back to a stick: choices

[cantdrv55]

Did you mean an M3 or X3? I didn't know any SUVs can come with a manual tranny.

[nostatic]

Originally posted by dmoolenaar
Holy crap an X3...you're knee is healed so quit the narcotics dude.

just another example of the man trying to keep me down...

[JeremyD]

wonder how much you could put in here:

[nostatic]

I thought about the previous version M Coupe (always loved it), but I need a back seat for hauling Calvin's friends around from time to time. I already have a 2-seater (the 911)...gotta have something vaguely practical.

[Moses]

What's your MAXIMUM budget?

[nostatic]

Originally posted by Moses
What's your MAXIMUM budget?

well if I want to blow my house downpayment savings, I can pay cash for a Caymen S

I'd really like to stay under $30K otd. I'm already upside down a few K on the GTI. But I also want to buy a car that I'm going to keep for a number of years, and I know from experience that cheaping out just costs more money down the road. In this case with the GTI, it is more a case of me expecting my leg to take longer to heal than it did, and me not realizing how much I hate not shifting while driving.

I really like hatchbacks/wagons. In fact I've never owned a sedan, although did drive the wife's A8 from time to time. But the hatch just makes hauling beach gear, bass amps, etc a lot easier.

You're trying to sell me on the 335, right?

[azasadny]

Mazdaspeed3!!!

[nostatic]

So are BMWs all that and a bag of chips? To be honest I've never driven one except for an M Coupe (which I loved). They are really common here in LA, and are often owned by wankers (at least in my neighborhood).

[JavaBrewer]

I still remember test driving a '74 2002 in Camarillio. I was blown away with how smooth and fun the car was. Of course I was 18 and my only frame of reference was my '77 Datsun p/u truck. King cab baby!

I think BMWs are all that but there are so so many of them.

[Jims5543]

Originally posted by Superman
Dismiss the front wheel drive cars now. Drive wheels belong in the rear. Porsche has never made a front wheel drive car, and probably never will. There is a reason for this.

You obviously never drove a MINI in anger.

I had the same opinion FWD is for commuter cars and REAL sports cars have RWD. Anything FWD is like a Honda and belongs getting groceries. Then I drove a MINI. I told everyone I know that I would have laughed in their face if they told me a FWD car is sporty and fun to drive before I drove a MINI.

When I tracked my MINI the poor guy in the C5 Vette was freaking out that he could not get me off his @ss around the track, he refused to give me a point by but preferred to try to kill himself trying to shake me loose. I wish I had it on video you could hear my pedaling the car trying not to rear end him in the turns and braking zones. The only advantage he had was in the straights where anyone can go fast.


Todd, I want your honest opinion of the car after you test drive it, I hope you get a salesman like me that encouraged me to drive it hard. He even took me to a empty parking lot to toss it around Autocross style.

I would look for a used CooperS maybe a 2005 you'll be way under budget and have a fun car. I am not really a fan of the Turbo model but that is my opinion. The scream of the SC is really cool.

[Gene Wilkes]

+1 on the MINI S but the Bimmers are SWEET too!

[Sarc]

Wrong coast, but no need to dip into the house fund to have some daily fun.


91 318is

90 325i

87 325i

IIRC, pkramer still has a sweet 325 that might be for sale.

[jim72911t]

Originally posted by nostatic
So are BMWs all that and a bag of chips? To be honest I've never driven one except for an M Coupe (which I loved). They are really common here in LA, and are often owned by wankers (at least in my neighborhood).

Todd, I was a lifelong BMW hater, as my first two cars were Datsun 510's, and, as a rule, I was supposed to hate them. Then, my Pop bought a used E36 325is with the sport package and a 5-speed. I drove it a few times, including once at Buttonwillow. I was hooked, and bought my E30 a couple of years later.

I have since come to the conclusion that it will be really difficult to buy any sort of passenger car that does not have a Roundel on the hood. Once you've owned one, nothing really comes close, especially VW's. They are true driver's cars, with amazing ergonomics.

I've been looking for an E36 M3 for a while now, but would be just as happy with an E46 wagon with a 5-speed and a sport package. Tough, if not impossible to find, though.

Good luck.

[KNS]

Love my '04 325i, 5 speed and Sport Package are all I wanted...

[nostatic]

I just got back from driving an '07 Cooper S. It is a very quick car when driven in anger. VERY quick. Reminds me a lot of the 911. Some oddities with torque steer (or something...not sure what), but a true go kart.

But the interior?

Worst
Ergonomics
Ever

Seriously. Garbage plastic, clown sized speedo, knobs and switches strewn everywhere that do randoms things, seat adjust inboard and obscured. I could go on and on. Complete crap. No matter how great the car drives I would never consider buying one, at least this "redesign." Maybe I'll look at a used one with the original interior.

They did have a, '04 330i with "performance package." Was black though...I can't own a black car. Probably quite a nice ride though.

[the]

Originally posted by nostatic
I just got back from driving an '07 Cooper S.

blah blah blah.

I would never consider buying one

I told ya that this morning.

[nostatic]

Originally posted by the
I told ya that this morning.

hey sometimes ya gotta find things out for yourself...

So what should i get, mom?

[cantdrv55]

Yeah, I don't like the '07 interior either. Cartoonish.

Does the next car have to have some grunt? If not, check out the Honda Fit. Nice car, gets 33 mpg city on regular gas and is only $18K or less for a 5 speed stick.

[Noah930]

Originally posted by nostatic
But the interior?

Worst
Ergonomics
Ever

Seriously. Garbage plastic, clown sized speedo, knobs and switches strewn everywhere that do randoms things, seat adjust inboard and obscured. I could go on and on. Complete crap. No matter how great the car drives I would never consider buying one, at least this "redesign." Maybe I'll look at a used one with the original interior.

Haven't been inside one of the "new" new Minis. But I didn't care for the old interior. I thought it was pretty cheap. I opened up the glovebox and thought it was going to come off in my hand. Garbage plastic, like you mention. I didn't care much for the layout, either (but that's just IMO). Fun ride, but that killed it for me in the ownership department.

[Jeff Alton]

I just drove the cooper "S" on the weekend as I too am looking for another car. Ummm, like the way it drove (escept for those stupid BMW turn signals) but the interior just plain sucks. Maybe at 37 I am way too old for the car, but it was fun.

I drove the Mazdaspeed 3 and it is fast, but it still just a fast cheap Japanese car. It is a true econobox with a big motor. Fun, but that is a lot of extra cash for a motor...

Drove a GTI with 6 speed and one with DSG. Preffered the DSG car, and the GTI had the best motor in my opinion. (not that it is worth much!)

Drove a 2002 M3, little to heavy feeling for me, but fast and a nice drive. Plus not sure it is a car I want to own when it comes off waranty.

Took a Lotus Elise out as well. Yummy, the salesman (old friend) and I were actually laughing out lound while I drove it. What a fun machine. Not sure it fits with what you need, can hardly haul the groceries with it...

Cheers