01-27-2018 04:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Frosticles (Post 9903038)
I beg to differ :mad::mad:

This was a direct result of Ethanol rotting fuel lines. The car was MOT'd the day before & given a clean bill of health. Was running quality braided fuel hoses & the ethanol rotted them from the inside out within two years

How much ethanol?

I've ran E10 for years and nary a problem. If these rotted in 2 years, they weren't quality as you claim.

RSBob 01-27-2018 04:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by chrismorse (Post 9902106)
Here in kalifoania, alcohol free gas is very hard to find, maybe two or three places in the entire county AND, it costs $5.50 a gallon, AND, you have to sign, in blood, that this "pure" gas will NEVER, ever, on pain of death, be used n our righteously pristine highways.
A couple of years ago, I was having trouble getting my home generator started. My mechanical friend worked on the carburetor, trying to get to work, when he found the carb so badly corroded that we had to replace it.
When having my lawn mower repaired, I asked the shop manager about alcohol related damage, on which, he became quite animated, pissed off, in fact. He said that fully 60% of his work was fixing damaged fuel systems, hoses, carbs from this f'ing trash, pseudo gas.
POLITICAL, imaginary, eco-groovy trash. Now, let me tell you how I really feel......
I need another beer to evolve...

If you do your research you will find that the states in the heartland whom grow the majority of the corn, had high paid lobbyists who pushed legislation for the adoption of ethanol (corn based) fuels. It was sold to the public as a cleaner alternative to pure gasoline which is total crap since it takes far more energy to grow, harvest, transport and process corn into ethanol. The states on either coast originally bought this bill of goods until it was learned that it was making corn growers and their suppliers (read large corporations like ConAgra, Monsanto) rich. Kalifornia and other eco states originally embraced the false prophet (ethanol) but anyone who has done their homework knows that it is bad for the environment due to the environmental toll it takes, it takes more energy to produce, as well as less efficient fuel (mileage, power for most cars) and it kills older cars. As a member of the eco-groovy trash set I oppose ethanol production and only buy ethanol free for my Porsches, lawn tractor, and other gas powered tools.

adias 01-27-2018 04:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by uwanna (Post 9903064)
I have used Marine Stabil in my 911 for many years. Started using it in my boat which is put up for seven months of the year and it preserves the fuel and especialy keeps it water free. Always cranks right up after
its seven month rest. Started using it in my 911 after the first good experience with boat storage. I can't imagine what you think could be in the Marine version that would harm anything in your car, after all boat motors and fuel systems are very close to auto internal combustion engines. In fact most smaller boats with inboard motors mostly use repurposed automobile engines. My Supra skiboat uses a Ford GT40 motor that is basically the same as the one in a high performance Mustang.

The concern is engine seals.

Why is there a Marine version and a regular version? Why not just market Marine for both? Actually the Marine is cheaper as it costs basically the same $18 vs $16 but it is 1oz/10-gallons whereas the standard version is 1oz/5gallons.

uwanna 01-27-2018 04:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by adias (Post 9903099)
The concern is engine seals.

Why is there a Marine version and a regular version? Why not just market Marine for both? Actually the Marine is cheaper as it costs basically the same $18 vs $16 but it is 1oz/10-gallons whereas the standard version is 1oz/5gallons.

The Marine version does a better job at moisture abatement, which is why it is helpful in wet marine applications . If ethanol seperates from gasoline it becomes hydroscopic, absorbing water and the marine Stabil addresses that. I don't know what "seals" you are worried about. If anything it preserves any "seals" in the fuel system much as it preserves the rubber fuel hoses.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 08:03 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.6.0
Copyright 2025 Pelican Parts, LLC - Posts may be archived for display on the Pelican Parts Website


DTO Garage Plus vBulletin Plugins by Drive Thru Online, Inc.